As the credits rolled after its debut at the Toronto International Film Festival, the standing ovation for the freshly released “Nuremberg,” was said to last four minutes or more, or, put another way, significantly better than it did Sunday night at the Cranberry Cinemas hours after a Steelers loss.
It was there that the dozen or so of us sat in a vaguely respectful silence for a few minutes, no clapping, no ovation, the only standing being as a preposition for beating it to the restrooms after 2½ hours. From what I gather from the relevant film sources, the Pittsburgh reaction will be more predictive of the movie’s ultimate place in the history of films about history.
A monumental challenge
“Nuremberg,” made a modest $11 million after its first three weekends, apparently getting the absolute minimal boost from the fact that it was 80 years ago this month that the United States and World War II allies France, England, and Russia brought to trial the leaders of Nazi Germany who hadn’t already killed themselves. It was a monumentally intricate legal challenge purposed to achieve international justice for monumentally historical evil.
Already being dismissed as “award bait,” by some industry observers, “Nuremberg,” clearly hopes to gain some relevance (and Oscar buzz) from the advancing specter of current events, and when the mayor elect of New York calls the American president a fascist only to have the president invite him to do it again in the Oval Office, well, let’s just say the climate might be favorable.
“Nuremberg,” which stars Russell Crowe as Hermann Göring, the Nazi war criminal and father of the Gestapo, and Rami Malek as the U.S. Army psychiatrist Douglas Kelley, charged with evaluating the mental status of the remaining Nazi hierarchy, is by my own estimate a beautifully presented work by James Vanderbilt, effectively paced even across 148 minutes, and worth the ticket just for the explosive confrontation in Göring’s cell at Nuremberg.
Not since Meryl Streep (as Sister Beauvier) and Philip Seymour Hoffman (as Father Flynn) met in the center of the ring in 2008’s “Doubt” have I come across such an arresting collision of acting heavyweights.
If “Nuremberg” manages to snag an Oscar nomination or two, no one should be surprised if that scene is responsible. But it’s not likely at this point it will approach for Academy Award splendor Hollywood’s first attempt at capturing the global emotion of the Nuremberg trials.
“Judgment at Nuremberg,” came out in 1961, just 15 years after the trials ended, and in stretching to almost three hours told almost as much about the history of Hollywood as the history of Germany.
Easily found today on demand, it’s a virtual museum of film iconography, as there are not many places you can see Marlene Dietrich sing to Spencer Tracy. If that’s not enough, it’s also got Burt Lancaster, Richard Widmark, Montgomery Clift, Maximilian Schell, the very definitely not in Kansas anymore Judy Garland, and even William Shatner.
History’s most painful pages
Clift, always the visage of a spooked cat on film, is positively iridescent as the mentally deficient German peasant Rudolph Petersen, sterilized by the Nazis and destined only to be tortured on the stand by the young defense attorney (Schell) determined to prove his mental limitations.
“Judgment at Nuremberg,” earned 11 Oscar nominations. Schell won Best Actor, and the writer Abby Mann, who grew up in East Pittsburgh, won for Best Adapted Screenplay. The New York Times called it powerful and persuasive and Variety said, “With the most painful pages of modern history as its bitter basis, Abby Mann's intelligent, thought-provoking screenplay is a grim reminder of man's responsibility to denounce grave evils of which he is aware.”
It is the nature and the expanse of this awareness that drives the dark subtext of both films. Though “Judgment at Nuremberg” was the first vehicle to display for a mass audience grotesque footage of Nazi concentration camps taken by liberating American and British troops, “Nuremberg” uses those shattering images as a turning point in the courtroom drama.
Widmark, who plays the lead prosecutor in the 1961 film, explains the challenge faced by nations aspiring to justice in the starkest possible terms at the outset. “Judgment at Nuremberg,” is a fictionalized story with fictionalized characters, but the real trials included prosecutions for judges at the top of the German legal system.
Judges, Widmark says, “distorted, perverted, and destroyed the law in Germany,” and were responsible for “murder, atrocities, torture,” and “the most malignant, most calculated, most devastating crimes in the history of all mankind.”
The defense deflects
How much everyday Germans knew about what was happening in the camps is the subject of intense narrative construction in both films, and the real effort of the defense to deflect responsibility, not only away from the Nazi’s but to multiple entities across the globe, gets plenty of oxygen in both as well.
Russia, the Vatican, American industrialists, and even Churchill get name checked as complicit at various plot points, and as Schell nears the crescendo of his summation he yells, “the whole world is guilty.”
As part of his close, the defense attorney asks whether the German judges should have carried out orders or be seen as traitors. Sounds vaguely topical, does it not?
Gene Collier’s previous column was “The humane way to talk about economics.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.