The sinister growl of Elon Musk’s government chainsaw may have moved backstage amid the twisted cirque de soleil that is Trump 2.0, but the damage continues, day by dreaded day.
As American institutions splinter and crack, the most depressing impulses of the new administration are the ones that makes us demonstrably dumber by the minute.
Attacks on institutions of higher learning might provide some visceral satisfaction for those with a range of resentments toward academia, some of them appropriate, but this ready-fire-aim application is doing outsized real-life damage.
The war on science
The war on science, just one sordid theater in the war on smart, if you will, means many things to many constituencies, but you don’t have to be a microbiologist or a molecular geneticist to understand what it means to either one.
“I find it terrifying, the possibility that I won’t have money and I won’t have a job,” said Abigail Matela, a faculty instructor in microbiology and molecular genetics at Pitt’s School of Medicine. “I’m trying just to ignore it, to pretend we’re going to continue to get the funding.”
If Pitt had a School of Converting Abject Terror into Nervous Laughter, Abigail might have tenure.
I spoke with her the other day about the jeopardy she and a project she’s been coordinating since 2018 now live with hour to hour. That’s called EvolvingSTEM, a program that brings the techniques of scientific experimentation into high schools, particularly Pittsburgh’s public schools, where students often lack the materials needed to even imagine themselves part of the next generation of scientists.
“We also have a summer teacher training where we bring them into our lab,” she said. “We produce a curriculum funded by NSF (the National Science Foundation, then we have another grant from the NIH (National Institutes of Health) that allows us to go into the classrooms with the teachers we’ve trained. We prepare all the material they need to put science in the hands of kids, kids who’ve never done these things.”
As the Post-Gazette’s Kris Mamula reported last week, Pitt lost a $1 million grant that helped 1,500 middle school kids with computer literacy, the sixth NSF grant terminated at the university since April 18. Pitt’s lost $3 million in funding all told. So far.
Trump’s budget request would chainsaw the NSF’s $9 billion budget in half, just as the foundation told NPR that nearly 350 previously approved programs had been terminated for “not being aligned with priorities.” That was on top of more than 1,000 awards eliminated earlier last month.
The computer scientist Trump installed to run the NSF abruptly quit without saying why, probably because it’s too obvious.
Backward irony
The shredding of science programs in general and STEM projects in particular, those buttressing science, technology, engineering, and mathematics, can only result in a society and workforce tangibly stupider in all those things.
Vaughn Cooper, the Pitt microbiology professor who pioneered the EvolvingSTEM model at New Hampshire more than a decade ago, noted a backward irony of torpedoing initiatives that have worked for decades.
“For years there’s been a major initiative to make the next generation of scientists look like the rest of society, and that kind of language has been baked into these programs dating back to the late ‘80s,” he said. “This program won the SEPA Award, that’s the Science Education Partnership Award, and it’s grown from the late ‘80s more under Republican Administrations because it’s engaged in relatively underfunded red states.
“It’s unusual that this sort of educational outreach is centered in a medical school but it works because our curriculum is motivated by and targeted toward showing biomedical relevance and studying microbiology so that kids can see how they can be part of the next generation of biomedical research, and we’ve grown that locally.”
The good news, as Prof. Cooper delivers it, is that “none of us have been cut yet,” but the bad news is that none of the NIH awardees have received the next allotment of funds. It’s business as usual if by that you mean business at cliff’s edge.
Thousands of scientists across the country have fallen away. Public service and public health careers are being chainsawed in the bud.
“The grants were paying for a large portion or all of our salaries,” said Colton Siatkowski, a young research technician with EvolvingSTEM. “I just graduated with my bachelor’s and now it’s saddening to see it’s not appreciated. Just aside from us, it’s not being able to bring these experiences into the classroom.”
Today’s future victims
Until Jan. 20, research was progressing apace on how cancer spreads, how to build predictive models on infectious disease, how to mitigate the pain of wounded soldiers, etc., according to Alan Garber, president of Harvard University, which is suing the Trump administration.
“As opportunities to reduce the risk of multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer’s disease, and Parkinson’s disease are on the horizon, the government is slamming on the brakes,” he wrote in a letter to the Harvard Community.
“The victims will be future patients and their loved ones who will suffer the heartbreak of illnesses that might have been prevented or treated more effectively. Indiscriminately slashing medical, scientific, and technological research undermines the nation’s ability to save American lives, foster American success, and maintain America’s position as a global leader in innovation.”
And to think our Golden Age has just begun.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “Arresting judges is only the beginning.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.