With the holidays upon us like an unblocked linebacker, it almost seems there’s a palpable desire to actually enjoy them. Whether that’s because the country is emotionally drained from a brutal years-long election campaign or just the joyful hope that the president-elect won’t appoint the Flintstones to run the National History Museum, welp, hard to say.

In either case, Thanksgiving is blessedly at hand, and even though this is a holiday celebrated in places from the Philippines to Liberia, nowhere are its traditions, origin story, and contemporary customs as chaotic or inexplicable as in the USA.

You’re not surprised.

All you need to know

Basically, all you need to know about the 21st century American Thanksgiving is that it probably wouldn’t exist without football, and even then, it has merely achieved a kind of convivial co-existence.

Advertise with us

When news stories about the local food banks are barely keeping pace with commercials reminding us that Shaboozey is doing the halftime show at Lions vs. Bears on Thursday, it’s clear there’s a power struggle in the all-that-we-hold dear division.

At the start of this long wet American slip-and-slide was the original argument of what Thanksgiving is, never mind what it should be. Though it was clearly some kind of harvest festival with a backstory in Europe, the American narrative gets traced to New England or Virginia, or Texas or Florida, depending on your weighing of the scholarship.

Even at that, Abraham Lincoln himself couldn’t get Thanksgiving any sustainable buzz by signing an 1863 proclamation designating it an official holiday.

It wasn’t until Yale edged Princeton at Hoboken, 2-0 on Thanksgiving in 1876, that college football teams as far west as Missouri got it in their heads that football as part of the holiday was an American natural.

Not everyone was pleased. “No longer is the day one of thanksgiving to the Giver of all good; the kicker is now the king and the people bow down to him,” griped the New York Herald in 1893. “Thanksgiving was meant to be a festival to God for mercies given.”

Advertise with us

At that time, football on Thanksgiving was still the prerogative of academic institutions and small community high schools that were beginning a uniquely prideful American tapestry. Besides which, God’s mercies were widely assumed to include your kicker not shanking a winning field goal try in the fourth quarter.

Similar assumptions had long been endemic to the holiday. Turkey, for example, probably became the main course for the day’s elaborate meal only because of Sarah Josepha Hale, a New Hampshire poet who founded a ladies magazine that predated even the Lincoln Administration.

In her mag, she published Thanksgiving recipes that leaned heavily on the Pilgrims narrative, which she assumed included turkey from the abundance of wild turkeys in New England. Though less practical, it could just as easily have been lamb, since one of Hale’s early poems was the nursery rhyme, “Mary had a little lamb.”

The Lions and the Bears

Regardless of what anyone put on the table, the modern Thanksgiving would not be brought to a full cultural boil until the NFL got in on the act in the 20th century. A league that never met a quaint American tradition in couldn’t monetize out of all proportion wasn’t going to wait around forever while colleges and high schools dominated the holiday football space.

It started with Lions v. Bears in the mid ‘30s, and a Lions home game became a Thanksgiving Day staple. In the ‘60s, the fledgling Dallas Cowboys got in on the act and made Thanksgiving a doubleheader. Now there’s a third NFL game on Thanksgiving, in case you can remember anyone wondering if two was too many.

Advertise with us

This actually was a thing – families being just a bit off stride while part of it was putting a labor-intensive gastronomical feast on the table as another part was all wrapped up in Cowboys-Seahawks.

Do you even remember what happened last Thanksgiving? Let me help. Do you remember Dolly Parton dressed like a Cowboys cheerleader?

Today, as Thanksgiving traditionally ends with a third NFL game that bleeds toward Black Friday, the league does not relent. Last year it mounted its first Black Friday matchup, featuring the New York Jets, a team that can traditionally get even Jets fans out of the house. This year it’s the Chiefs and Raiders on Black Friday, a tradition that will no doubt persist.

Look, if you want your holidays solemn and quiet and – what’s that word? – holy, well, at least there’s Christmas.

HAHAHAHAHAHA!

Advertise with us

A Steelers Christmas

The Steelers will host the Chiefs Christmas Day at 1 p.m and ours is not to wonder why. It’s not because Christmas happened to fall on an NFL Sunday. It’s because the NFL identified even your minding-it’s-own-business Christmas on a Wednesday just a little too marketable.

Once upon a time, when there arose no such clatter as the Super Bowl, the NFL Championship game was played in late December. In 1960, Christmas was on a Sunday, so the Eagles and Packers played the title game on Monday. Because you don’t play on Christmas. That would be crazy.

Gene Collier’s previous column was “Oh no! Not the wintry mix!”.