Today is Vietnam War Veterans Day. Six years old, it’s not on a lot of calendars. The app on my iPhone doesn’t list it, though it does list April Fool’s Day, to which it falls mockingly close. I believe the recognition is not only unnecessary — we already celebrate Veterans Day on November 11 — but that it is also demeaning and disingenuous.
It’s a political PR event designed to salve the conscience of the nation and another chapter in the long-term effort to rehabilitate the image of Vietnam veterans to improve recruiting. Who would join the military of a country that treats its veterans the way Vietnam vets were treated?
And in its attempt to be a panacea by including everyone who served in the military from 1955 to 1975, more than 7 million people, it diminishes the sacrifices of the estimated 850,000 living veterans who earned the Vietnam Service Medal by actually serving in Vietnam.
I am a war orphan and a Vietnam veteran, so I am all too familiar with the personal cost of wars both heroic and foolhardy. In ’67 and ‘68, I served with the Fourth Infantry Division in Vietnam. I was a combat engineer, a demolition specialist and, when I was promoted to Sergeant, I became a squad leader. There is a silver star in the center of the ribbon on my VSM representing the five combat campaigns in which I participated, including the 1968 Tet Counteroffensive.
At times we operated so deep in the triple-canopy jungle of the Central Highlands that even God would have had a hard time finding us. And in the 54 years since I came home, Vietnam has never been far away.
I was back in the States a mere six hours when I learned my first lesson about what it meant to be a Vietnam vet. I was seated on an airplane next to a young minister, who upon seeing me in my new class A uniform, with unit patches, Sergeant stripes and ribbons, asked where I had been. When I replied, “Vietnam,” he simply said, “Oh,” and did not speak to me for the remainder of the flight. Did he just not know what to say, or did he think we were all rapists and baby killers?
Read More
After that, it didn’t take long to find out just how unpopular Vietnam veterans were. On television and in film we were portrayed as loners, outcasts and psychopaths, a theme that Sylvester Stallone mined with great success in his Rambo series.
Because of that, many of us kept our service a secret. Telling someone you had fought in Vietnam was a defining moment in a relationship. Having lived through this, I cannot understand the motivation of the many people who falsely claim to have served in Vietnam.
As evidence that Vietnam War Veterans Day is an act of political sleight of hand, among the objectives of the commemoration are to highlight technology, science and medical advances made during the war and pay tribute to the wartime contributions at home by American citizens. I’m sure the authors of the bill creating the commemoration didn’t mean Agent Orange or protesters, although protests did more to bring about the end of the bloodshed than the politicians who spent months arguing about the shape of the negotiation table while men were dying.
It should also not go unnoticed that the bill was signed into law by a man who paid a doctor to falsify his medical records to avoid serving, called Vietnam Veterans “losers” and maligned arguably the war’s greatest hero, the late Senator John McCain, when he bellowed, "He's a war hero because he was captured. I like people that weren't captured." John McCain is a war hero because during five years of torture as a POW, he conducted himself with selfless bravery and honor, a model most of us could never follow.
Vietnam War Veterans Day does nothing for veterans. It doesn’t make us whole, stop the nightmares, cure the diseases caused by Agent Orange or erase the brutal images most associated with the war — the child with her clothes burned off by napalm, the bodies of the women and children massacred by U.S. soldiers in My Lai, or the helicopters evacuating people from the rooftop of the U.S. Embassy in Saigon on April 30, 1975.
I propose, therefore, that instead of Vietnam War Veterans Day we borrow from the Jewish tradition of Yom Kippur, when Jews face up to their missteps and repent for them. We could call it a day of Reflection and Commitment and hold it every November 13, the day the Vietnam War Memorial was dedicated.
As a country we need to reflect on the leadership decisions that have gotten us into fruitless wars like Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan, at great human cost. And we must commit to never making the same mistakes again.
Dolph John Armstrong, a retiree from U.S. Steel public affairs, served in Vietnam in 1967 and 1968. He lives in Mt. Lebanon (dolphjudy@gmail.com).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.