Strictly from the standpoint of electoral gamesmanship, the selection of a vice presidential running mate doesn’t actually have to make sense, and rarely does.

Now that Kamala Harris has anointed Tim Walz as hers, presidential politics returns to a well-worn historical groove, counterintuitive as it might appear: Donald Trump chose a senator from a state he’ll win anyway, Ohio, and Harris chose a governor from a state she’ll win anyway, Minnesota, so yeah, on we go.

In one sense, both choices merely emphasize how unimportant the second spot on the ticket is to the voters. As I mentioned recently on this page, MAGA loyalists would still vote for Trump if Michelle Obama were his running mate, just as the Never Trump movement would still back Harris all the way if she’d named Eric Trump to the No. 2 spot.

The far more compelling requirement for the task at hand is finding someone you can campaign with comfortably and effectively, and ostensibly govern with, beginning Jan. 20, 2025.

Advertise with us

Fresh irritant

Through whatever vetting process the Harris campaign was able to implement in less than three weeks, Walz emerged triumphantly Tuesday morning and immediately set the cable news record for most nationally televised photographs holding a piglet, at least at the top of the news cycle, and maybe ever, by a guy few people outside of Minnesota had even heard of two weeks ago.

But Donald Trump had heard of Tim Walz, and had already identified him as a fresh irritant, something I doubt very much was lost on the Harris campaign.

“Why did Fox News put up Tim Walz, Governor of Minnesota, where I am leading? They make me fight battles that I shouldn’t have to fight!” Trump posted two weeks ago on Truth Social.

Walz had told Fox’s daytime hosts that Republicans are stuck with Trump: “He’s yours, you’ve got him, welcome to it.”

What’s way more irritating to MAGA’s favorite felon are the implications of Harris’s first political decision at the top of the ticket. That she chose Walz over both Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania and Mark Kelly of Arizona indicates that her view of the electoral map is different from what most of the punditry is pushing.

Advertise with us

Confident choice

Harris surely recognizes that Pennsylvania and Arizona are two of the seven battleground states (with Nevada, Georgia, North Carolina, Michigan and Wisconsin) that will tip the 2024 election, and that Arizona has the further distinction of being a border state, the border most of the Republican energy is spent screaming about, just not legislating about. She just doesn’t think that she needs either the Arizona senator or the Pennsylvania governor at her side to win in either place.

That calculus, not so much Tim Walz holding various piglets, is the big story here.

If Harris is right, Trump is going to need a new panic button, because the Tim Walz irritant is nothing compared to the prospect of losing in either of those places, especially Pennsylvania.

If Harris is wrong and ends up losing Pennsylvania by a gnat’s eyelash, as a famous calculator used to say, she’ll be accused of the worst political miscalculation in American history, particularly given the stakes.

Shapiro was in many circles considered the optimal choice, rising star of the party and popular consensus-building governor of a swing state, all that stuff, but he wasn’t 100% palatable with younger voters activated by the Israel-Hamas conflict or with voters who would consider a Black woman with a Jewish running mate as three strikes.

Advertise with us

Walz might be bringing similar political chops to Harris’s table, but in denying Shapiro, she passed on an expert communicator who always knows the right rhetorical play in the right moment.

Almost immediately after Harris tabbed Walz, Shapiro called him an “exceptionally strong choice,” adding, “over the next 90 days, I look forward to traveling all across the Commonwealth to unite Pennsylvania behind Kamala Harris' campaign to defeat Donald Trump.”

Moderate champion

I thought Harris would be naming Kelly this week, because she pretty much couldn’t go wrong with a former Navy pilot and astronaut who could speak to the border issue and whose wife, former Arizona Congresswoman Gabby Gifford, survived a 2012 assassination attempt and inspires Kelly’s passion for gun legislation.

None of that is to say that Walz won’t prove highly useful in this 2024 stretch drive. It’s going to be pretty difficult for his opponents to paint a mid-American military guy who coached football and taught high schoolers as an extreme radical left lunatic, but there’s never been an up Trump couldn’t call down.

Walz served six terms in Congress and has been Minnesota’s governor since 2019, where his legislative achievements have focused on helping school kids, veterans and families with medical leave. His biggest impact was likely in reproductive rights, for which Minnesota offers comprehensive protections that overturned nearly every restriction enacted by previous Republican administrations.

Advertise with us

In post-Dobbs America, abortion rights have been a winner just about every time this issue has gone on a state ballot. Tim Walz’s name alongside Kamala Harris’s might not have been a lot more complicated than that.

Gene Collier’s previous column was “To vote or not, that's Trump question?”