On the working list of 1,000 or so things I’ve put off for too long, I must now add my sternly worded letter to the producers of Jeopardy!

It wasn’t intended to complain, although they should definitely lose that stupid exclamation point, a pathetic attempt at hipness that makes me almost wish they’d stuck with Merv Griffin’s original title: “What’s the Question?”

As it happens, Jeopardy! returns next week for the 42nd season of the current iteration, so my letter outlining suggestions and concerns will be too late to have any impact. Alas, a game show that’s somehow won 45 Emmy Awards without any input from me must proceed on its own instincts.

First, the praise

Mind you, I generally revere the show that for generations has rewarded the thirst for knowledge, an American gathering place where facts are facts and the truth wins every single night. My letter would have carried the best of intentions, but as they say way too often, life gets in the way. The summer comes and goes, you end up watching too much (any) Pirates baseball, your country slides almost blindly into fascism, and you wind up getting distracted.

Advertise with us

Before Jeopardy! ended its 41st season, fascism was clearly in someone’s consciousness at Jeopardy! headquarters. In fact, in an episode that aired in February, host Ken Jennings actually said to contestant Ray Lalonde, “Ray, I hate to ask, but how confident are you about fascism?”

Ken only asked because FASCISM was the first category that night in Double Jeopardy. “First unfortunately we have Fascism,” Ken quipped, then introduced the five other categories.

“Ray, what appeals to you?" Ken asked to start the round.

“Fascism,” Ray deadpanned.

“Sorry to hear that,” said the host.

Advertise with us

Ray did well in the category, where he found the Daily Double, which was when Ken asked mischievously about his confidence.

Jennings, who once won this game a record 74 nights in a row, was the perfect person to succeed the late Alex Trebek, whose earnest dignity defined the job for 37 seasons. When Trebek died near the end of 2020, the show staged a months-long on-air audition to succeed him that featured everyone from failed Pennsylvania Senate candidate Dr. Oz to eventual Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers.

You may insert your own joke right here, which I presume is something like, “Ken, I’ll take Costly Turnovers for $13.65 million.”

Now the criticism

Anyhoo, the crux of my letter was going to address Jeopardy!’s only obvious weakness, the tedious segment after the first commercial break when we’re somehow compelled to get to know our contestants whether we want to or not.

Dear Producers, the difference between this segment and dead air is purely hypothetical. It’s too short for anything remotely interesting to emerge, particularly in the event that the most interesting thing about the contestants is that they’re on Jeopardy! Poor Amy Schneider, who won 40 games in a row in 2022, told media outlets she was almost relieved to lose so that she wouldn’t have to produce any more personal anecdotes.

Advertise with us

The fact is, this segment will never improve unless the contestants can either borrow anecdotes or simply make them up. I certainly wouldn’t advocate for anything further from Robert F. Kennedy Jr., for example, but if a Jeopardy! contestant could tell Ken that he once dumped a bear carcass in Central Park and staged it to look like a bike accident, well, now we’re getting somewhere.

Or, as I said, just make it up.

Ken: Two-time champion Scott Williams, I hear you got into a bit of a kerfuffle after last night’s show.

Scott: That’s right, Ken, I was in this bar watching the Real Housewives when this dude starts in on me about missing two questions in the High Finance category on Monday. “Remind me not to ask this jamoke for advice on my money,” he says to his buddy. “This guy wouldn’t know a contingent deferred sales charge from a power purchase agreement.” So I stabbed him.

Ken: You stabbed him? Were police called?

Advertise with us

Scott: No, turns out I jabbed the knife right into his belt buckle and so no skin was broken, but he and his friend just ran outta there, so I finished watching Real Housewives of Orange County and that Kelly is such a witch!

Ken: Scott, you have the next selection.

And more criticisms

So that was my only major criticism, but had I actually gotten around to writing, I’d have included the following complaints as well:

Contestants should not be given warnings about failure to respond in the form of a question, which seems the whole point of a show originally titled, “What’s the Question?” Ken’s vibe is a gentle warning for contestants during the first round, and only to penalize in Double Jeopardy. No more Mr. Nice Guy on that.

Written responses in Final Jeopardy must include a question mark at the end, for obvious reasons. A show that insists on proper pronunciations must also require correct spelling and punctuation. C’mon, Jeopardy! You’re Jeopardy!! This ain’t The Match Game.

Advertise with us

Also, one of the three nightly contestants must be selected from the studio audience. Yeah you, c’mon down; let’s see if you know anything.

Finally, a gentle reminder for Ken, whose voice can be a bit too dramatic in identifying an incorrect response. When he says, “Nooo,” I sometimes hear, “you dope!”

Gene Collier’s previous column was “Before praying at the Pentagon, locate the exit.”