This week brought Pittsburgh’s annual genuflection to the memory of the Mazeroski homer, accentuated by the reflexive if still inexplicable significance the media attaches to anniversaries divisible by 5.

It was 65 years ago Tuesday that an instantaneously legendary second baseman launched a baseball into Oakland’s autumn sunshine to lift the plucky Pirates past the dynastic Yankees in the World Series, an indelible and some would say unequaled moment in the city’s history.

“I don’t think anything approached that ’60 World Series,” Jim Gelston was telling me the other day. “I don’t even think the Steelers’ Super Bowl games, all great thrills, approached it. People my age would tell you that the apex of sports thrills in Pittsburgh was that ’60 World Series.”

I told you.

Advertise with us

Baseball memories

But this isn’t really about that; it’s more about the way baseball plays in the memory and the ways those memories orient and help define the people who carry them through the generations.

Miles deep in the metaphorical footnotes from Game 7 in 1960, for example, lies the doggedly relevant factoid that Maz’s homer ended a 35-year drought of World Series championships for Pittsburgh, doggedly relevant because 35 years without one is, as Gelston put it, “small potatoes compared to now.”

Now the Pirates have completed 46 years of trophy-free baseball, maybe you’ve heard, and some were actually rooting for a Mariners-Brewers World Series this week to put Bob Nutting’s franchise in the dimmest comparative light possible. OK maybe just me, but still.

The Brewers would put another small market team in a tournament Nutting can’t even sniff, and a World Series that included the Mariners, which has never happened, would leave Pittsburgh as the longest abandoned Series venue anywhere.

Mr. Gelston and I have been sharing laments on a broad range of topics for what feels like decades. He’s a South Hills guy who migrated north to Bradford after grad school and is now retired at 81. His reliable correspondence reminded not only that Tuesday was notable Pittsburgh baseballversary, but that Thursday was the 100th anniversary of the Pirates’ victory in the 1925 World Series.

Advertise with us

Generational memories

He wasn’t alive and, no, I didn’t cover it, but this is where our theme emerges: He still has a memory of it through his father, as well as the larger framework of baseball memory to include his grandfather.

“My grandfather was big on Honus Wagner, my father’s guy was KiKi Cuyler, and as a kid I was on the original Frank Thomas,” he remembered for me. “My dad always had a far-away look on his face when he reminisced about the 1925 World Series, especially Cuyler’s two-out double in the eighth inning of Game 7.”

Blocks away, Pitt Stadium had opened weeks before the Series and Pittsburghers were suddenly traversing the Allegheny on the new 40th Street Bridge. America had half as many humans as it does today, and one of them was conspiring to obtain the result of Game 7 between the Pirates and the Washington Senators.

All the Pirates had to do for the championship was beat Walter Johnson, the Big Train himself. (He was 6-1, 200, plenty big enough to be the Big Train in those days).

One particle of the hyper-granular oral history of Oct. 15, 1925, put through a century of generational baseball memory, goes like this:

Advertise with us

“My father was a 1929 graduate of South Hills High School, but it seems he was truant from school that day,” Gelston said. “That family was poor, so he didn’t have the money to go to games, but for the seventh game of the World Series he went through the Liberty Tubes to a drug store in downtown Pittsburgh and they had some kind of readout, almost like a digital thing going left to right above the door or something.”

Changing memories

Three miles to the east, a cast of contemporary All-Stars and future Hall of Famers were negotiating a settlement to the game’s ultimate issue. Aside from the Big Train, there was Muddy Ruel, Bucky Harris, Goose Goslin, Kiki Cuyler, Pie Traynor, and Stuffy McInnis in an era when you seemingly couldn’t play the game without a killer nickname.

Unlike 35 years later, conditions were acutely sub-optimal that fall. Game 7 started in the rain, descended into the muck, and Goslin, in left field for the Senators, claimed that by the late innings, he couldn’t see the infield for the fog.

But he was most assuredly watching a Train wreck. The Pirates peppered Johnson for 15 hits including eight doubles, according to baseballreference.com, but the game was still tied 7-7 when Cuyler came up in the eighth. With two out and two on, Cuyler laced a double to right and the Pirates went on to win 9-7.

It went into the memories in different ways through different portals and maybe it comes out a different way every time, but it’s fresh 100-year-old baseball magic.

Gene Collier’s previous column was “When defending the Constitution means you hate America.”