Like just about every time they put “Coach and Mrs. Jagoff” on stage this month, the Sunday performance was sold out at the Iron Horse Theatre in Ambridge, which is little short of a miracle even for what we like to call an intimate space.
All the way back to ancient Greece, intimate is the theatrical term for small.
New plays from new playwrights generally expire without making it to a home printer. Most of the others burn up upon entry to the harsh competitive atmosphere of public art. The few that somehow get produced all but glisten with unrefined faults, most fatal, but there’s a certain wonder about new play when the new playwright is 77 years old.
“I’m a bit of a perfectionist, which is not practical or healthy,” Bruce Zewe was telling me after a recent show. “But I got some good advice from a friend of mine: Just enjoy the experience. Don’t expect perfection. At this point, the play is no longer yours in a sense; it’s theirs.”
He gestured toward an appreciative, emptying house, and it’s true: “Coach and Mrs. Jagoff” now belongs to the audience, to the players and the producers and the crew, but mostly it belongs to us in a way that feels so Western Pennsylvania authentic. If Bruce’s first play has its faults, all of them somehow get folded into a stunning symmetry that seems possible only in this place and in these moments.
A lifetime in the making
The Coach and the Jagoff at hand are Jake and Lynn Sebastian (played by Eric Vollmer and Amy Sikora Baschnagel), an affluent couple in a battered rust belt river town. He’s coaching the high school football team that defends the town’s fading self-image and she’s watching in abject horror as he leans harder and harder into alcohol to buttress his flagging confidence.
Where else should this happen, could this happen, than at the Iron Horse, the theater founded by North Side native and drama teacher London Cain, who turned a former church turned former bar turned former church again into rehearsal space for his students and then into a gem of a community theater? Who else should this happen to, could this happen to, than a retired communications pro who long thought the cultural touchstones of his earliest memories had dramatic potential?
“When I was 8 years old, our house was maybe 500 feet from the football field,” Zewe said. “I’d be going to bed and I’d hear the high school band playing and I was drawn to it; the players were my idols when I was a boy. I still go. My friend and I go to an occasional Pine-Richland game and some Aliquippa games.”
Just as everyone in the Brooklyn of the mid-20th century grew up in the shadow of Ebbets Field, everyone around here seems to have lived in the outer glow of Friday night lights, and it was almost inescapable that Zewe’s first play, most of eight decades in the making, would be positioned in those lights and the shadows they throw.
Coaching politics
High school football, upon us all anew this very week, drives the narrative for “Coach and Mrs. Jagoff,” but Zewe’s script has provided plenty of accommodation for its attendant pathologies: dependence, disillusionment, community jealousies, treachery, elitist nonsense.
“Every place, every town, every neighborhood thinks it’s friendlier than it really is,” says one exasperated citizen in the second act. “Everybody thinks he’s friendlier than he really is. Attila the Hun probably thought he was friendly.”
The writing process for Zewe started some seven years ago as he was reading Mike White’s coverage in the Post-Gazette about the circumstances at work in the dismissal of a successful local coach.
As we headed toward Friday’s kickoffs, the sometimes twisted dynamics of our grandest traditions remain at full display. Twenty-four new coaches will stalk WPIAL sidelines this week, and in the previous eight seasons, 20-24 coaching changes have been the annual norm. Of the 116 schools, Mike was telling me Monday, 60 have had at least one new coach since the end of the 2022 season.
Metastasizing pressures and raw politics hang from the coach’s neck sure as his whistle. Most of them work ridiculous family-straining hours and even the winningest among them are never more than five school board votes from dismissal.
“I feel like I’m evaporating,” Coach Sebastian says on the dark side of Zewe’s script, “disappearing in plain sight.”
Last chance
Among the strengths of the writing here is the playwright’s comfort with dialogue, for which he credits, naturally, Warren Buffett.
“In my career, writing for organizations, I always wrote in a conversational way,” he said. “Warren Buffett of Berkshire Hathaway always writes this well-regarded annually report letter, and he when he sits down to write the letter, he thinks he’s talking to his aunt, who is bright but doesn’t know a lot about business. He tries to tell her what’s happened at Berkshire Hathaway as simply and clearly as possible.”
Warren Buffett’s aunt couldn’t make any performances of “Coach and Mrs. Jagoff,” which earns reliable standing O’s for a script with well-drawn characters that moves nimbly under the direction of Dannette Pemberton.
There are two shows remaining this weekend, but tickets are scarce. The origin story continues everywhere Friday night, in every town up and down all three rivers.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “Fear and loathing at the Library of Congress.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.