Perhaps due to the complete absence of public anticipation, it took most of a year for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to deliver a formal update on America’s nutritional guidelines, or as the government put it, “reclaiming the food pyramid.”

Only in the America of 2026 can the people in charge of recommendations for a healthy diet find themselves compelled to present it like they’ve just raised the flag at Iwo Jima.

We don’t listen

The food pyramid became a government staple in the early ’90s, with things that were good for you at the bottom (grains) and things that were bad for you at the top (fats), with everything else in between arranged in narrowing order of nutritional benefit.

But the pyramid disappeared during the Obama administration, replaced by a circular MyPlate drawing (a pie chart, but no pie) suggesting that half your plate (your diet) should be fruits and vegetables, about a quarter of it grains, with the rest protein. A small cup represented low-fat dairy.

Advertise with us

But historically, regardless of what elementary school graphic the government chose to present a healthy diet, Americans could be relied upon to ignore it. We eat what we want, unfortunately, no matter who is staffing HHS or FDA of DGC/BCHW (Department of Good Cholesterol to Bad Cholesterol Hand-Wringing).

If you’re like me (God help ya), you might remember from health class the vague notion that there were Five Basic Food Groups, along with the nagging suspicion that they were not Fritos, Cheetos, Doritos, Tostitos, and Pizza. So not exactly MyPlate, but not unlike my plate.

Official nutritional guidelines in America have always been at odds with generational food pathologies. If you had a grandmother with a hankering for potato chip sandwiches and a favored uncle insisted there were no calories in Oreo’s or Hershey’s kisses (not naming any names), you tended to regard the food pyramid with the turned head of a surprised dog.

In Pittsburgh, you probably wondered if you were looking at the wrong side — wait, where are the French fries, coleslaw, pierogis, Primanti’s and Turner’s Tea?

If you thought the government’s nutritional guidance was irrelevant or dubious until last Wednesday, the press conference on “reclaiming the food pyramid,” didn’t do much to rectify anything.

Advertise with us

Skeptics noted, for example, that the new food pyramid is upside down. Its broad base is at the top, its point is at the bottom, looking something like the first drawing rejected by the ancient Egyptians at that first pyramid planning meeting one night about 5,000 years ago.

Why would we listen?

Upside down is so on brand for this administration that no one even bothered to point out how on-the-nose an inverted pyramid is for Health and Human Services, with its inverted vaccine policy, inverted CDC administration, and inverted logic that the Secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., needn’t have any medical or scientific training.

Kennedy did most of the talking, but the recommendations sounded as though they’d been written by the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association and/or the National Dairy Council, because right at the top of the new diet chart — meat!

Also whole milk.

The very next day, Jan. 8, McDonald’s ran a cheeseburger promotion whereby you could snag one for $1.08, supposedly because it was 1/8 on the calendar and as a reminder that one in eight Americans have worked at McDonald’s. Exclusively on the app, of course. Coincidence? Apparently.

Advertise with us

Michael Pollan, author of “The Omnivore’s Dilemma,” said in an interview with the San Francisco Standard that even as he identified some “glimmers of light,” in the new guidance, he found the meat thing a little troublesome.

Elevating meat as if we need to eat more when “we’re eating huge amounts, more than the earth can sustain, more than is good for us,” he said, “feels like a throwback to the way we ate in the ‘50s and ‘60s, when we ate lots of meat and full-fat milk and had lots of heart disease.”

He thought this idea “was more ideological than a scientific recommendation. Not to mention, if you’re interested in limiting your climate footprint, giving up beef would be the most important. It’s probably better than buying an electric vehicle.”

Yeah, could be, but an administration that’s gleefully plotting to yank oil from underneath Venezuela is clearly uninteresting in its climate footprint, to say nothing of its open hostility to electric vehicles on days that Trump is not selling Muskmobiles on the White House lawn.

We won’t listen to Dr. Oz

Last week’s HHS announcement also included a reliably unhelpful presentation by Dr. Oz on alcohol consumption, even as he said that less alcohol is better and none is best. On the other hand: No limits.

Advertise with us

“There is alcohol in these dietary guidelines, but the implication is don’t have it for breakfast, all right?” Oz said. “This should be something done in a small amount and hopefully at some kind of an event that might have alcohol at it.”

The guidelines no longer say what a small amount is, what a recommended amount is, and no longer warn of the risks of alcohol, but you’re certainly free to consume alcohol, hopefully, at “some kind of event,” such as, you know, 5 p.m.

Thank you esteemed public servants.

Gene Collier’s previous column was “Corey O’Connor’s funny first pick.”