Sixty years ago this Friday, the unspeakable blowback of violence that greeted the civil rights movement hit its repugnant climax on a dark road outside Philadelphia, Mississippi.
Pulled from their Ford Fairlane station wagon after a convoy of policemen and Klansmen (some of whom were both) chased them down on Highway 492, three young activists who’d been helping register Blacks to vote were shot dead, driven to a farm south of town, and buried 15 feet deep in an earthen dam.
It took the FBI more than six weeks to find the bodies, and took the feds three years to charge 18 conspirators, eight of whom served modest sentences. It took 41 years, until 2005, before Mississippi authorities finally convicted Edgar Ray Killen of three counts of manslaughter. He died in prison in 2018.
Incomplete justice
“It’s not, obviously, complete justice,” Jerry Mitchell was telling me on the phone from Mississippi this week. “The families had a great desire for society to say, ‘Hey, this was wrong,’ but it’s incomplete justice.”
Much of the incomplete, delayed, denied, deconstructed justice that finally emerged from that awful American era would not exist at all if it weren’t for Mitchell, whose indefatigable investigative reporting brought dozens of dead civil rights cases back to life throughout the South beginning in the mid ‘80s.
Byron De La Beckwith, who shot NAACP field agent Medgar Evers dead in his Jackson, Mississippi, driveway in 1963; Sam Bowers, who was behind the firebombing that killed activist Vernon Dahmer in 1966; Bobby Cherry, the Klansman behind the 1963 Birmingham Church bombing that killed four girls; and Killen, who plotted to kill Michael Schwerner, Andrew Goodman, and James Chaney late on the night of June 21, 1964, all went to prison in no small part because of Mitchell’s reportage.
Read More
Much of it was pulled together in “Race Against Time,” the richly-detailed 2020 book about re-opened murder cases from that time, but something Mitchell wrote in the epilogue struck me again only recently. “I have long thought of the work that journalists and authorities have undertaken as a pursuit of justice,” he wrote. “But the more time I’ve spent on these cases, the more I’ve come to believe that they are just as much a pursuit of memory.”
Anyone old enough to have even the memory of a memory of the summer of 1964 struggles as much with the impact and feel of convulsive national news stories as with the details of quotidian existence in the era.
A lost narrative
On the afternoon of June 21, 1964, which was Fathers’ Day, I was watching a baseball game on television at my grandmother’s house, something I remember only because Jim Bunning was pitching a perfect game for the Phillies against the Mets. Four nights earlier, on Wednesday of that week, the Rolling Stones had appeared at West View Park’s Danceland, which still seems, frankly, next to impossible.
But around 5 o’clock on Sunday, three civil rights workers were pulled over for speeding by Neshoba County Deputy Sheriff Cecil Price, who took them to the jail in Philadelphia and let them stew for five hours until their murderers got into position. They were released shortly after 10 and started driving toward Meridian. They did not get there.
The national outrage that boiled up over the fate of Schwerner, Goodman, and Chaney got written into history as the decisive impetus for the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and eventually the Voting Rights act of 1965. But resistance to integration is surely in the wind again, not just within the American progeny of Mississippi’s worst klaverns, but in authorities from state legislatures to the Supreme Court, which seems ever ready to curtail voting rights given even minimal political cover.
Even as America observes Juneteenth, celebrating the freeing of slaves a century prior to 1964, this 2024 America can feel like it’s completely lost the narrative on the race issue.
“When I interviewed Beckwith (who was convicted in 1994), no one viewed him as anything other than a radical, as crazy, not one of us,” Mitchell said this week. “It’s amazing to me how some of the things he supported have become a lot more mainstream. So now, Beckwith’s (extreme segregationist) views have become a lot more mainstream. That his views would not be viewed the same way now kind of says something.
“It’s frightening. You would think we’d all be willing to stand up against racism, but apparently not anymore.”
Not all against racism
Mitchell, now 65, still stands against oppression and injustice wherever he can find it, as head of the Mississippi Center for Investigative Journalism. His storehouse of awards includes a MacArthur Foundation genius grant, and he’s a frequent speaker at colleges and universities nationwide.
In the summer of 2005, he spoke at Queens College in a moment he remembers as “a wild juxtaposition.” Queens College once counted among its students Andrew Goodman, who rode in that Fairlane. A few weeks later, Killen, his murderer, was finally convicted.
It was June 21.
Gene Collier is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and on X @genecollier. His previous column was “Clarence Thomas forgets too easily.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.