For its final performance, in the role of the fresh corpse of a dearly departed community touchstone, Comtra Theater somehow delivered still again. You know, like always.
On a brutish Pittsburgh morning effectively set-designed for bad news, the old barn on Cranberry’s Route 19 hunched in the plunging wind chills and blackening slush, its FOR LEASE sign barely noticeable off the northbound shoulder, a Christmas wreath and an American flag standing watch near the entrance, a small white-on-black message board saying nothing, and thus everything.
A collective wound
Gone after four decades of hyper resilient against-all-odds community theater, and, toward the end, comedy and drag shows (mostly because they carried no rehearsal costs), Comtra’s exit from the region’s cultural landscape opened a wound in its collective alumni everywhere.
“I’m mourning the loss of my playground,” said Trey Compton, the New York-based director who grew up in Pittsburgh (North Allegheny, Pace University). “I played ‘Oliver’ there in fourth grade. I was in ‘The Secret Garden’ there. It was the place I used to sharpen my sword, to risk and fail, to risk and fail again and again, and to risk and succeed.”
For the audience, the essential, tangible, muscular charm of the place was exactly that — the risk. ‘Godspell’ is obviously in good hands on a CLO stage downtown or in New York, but a flying make-your-own-costumes leap at it on a Friday night across the highway from Monticello’s pizza is another proposition.
From its 135 seats, Comtra Theater was, well nuts. Deliciously nuts. It was theater in the round, with actors entering and exiting from four portals that could feel like eight. It sometimes had live music with players perched randomly near the rafters.
You could see a show carried by a fearless 9-year old co-starring with a 50-year-old actuary bored-out-of-his-9-to-5-mind waiting for this very moment, with a budding 15-year-old ingénue in between.
The gyroscopic risk/failure ratio was so baked into the cake that every scene that reasonably clicked and every song generally executed by people who were practically in your lap was exhilarating. But don’t be misled, there were plenty of productions at Comtra over the years that glistened curtain to curtain, many done with all-volunteer casts and crews that were earnest, talented, joyous.
A big heart
“To me the big thing there was just the opportunity to entertain at low cost; I mean low cost emotionally, low cost literally, and low cost artistically,” said Compton.
“You could do ‘Seussical’ the way you wanted and the only people who cared were there to support you regardless. You do it where you’re not making choices with a noose around your neck. Risk taking is disappearing from community theater and even regional theater. Many of these kinds of places are one or two bad choices away from closing the doors.”
Comtra was the creation of Marie Teets, who bought the barn in the early ’80s when Cranberry was very much barn-centric and chicken-house adjacent, not all Dress Barn and Pottery Barn. Marie was its heart, soul, inspiration, actress, manager, 24/7 Mother Superior until her death from cancer in 2013. Her son, Cecil, and General Manager Becky Ruff have run the place energetically since despite galloping production costs right through COVID.
“After Marie died we had to do a massive renovation because of a water line break, but we’d finally gotten into a good pattern when COVID shut us down, then my dad died from COVID and that really petrified me,” Becky said the other day.
“It’s heartbreaking. We had to be self-sustaining and if we didn’t sell every seat, we were in the red. Tickets for the last show were $25, but if people came in whose kids were in the show and they couldn’t afford it, I’d say, ‘You can help us pass our programs and that’ll be for your tickets.’ My heart was bigger than my brain I guess.”
A community loss
As Comtra vanishes into the commercial sprawl of southern Butler County, a lot more is lost than its reliable theatrics. Places that lose a community theater lose a part of the vitality and potential of the community itself.
“Comtra gifted us an incredible creative experience,” said the actress Lara Hayhurst on the phone from New York. “It’s not the kind of opportunity you get very often. Once when we were doing ‘Rocky Horror,’ I remember it was just a gaggle of Comtra regulars with such a Judy Garland hey-we’re-putting-on-a-show feel, except in fishnets, and once after a long dress rehearsal we were allowed to have a sleepover,” she said.
“We brought snacks and candy and sleeping bags and we were camping out under the tables in the dressing room instead of so many other horrific things we could have gotten into at that age. It gave us a place to play and be silly kids and create art.”
Gene Collier’s previous column was “Jimmy Carter was a man who’d go into a nuclear reactor.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.