The Memorial Day weekend has long claimed an extra-comfortable place on the American calendar, a four-day affair with beer, baseball, hot dogs, and rock ‘n’ roll (see WDVE’s annual Memorial Day 500 countdown), even as its original intent didn’t figure into anyone’s version of a celebration.

In a country where George Washington has become best known for the blowout mattress sales around his birthday, things tend to get twisted a bit over time, so the fact that we’ve turned honoring the profound sacrifices of our war dead into an extended party seems like the natural evolution of things.

Who is the greatest?

The holiday or some version of it has been around for most of two centuries, but for some reason I most associate it with the heroism of what Tom Brokaw called the Greatest Generation, the people who grew up during The Depression and won World War II, then went about their largely unassuming lives having enabled the very freedoms succeeding generations take for granted.

Brokaw wasn’t trying to start any arguments, because what defines greatness is clearly a matter of ancient discussion. And like everything else, the definition of our loftiest standards tends to get muddier and muddier.

Advertise with us

Do we accept greatness on its own authority, as from Muhammad Ali: “I Am The Greatest”? No disrespect to The Greatest, but that’s a little too efficient. Must we acquiesce to greatness when it occasionally becomes a title? If Alexander the Great, Constantine the Great, Peter the Great, and Vladimir the Great could somehow have met, how would they sort that out?

Those fellas weren’t contemporaries, but they might have found the solution in the example of Socrates, whom you can bet will turn up at the near the top of the list when Rolling Stone finally gets around to ranking the greatest thinkers of all-time. No argument with proponents of Aristotle, Plato, Archimedes, Pythagoras, et al, but the story goes that when someone told Socrates that an Oracle had declared him the wisest man in Athens, he immediately set out to prove otherwise, rather than, you know, schedule a parade.

The Socratic method in this case was basically, according to the ancient internet, Socrates walking around asking people what was truly worthwhile in this life, on the theory that anyone who knew would obviously be wiser than he. After questioning everyone he could find (he must have been a real pain in those days), Socrates found that not only could no one answer, they all instead pretended to know something they certainly did not.

Thus he realized that maybe he was the wisest man because he was prepared to admit his own ignorance. It was this self-awareness — that he knew how much he didn’t know – that made him wiser than the rest.

The source of greatness

This would suggest an ancient linkage between greatness and something with which it’s rarely associated in this century — humility, which I started thinking about too much last week when, on Stevie Wonder’s 75th birthday, Elton John said he thought “Songs in the Key of Life” was the greatest album ever.

Advertise with us

You heard me.

Why would Elton John, whose musical bona fides are so capacious, feel the need to further validate Stevie Wonder, whose are every bit as substantial if not more (I’ll leave it to the Memorial Day 500 to sort that out)? That’s humility, at least by some definition.

Why would Paul McCartney, whose songwriting aptitudes are a force beyond nature, claim the best song ever written is the Beach Boys’ “God Only Knows,” by Brian Wilson? In some way, it’s humility.

Why would John Coltrane, whose saxophone produced sounds some of his greatest contemporaries could barely imagine, say of Stan Getz, “Let’s face it. We’d all sound like him if he we could”? Before long, you get to suspect that true greatness depends to an extent on genuine humility.

Not talking here about music, although it sure sounds that way. Frame it with any discipline you want.

Advertise with us

General Ulysses S. Grant, whose greatness as military strategist and leader got a thick share of the credit for winning the Civil War, was known to sleep on the ground with his troops and wear similar uniforms. Grant’s humility, historians have noted, stood out among his worthy aspects.

This is greatness

In the Greatest Generation’s most desperate hours, the eve of D-Day, Dwight Eisenhower’s humble conscience required him to claim responsibility for failure before it even approached.

“Our landings in the Cherbourg-Havre area have failed to gain a satisfactory foothold and I have withdrawn the troops,” Eisenhower wrote, in case things went sideways. “My decision to attack at this time and place was based upon the best information available. The troops, the air and the Navy did all that bravery and devotion to duty could do. If any blame or fault attaches to the attempt it is mine alone.”

If that somehow doesn’t define greatness, it’s very much what it looks like.

Gene Collier previous column was “Elon Musk, backstage clown, is leaving the stage.”