The tipping point is still again a talking point, an indefinable and so far unreachable place where Americans make it obvious they will no longer tolerate the abuses they’re absorbing from the government they themselves elected.
Are we there yet?
Dubious.
The tipping point, or if you prefer the slightly more pompous “inflection point,” is most commonly expressed in the helpless effluvium of “enough is enough,” but even after two people in Minnesota were shot dead in the street by federal agents this month, it’s still an open question as to whether enough of We The People feel enough of the tangible outrage to show that enough is enough.
A sick narrative
Even if we could swallow the sick narrative that the two fallen Americans, one a Minneapolis mother of three and the other an ICU nurse at nearby Veterans Hospital, should have known better than to protest a government immigration enforcement operation and were therefore somehow complicit in their own unfortunate killings, maybe we can wobble closer to the tipping point on the case of Liam Ramos.
Ramos apparently survived Operation Metro Surge, although no one has seen him for a week. He was detained by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security during a wave of arrests targeting, in the government’s own words, “dangerous criminal illegal aliens in Minneapolis, including murderers, rapists, gang members, perpetrators of fraud, child pedophiles, and incredibly dangerous individuals.”
And I guess Liam Ramos fits into one or more of those categories. He sure looks the part in that baby blue knitted cap with the bunny ears and his Spiderman backpack.
Liam Ramos is five.
As of midday Tuesday he was in a government detention facility in Texas, called this week by visiting immigration attorney Eric Lee “a horrible, horrible place,” where mothers mix baby formula with “putrid” water and meals contain “bugs, dirt, and debris.”
Do you know what they’d have called places like that 80 years ago? I think you do, maybe because it’s National Holocaust Remembrance Day.
Obviously, things could be worse for Liam. Ask Renee Good and Alex Pretti. At least the 5-year-old wasn’t pepper sprayed, wrestled to the frozen concrete, pummeled, and shot multiple times. They wouldn’t do that to a 5-year-old, would they?
Mr. Rogers’ response
What they would do, with zero compunction, is detain him with his father in a sweep of “dangerous criminal illegal aliens,” even though his father has no criminal record, fly him to Texas, and put him in an environment known to jack up the chances that children and juveniles will develop PTSD, depression and suicidal ideation.
A 2-year-old girl experienced much the same thing this month. U.S. Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota was able to get that girl and her father back from Texas, but there’s been no rescue yet for Liam or the other children being held at the Texas facility. On Saturday, they chanted for their freedom from the open areas of the facility, according to Lee.
Four students from one Minneapolis-area school district have been taken by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents during Operation Metro Surge according to school officials. Two were 17, one was 10, and 5-year-old Liam.
With half the country snowbound on Saturday and much of it glued to the continuing coverage of the Alex Pretti shooting, a woman interviewed on one of the cable channels invoked an image that was nearly as hard to contemplate as the news itself.
“They say they’re coming in to save us from some evil; they’re talking about our neighbors, who bake for us, who take care of us,” she said from within her hooded parka. “Alex was murdered while he was helping. I can’t stop thinking about Mr. Rogers. Mr. Rogers said ‘Look for the helpers,’ and right now, the helpers have a target on our forehead. Mr. Rogers would be here right now too, so I’m here.”
We must be awfully close to Enough Is Enough when we’re taking a spoonful of solace from the fact that Fred isn’t around to see the cruelty being aimed at our most vulnerable by our most powerful. When your definition of power is fear, as the president once told journalist Bob Woodward, the indiscriminate use of cruelty is virtually inevitable.
It’s pretty apparent no one thought to shoot out one of Renee Good’s tires as she tried to drive away from federal agents Jan. 7, just as it’s equally apparent no one thought to tase Alex Pretti as he struggled with masked Border Patrol operatives. Because there was a larger point to be made, right? Do as we say, because we might just kill you.
Bovino forgets the Constitution
It was all but confirmed over the weekend by then still Border Patrol Commander Greg Bovino, who told a press conference that Americans might wanna be careful out there.
“When politicians, community leaders, & some journalists engage in that heated rhetoric we keep talking about, when they make the choice to vilify law enforcement, calling law enforcement 'Gestapo' or using the term 'kidnapping,' that is a choice & there are actions & consequences."
As Illinois Governor JB Pritzker replied on Bluesky, “Here's the thing, Greg — free speech is still protected by the First Amendment. If you want folks to stop saying you're the secret police who are kidnapping and killing people, maybe stop acting like the secret police who are kidnapping and killing people.”
Gene Collier’s previous column was “A dark year with the Threatener-in-Chief.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.