As few of us need to be reminded, American politics has always stalked the Oscars, but this coming Sunday presents a historic difference by at least one fairly fraught dimension: Up until now, no one has ever walked in to the Academy Awards ceremony with a puncher’s chance to win Best Actor for playing the sitting President of the United States.

Sebastian Stan has that exact puncher’s chance, a term I first stumbled over in the ridiculously opulent and still reliably seedy casino boom that was the Atlantic City of the mid-’80s, when menacing entrepreneurs like Donald Trump and Don King conjoined to stage highly conspicuous prize fights in and around Trump’s doomed boardwalk empire.

A puncher’s chance was a slim opening for the underdog fighter to land the one lucky punch that would split the pre-fight wisdom like a lightning bolt. A puncher’s chance was virtually no chance, but all kinds of boxing people gave all kinds of fighters at least that courtesy.

The scion and his mentor

The Trump that gets put on screen in “The Apprentice” is that 1980s version, the one-dimensional real estate scion mentored by the infamous attorney Roy Cohn, whose legal scruples were few and moral principles fewer.

Advertise with us

Stan is the seriously capable, 42-year-old Romanian-American actor best known to fans of Marvel Universe vehicles, but his version of Trump is memorable and layered enough that it will apparently take a championship performance from someone like Oscar winner Adrien Brody (“The Brutalist”) or Timothee Chalamet (“A Complete Unknown”) to beat him. The other Best Actor nominees are Ray Fiennes (“Conclave”), and Colman Domingo (“Sing Sing”).

That Sebastian Stan’s name will be read as one of the finalists during Oscar’s climactic moments is an artistic triumph by itself, for as America has come to understand, Trump’s character is not exactly a maze of nuance. Psychically he’s essentially a sword, all blade, little hilt. Stan engages in no attempt to make Trump even remotely complicated, only to respond to the toxically flawed, uniquely American forces that positioned him for history.

“The only way we can learn is through empathy,” Stan explained to Associated Press film critic Jake Coyle last October. “We have to protect empathy and continue to nourish it. And I think one way of nourishing empathy is showing what its exact opposite can be.”

Though “The Apprentice” debuted at Cannes last May and was a nominee for the festival’s Palme d’Or, its path to American theaters was perilous and underfunded. There were major distribution issues. Trump lawyers threatened it early and remained engaged.

When the trailer finally dropped on Sept. 10, the Night of They’re Eating The Dogs!, the Trump campaign screeched that “The Apprentice” was “election interference by Hollywood elites,” among other not-so-kind things.

Advertise with us

Mendacity and lies

The film wound up being an international co-production of Canada, Denmark, Ireland, and the United States, three of which Trump has talked about taking over all or part of, but just one of which is stupid enough to have let it happen.

Written by Gabriel Sherman, who wrote the book on Fox News founder Roger Ailes (“The Loudest Voice in the Room,” later a Showtime series), “The Apprentice” looks destined for that congested cinematic off ramp marked Good, Not Great. The solid majority of reviews have been favorable.

Most of the reviewers’ florid compliments have accrued to Stan, whose puncher’s chance shouldn’t be any better than those of co-star Jeremy Strong. His rendering of Roy Cohn is definitive and unlikely to be surpassed.

The lifetime of dirty legal tricks and screw-you personal strategies Strong embodies here got itself described as “uncanny in its accuracy” by no less decorated a dirty trickster than Roger Stone, the former Trump stooge (seven felonies) who got his presidential pardon on Dec. 23, 2020.

Cohn’s “defiance of reality, and his denial of reality, to me are the signature components of what he instilled in (Trump), his star pupil,” Strong told Coyle for that same AP story. “It’s a legacy of mendacity and lies and denialism and the aggressive pursuit of winning as the only moral measure. Cohn didn’t believe in showing vulnerability. He was only interested in projecting strength, and I find that very tragic.”

Advertise with us

In Sherman’s script, Stan has the heavier lift, as it’s difficult for an actor of even outsized aptitude to play a character with no soul, but Strong’s Cohn is as richly colored as can be. A gay man who died from AIDS in 1987, Cohn schools Trump on a carnivorous social gospel, that America is a nation of men, not laws: to hell with what people think of you, none of that matters except winning.

But Trump is not, as Strong described, a star pupil. He’s a feckless student, as ever, and forgets the part where Cohn tells him “You have to be willing to do anything for America, to safeguard Democracy.”

Cohn’s cardinal rules

In our Oscars history, only Daniel Day-Lewis has ever taken the Best Actor statuette for portraying a POTUS, that with his 2013 depiction of Lincoln. Seven others including Anthony Hopkins twice, from Raymond Massey in 1941 to Sam Rockwell in 2019, all lost on the big night.

If Sebastian Stan joins that list on Sunday, he can be forgiven for briefly reflecting on the third of Cohn’s cardinal rules for Trump: 1) Attack, attack, attack. 2) Deny everything, admit nothing. 3) Never admit defeat.

Gene Collier’s last column was “Project 2025 and the ‘stable’ family.”