As has been noted with appropriate disgust, the world’s worst Phillies fan had his name in the papers again this week, but not for any of the transgressions you’d typically expect.

Plenty are the hypotheticals that would trigger a mudslide of public criticism for someone of that particular subset of the baseball mad, an observation offered with love as it includes multiple generations of my own family.

Samuel Alito, however, fits no one’s handy stereotype of a Phillies fan. Yes, he’s attended the club’s fantasy camp. Yes, he’s been spotted in pricier seats at some of their recent postseason games. And yes, the club’s mascot, the incomparable Phanatic, even turned up at a function welcoming Alito to his new job some years ago, but that’s where things kind of went sideways.

Blame the wife defense

Sam’s new job was Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, thank you George W. Bush, a perch in the American power structure so high you can rip away half a century of reproductive rights if you just put your mind to it. You can even write the opinion.

Advertise with us

This week, Sam was in the news again for the wrong reasons, not that there are many right ones. When you’re a Supreme Court justice, you’re supposed to be an umpire, and it’s almost never good when the umpire’s name gets in the paper.

So why does the New York Times have this story about the Alitos flying an upside-down flag at their home in Virginia in the days following the Jan. 6 insurrection? Can’t be good. The stars and stripes carried upside down was staple among those who attacked the Capitol that day, so the number of plausible innocent explanations for why a Supreme Court justice is supporting an attempted overthrow of American democracy were not exactly numerous, Clarence Thomas notwithstanding.

Alito should have just claimed operator problems: “I guess I just put the rope through the wrong holes and, you know, it was a cold day, and I didn’t even look at it when I pulled it up there!”

But no. Like anyone with no political agenda whatsoever, he went on Fox News, and then wound up blaming his wife, which Sam should realize must be officially scored as two errors on the same play.

Recusal refusal

The supposed spark for all this was some story about a neighbor flying another flag with a profane taunt at the defeated Trump that upset Sam’s wife because it was visible to kids awaiting the school bus, never mind that others recalled that Virginia schools were remote in 2021 and that nobody was waiting for any school bus, but it’s ok because this is a Supreme Court justice who obviously knows, based on settled case law, that if a neighbor expresses an unpleasant sentiment via that pesky First Amendment, you should immediately demonstrate support for overthrowing the government.

Advertise with us

As they say in Philadelphia: BOOOOOOOO!

But somehow this story faded to nothing in a matter of days, with Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Dick Durbin telling reporters Monday “I don’t think there’s much to be gained with a hearing at this point. I think he should recuse himself from cases involving Trump and his administration.”

Oh I’m sure he will. Just like he surely recused himself from the Jan. 6 trial that would have been completed already had not the Supreme Court taken up this preposterous Trump claim that he’s immune from prosecution. Just like Clarence Thomas I’m sure planned to recuse because his wife Ginni was neck deep in the effort to overturn the 2020 election.

Donald Trump will appear on Jeopardy Masters before any of his Supreme Court allies do anything to upset him. They’ve positioned themselves as he has, above the fray, above established ethical standards, and, like their subpoena-ignoring sugar daddies Leonard Leo and Harlan Crow, above the law.

Justice for sale (or trade)

Should you think that malignant posture isn’t metastasizing, I’ll remind you that Trump just finished a fifth week in a Manhattan court room where he violated a criminal gag order at least 10 times (and had his GOP flunkies violate it 10 more) and never got closer to a jail cell than a golf course.

Advertise with us

But don’t worry, 45 House Democrats have just crafted a sternly worded letter they plan to send to the house with the upside-down flag.

Ooooh!

They’ve also got a Court Reform Task Force in the works. As you know from your history, nothing derails a lawless fascist movement quicker than newly formed task force.

The Supreme Court has dug itself into a contemptible hole so deep it needs to be changed in every possible way — ethics reform, term limits, roster expansion — but these are serious ideas commonly trafficked by serious people. In America, this is the age of unserious people doing serious damage.

At a Phillies game last weekend, a truck pulled up outside the ballpark carrying a banner listing Alito’s sins and suggesting he be traded to the Braves.

Advertise with us

Would that it were that simple.

Gene Collier is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette; gcollier@post-gazette.com and @genecollier. His previous column was “The late, great Hannibal Lecter comes to America.”