Sixty years ago this Fri­day, the un­speak­able blow­back of vi­o­lence that greeted the civil rights move­ment hit its re­pug­nant cli­max on a dark road out­side Phil­a­del­phia, Mis­sis­sippi.

Pulled from their Ford Fair­lane sta­tion wagon af­ter a con­voy of po­lice­men and Klans­men (some of whom were both) chased them down on High­way 492, three young ac­tiv­ists who’d been help­ing reg­is­ter Blacks to vote were shot dead, driven to a farm south of town, and bur­ied 15 feet deep in an earthen dam.

It took the FBI more than six weeks to find the bod­ies, and took the feds three years to charge 18 con­spir­a­tors, eight of whom served mod­est sen­tences. It took 41 years, un­til 2005, be­fore Mis­sis­sippi au­thor­i­ties fi­nally con­victed Ed­gar Ray Kil­len of three counts of man­slaugh­ter. He died in prison in 2018.

In­com­plete justice

“It’s not, ob­vi­ously, com­plete justice,” Jerry Mitch­ell was tell­ing me on the phone from Mis­sis­sippi this week. “The fam­i­lies had a great de­sire for so­ci­ety to say, ‘Hey, this was wrong,’ but it’s in­com­plete justice.”

Advertise with us

Much of the in­com­plete, de­layed, de­nied, de­con­structed justice that fi­nally emerged from that aw­ful Amer­i­can era would not ex­ist at all if it weren’t for Mitch­ell, whose in­de­fat­i­ga­ble in­ves­ti­ga­tive re­port­ing brought doz­ens of dead civil rights cases back to life through­out the South be­gin­ning in the mid ‘80s.

By­ron De La Beck­with, who shot NAACP field agent Med­gar Evers dead in his Jack­son, Mis­sis­sippi, drive­way in 1963; Sam Bow­ers, who was be­hind the fire­bomb­ing that killed ac­tiv­ist Ver­non Dah­mer in 1966; Bobby Cherry, the Klans­man be­hind the 1963 Birming­ham Church bomb­ing that killed four girls; and Kil­len, who plot­ted to kill Mi­chael Sch­w­erner, An­drew Good­man, and James Chaney late on the night of June 21, 1964, all went to prison in no small part be­cause of Mitch­ell’s re­port­age.

Much of it was pulled to­gether in “Race Against Time,” the richly-de­tailed 2020 book about re-opened mur­der cases from that time, but some­thing Mitch­ell wrote in the ep­i­logue struck me again only re­cently. “I have long thought of the work that jour­nal­ists and au­thor­i­ties have un­der­taken as a pur­suit of justice,” he wrote. “But the more time I’ve spent on these cases, the more I’ve come to be­lieve that they are just as much a pur­suit of mem­ory.”

Any­one old enough to have even the mem­ory of a mem­ory of the sum­mer of 1964 strug­gles as much with the im­pact and feel of con­vul­sive na­tional news sto­ries as with the de­tails of quo­tid­ian ex­is­tence in the era.

A lost nar­ra­tive

On the af­ter­noon of June 21, 1964, which was Fathers’ Day, I was watch­ing a base­ball game on tele­vi­sion at my grand­mother’s house, some­thing I re­mem­ber only be­cause Jim Bun­ning was pitch­ing a per­fect game for the Phill­ies against the Mets. Four nights ear­lier, on Wed­nes­day of that week, the Roll­ing Stones had ap­peared at West View Park’s Dan­celand, which still seems, frankly, next to im­pos­sible.

Advertise with us

But around 5 o’clock on Sun­day, three civil rights work­ers were pulled over for speed­ing by Neshoba County Dep­uty Sher­iff Ce­cil Price, who took them to the jail in Phil­a­del­phia and let them stew for five hours un­til their mur­der­ers got into po­si­tion. They were re­leased shortly af­ter 10 and started driv­ing to­ward Me­rid­ian. They did not get there.

The na­tional out­rage that boiled up over the fate of Sch­w­erner, Good­man, and Chaney got writ­ten into his­tory as the de­ci­sive im­pe­tus for the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and even­tu­ally the Vot­ing Rights act of 1965. But re­sis­tance to in­te­gra­tion is surely in the wind again, not just within the Amer­i­can prog­eny of Mis­sis­sippi’s worst kla­v­erns, but in au­thor­i­ties from state leg­is­la­tures to the Supreme Court, which seems ever ready to cur­tail vot­ing rights given even min­i­mal po­lit­i­cal cover.

Even as Amer­ica ob­serves June­teenth, cel­e­brat­ing the free­ing of slaves a cen­tury prior to 1964, this 2024 Amer­ica can feel like it’s com­pletely lost the nar­ra­tive on the race is­sue.

“When I in­ter­viewed Beck­with (who was con­victed in 1994), no one viewed him as any­thing other than a rad­i­cal, as crazy, not one of us,” Mitch­ell said this week. “It’s amaz­ing to me how some of the things he sup­ported have be­come a lot more main­stream. So now, Beck­with’s (ex­treme seg­re­ga­tion­ist) views have be­come a lot more main­stream. That his views would not be viewed the same way now kind of says some­thing.

“It’s fright­en­ing. You would think we’d all be will­ing to stand up against rac­ism, but ap­par­ently not any­more.”

Advertise with us

Not all against rac­ism

Mitch­ell, now 65, still stands against op­pres­sion and in­justice wher­ever he can find it, as head of the Mis­sis­sippi Center for In­ves­ti­ga­tive Jour­nal­ism. His store­house of awards in­cludes a MacArthur Foun­da­tion ge­nius grant, and he’s a fre­quent speaker at col­leges and uni­ver­sities na­tion­wide.

In the sum­mer of 2005, he spoke at Queens Col­lege in a mo­ment he re­mem­bers as “a wild jux­ta­po­si­tion.” Queens Col­lege once counted among its stu­dents An­drew Good­man, who rode in that Fair­lane. A few weeks later, Kil­len, his mur­derer, was fi­nally con­victed.

It was June 21.

Gene Col­lier is a col­um­nist for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and on X @genecol­lier. His previous column was “Clarence Thomas forgets too easily.”