To the deeply-felt satisfaction of his political enemies, Barack Obama has precious little to say anymore, so it was nothing less than jarring when one of his current observations came out of a the clear blue sky on Bluesky.
If you don’t know, Bluesky is the social media platform absorbing much of the exodus from X, formerly Twitter, where the growl from Elon Musk’s chainsaw and the attendant destruction of what used to be America has chased a lot of users into the streets.
Obama took off for the Sky with his 130 million followers and finally posted something a week ago today, which happened to be a key anniversary: “Figured I’d hop on here today for the 15th anniversary of the Affordable Care Act,” wrote the 44th president of the United States. “With everything going on right now, it’s easy to feel like the regular folks can’t make a difference — but the ACA is a reminder that change is possible when we fight for progress.”
With everything going on right now, this is what you’ve got, a little pat on the back for your quiet self?
A feckless tradition
Not terribly helpful when “everything going on,” includes the rise of American kakistocracy, but Obama’s tepid comments were fully within the mysterious parameters of an unwritten ex-presidents’ code of conduct. This country comes by its traditions in weird and often meandering ways, but this thing about former presidents staying out of the public square, it says here, is among our most feckless.
How do figures like Obama, Bill Clinton, George Bush, and now Joe Biden, who understand better than most living Americans both the depths of our politics and the promise of our democracy, simply take a seat in the stands or leave the stadium altogether when it’s check out time at the White House?
Bush left Washington when he was 63. Obama only 55. Clinton 54. Biden looked 111, but the point is, there’s little benefit for the country’s civic discourse and its general direction if its most skilled politicians, and sometimes its greatest orators and most serious brains, effectively drop off the earth.
To be fair, Obama has campaigned for Democrats and piped up fitfully when the moment moved him. He weighed in on the looming Wisconsin Supreme Court race and he did call Trump and Musk’s dismantling of USAID “a profound foreign policy mistake,” but his thoughts have generally been absent from public forums.
In that fashion, he’s maintained what’s been called the “dignified silence,” of past presidents, which has somehow become the one of our hallowed “norms.”
Be like Donald
History says it wasn’t always thus, that Theodore Roosevelt spent part of his post-presidency hounding President Taft, that Herbert Hoover loved going on the radio to blister FDR, and more recently, that Jimmy Carter had no qualms about criticizing Ronald Reagan on foreign policy.
But mostly, beginning with Eisenhower, the George W. Bush model of near-absolute silence is considered a model to be revered. “It’s out of respect for the office,” a former Bush aide recently told The Hill, “it’s just not his style.”
That sounds like two different things, but it might be time to revisit the ostensible ground rules when the twisted post-norms strategy of ignoring rules, laws, and even the Constitution has become a path to the presidency.
The undisputed heavyweight champion of criticizing the next president is Donald Trump (2020-24), whose personal hatred of Biden continues up to the minute. Even after re-gaining the White House, Trump used his second Inaugural Address to cast the Biden presidency as a “horrible betrayal,” with Biden sitting right there.
In his first address to a joint session of Congress, six weeks later, Trump mentioned Biden another 16 times. As pathologies go, this one is fairly simple: Biden beat him in 2020, and Trump is congenitally unable to accept losing (see Jan. 6).
Biden’s only response came Jan. 20: “We’re leaving the office. We’re not leaving the fight.” He then promptly left the fight.
Out of the game
It’s perfectly logical that Biden’s silence about “everything going on,” and as well Obama’s and Clinton’s and Bush’s, is purely the by-product of fear, that from which is derived most of Trump’s power. As one political observer has noted, “What are they going to say? Please don’t send me to prison for life?”
Kurt Bardella, the Democratic strategist and communications adviser, this month told The Guardian that the ex-presidents should “Stop playing ‘I don’t want to step on anyone’s toes or prematurely step out of line.’ We don’t have time for that crap. Get in the game or don’t talk ever again. If you don’t have anything to say now, while this is going on before our very eyes, I don’t want to hear from you ever again.”
Sounds about right.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “For Bob Nutting, ‘play ball!’ doesn’t mean play to win.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.