There are monuments to it in seven states; there’s even a museum in Arkansas, but America’s greatest maritime disaster never dominated one news cycle, not even the one in which it happened 160 years ago this week.
A vanishingly small percentage of people walking around today have ever heard of the Sultana, a massive side-wheel steamboat built in Cincinnati to run cotton and newspapers and people, among other things, up and down the Mississippi River. Not long after midnight on April 27, 1865, three of its four onboard boilers exploded and it sank in a fireball seven miles north of Memphis, killing almost as many people as a far more famous ship on a subsequent April night in the North Atlantic.
The Sultana officially carried a human capacity of 376, not counting a crew of 85, but the death toll went into our mostly forgotten history as almost 1,200, with bodies turning up months later as far south as Vicksburg. At one point on its final trip north, 2,127 souls were estimated to be aboard the doomed steamer.
Two problems
While the story of the Titanic (death toll just north of 1,500) continues to thrive in international multi-media narratives more than 100 years after gashing itself against an iceberg, the Sultana story, a craven parable of raw corruption with overtones in national politics, barely made it out of the 1860s.
We can always blame the media for this kind of uncomfortable dichotomy, but the journalists of the time faced two indomitable problems. First, disseminating the news was something of an ordeal in the moment, what with contemporary delivery systems that included newspapers carried by steamship and, only a few years earlier, the pony express. Not exactly like getting your news with a couple of clicks.
The other major problem was the endemic difficulty of editorial judgment, because April was not exactly a slow news month in 1865. On the 9th, Robert E. Lee met Ulysses S. Grant at Appomattox Court House and surrendered, essentially ending a fairly nettlesome matter called the Civil War.
On the 14th, Abraham Lincoln was shot in the head by Confederate sympathizer and noted thespian John Wilkes Booth. On the 15th, Lincoln died, necessitating an avalanche of follow-up stories that would include the first use of Booth’s new media label: actor-turned-assassin.
On the 26th, America’s most wanted fugitive was trapped by authorities in a Virginia barn, where Booth was shot and killed by Union cavalryman Boston Corbett. On the 27th, a steamboat going down in the Mississippi seemed like small potatoes, and has pretty much stayed that way.
Singular horror
To be sure, books have been written, documentaries done, movies made, and songs sung about the Sultana, but the Sultana has never been sustained by any cultural oxygen outside of websites like LostinHistory.com. It’s not been for lack of a compelling story line.
The Sultana was engaged in its regular shuttles — St. Louis to New Orleans and then back upriver — when that week in Vicksburg its captain, James Mason, was approached by a Union officer, Captain Reuben Hatch. With the Civil War ended, Hatch was in charge of thousands of freshly released Union prisoners of war.
According to the research published in the Naval Institute Press, the government was paying $2.75 per enlisted man and $8 per officer to any steamboat captain who’d take a group of them north toward their homes in Michigan, Indiana, Kentucky, Tennessee, and West Virginia.
A deal with kickbacks between Hatch and Mason gets explained in most historical accounts as the reason behind the gross overcrowding of the Sultana, although whether putting two thousand people on a boat designed for less than 500 caused the boilers to overheat and explode became an unsettled debate.
There is no disagreement on the singular horror of that night or of the unspeakable suffering of the passengers, some of whom had survived the exposure, starvation, and disease of rat-infested Andersonville prison, only to be released in hopeful spirits onto the decks of the Sultana.
Many were killed by the force of the multiple explosions, many more as the ship’s twin smokestacks toppled, one into the hole blown by the explosions, the other onto the overcrowded upper deck. Other passengers were catapulted into a dark river of death.
Responsibility evaded
Mason was among the dead, but Hatch evaded all responsibility as the question of who actually overcrowded the Sultana was adjudicated and overturned and re-adjudicated to no clear result. Hatch avoided three subpoenas in that process, and historians would note that his checkered military career was aided or ignored by politicians up to and included even Grant and Lincoln.
Corruption to the highest levels of government, suffering below. Can you imagine?
Gene Collier’s previous column was “The Save Act won't save democracy.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.