Last. Dead last. That is where the Pittsburgh region’s labor market is ranked among the country’s largest metro areas in an annual survey by The Wall Street Journal and Moody’s Analytics. Behind fellow Rust Belt cities Detroit, Buffalo and — yes — even Cleveland.
This comes after the Post-Gazette reports that Allegheny County last year had one of the nation’s steepest declines in population and the county lost 50,000 jobs in five years.
It is becoming a death spiral. A lack of workers begets a lack of jobs which begets even fewer workers and so on. After Renaissance I and II, after surviving the collapse of the steel industry, after Pittsburgh being named “America’s Most-Livable City,” it appears the “412” is on the verge of just fading away. How can this be?
It’s not for lack of potential. The “eds and meds” economic base remains strong and a natural incubator for other business growth. Housing costs are relatively low. There are no worries about water resources or hurricanes. The region was named one of the best for working remotely. It still has “major league” cultural and sports attractions.
Yes, we have an older population but not much older than Buffalo and Cleveland. Yes, we have infrastructure challenges, but multiple surveys find many other metro areas with – believe it or not – worse roads and other problems.
Some will quickly point a finger at unions, but that doesn’t wash. Union membership in the region is now only marginally higher than the national average. New York, Los Angeles, Chicago and Philadelphia have union rates as high or higher and stronger labor markets.
Read More
Yet Pittsburgh was 56th of 56 major metropolitan areas in the Wall Street Journal/Moody’s ranking. Why is every other major metropolitan area doing a better job of attracting and sustaining a new generation of residents and a new era of economic growth?
What looks to be missing is a shared sense of urgency and unity among civic and business leaders. No bold vision of what needs to be done. No rallying around a common mission, as occurred in the past. What happened to the business/education/government partnership that once made the region the envy of many other metro areas?
There are efforts aimed at these very goals but how are they working out? As football coach Bill Parcells said, “You are what your record says you are.”
The time has come for Renaissance III. Not so much a bricks-and-mortar event, like Renaissances I and II. And not just focused on Downtown. This one needs to be more about attitude, opportunity, cooperation and recruitment.
Focus on breaking down the barriers to business and job growth. For example, how can the city charge $255,000 for a zoning review and expect anyone to be enthused about developing anything? What other bureaucratic and tax policies stand in the way of new jobs and new investment? Everything should be on the table, down to paying remote workers to relocate here as other cities have done.
Be innovative in attracting outside investment and new residents. We are reminded regularly about the love for New York and that Virginia is for lovers. Who is telling people – not just tourists – they should at least like Pittsburgh a little? Engage the creative community in selling what the Pittsburgh area has to offer.
Without a new renaissance of how we think, talk and act, there is no hope in solving all the other problems the region has.
Is there anyone out there willing and able to lead the charge? I hope so. No doubt it won’t be easy, but it is necessary.
If not, we should post a sign asking the last person out of the region to turn off the lights. At least save on the electric bill.
Chet Wade is a former Post-Gazette business editor and retired vice president of corporate communications at Dominion Energy, and is now is a communications consultant and adjunct faculty member at Point Park University. He lives in Mt. Lebanon.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.