What with the planet ac­cel­er­at­ing its seem­ingly in­al­terable de­scent into mad­ness, the rel­a­tively ob­scure le­gal set­tle­ment of a years-long ar­gu­ment in mad­ness-prone Flor­ida this week didn’t get the no­tice it might have.

Based on the terms of the agree­ment, it looks like the gov­er­nor, the flail­ing pres­i­den­tial pre­tender Ron DeSan­tis, along with his flun­kies in the Flor­ida Depart­ment of Health, have been ly­ing about COVID statis­tics since at least June of 2021.

Owning their own lies

Now they’re re­quired to ef­fec­tively own their lies, and fork over $152,250 in le­gal fees to the Flor­ida Center for Govern­ment Ac­count­abil­ity and for­mer state rep­re­sen­ta­tive Car­los Guillermo Smith, who filed suit two years ago.

Advertise with us

“The Depart­ment lied about the ex­is­tence of these pub­lic records in court and did ev­ery­thing to re­strict in­for­ma­tion and down­play the threat of COVID even while the Delta vari­ant ripped through Flor­ida — a de­ci­sion that cost many lives,” said Rep. Smith in a state­ment.

Prior to the ig­ni­tion of the Delta vari­ant that sum­mer, Flor­ida’s health de­part­ment rou­tinely fur­nished the pub­lic with de­tailed in­for­ma­tion on a daily ba­sis. But with the num­ber of cases mul­ti­ply­ing across the state and the gov­er­nor de­clar­ing “Flor­ida’s open for busi­ness!” the Depart­ment changed the way it was re­port­ing data to the Centers for Dis­ease Con­trol.

The new method made it ap­pear the vi­rus was in­stead de­clin­ing just as DeSan­tis was run­ning for a sec­ond term for gov­er­nor and keep­ing no se­crets about his White House am­bi­tions.

Rep. Smith vs. the State of Florida 

When Rep. Smith asked the state for de­tailed COVID info for Orange County, the long ar­gu­ment that en­sued went es­sen­tially like this:

Advertise with us

Smith: I need info on con­firmed COVID cases in Orange County by age, sex, eth­nic­ity, and race, and I need the vac­ci­na­tion rate.

The Depart­ment: That’s con­fi­den­tial.

Smith: No it’s not.

The Depart­ment: Yes it is, and it’s not sub­ject to pub­lic dis­clo­sure.

Smith: No it’s not and yes it is.

Advertise with us

The Depart­ment: Yuh-huh and nuh-uh.

Smith: I’ll sue to get it.

The Depart­ment: Knock your­self out.

Smith: Ok, the Court says you’ve got to ex­plain why you’re re­strict­ing this data.

The Depart­ment: What data?

Advertise with us

Smith: The COVID data.

The Depart­ment: It doesn’t ex­ist.

Smith: The data you said is con­fi­den­tial and not sub­ject to pub­lic dis­clo­sure doesn’t ex­ist?

The Depart­ment: Right.

Smith: Ok, now the ap­peals court says you have to show the data.

Advertise with us

The Depart­ment: Oh ... all right then.

Prevent­able deaths

All of this could be sloughed off as com­mon Flo­rid­ian slap­stick­ery if it weren’t for, you know, all the dy­ing. Some stud­ies have pos­ited that Flor­ida leads the na­tion in pre­vent­able COVID deaths, and DeSan­tis’s chronic vac­cine id­i­ocy has been no small con­trib­u­tor.

There is sig­nifi­cant ac­a­demic ev­i­dence that DeSan­tis is, in fact, not an id­iot, but his ap­proach to the COVID cri­sis has al­ways been purely po­lit­i­cal flim­flam. The Miami Her­ald, among oth­ers, has re­peat­edly nailed him on it.

“The vast ma­jor­ity of peo­ple hos­pi­tal­ized in Flor­ida – and the 87,141 who have died on his watch — had not been vac­ci­nated,” said the ed­i­tors. “The big­gest clus­ters of the dead were in red Pan­han­dle coun­ties where peo­ple lis­tened to his pan­demic mis­han­dling as if it were gos­pel.”

Advertise with us

He was also a hyp­o­crite. “When he was run­ning for re-elec­tion in 2021 and vac­cines were at a pre­mium, he made them avail­able to his wealthy do­nor class in at least two Flor­ida lo­ca­tions and pro­claimed that they ‘saved lives.’ Then, he saw the po­lit­i­cal profit of stand­ing against vac­cine man­dates.”

You might con­clude that this kind of cra­ven du­plic­ity is so pun­gent that you could smell it all the way to Iowa and any­where else DeSan­tis had taken his doomed pres­i­den­tial cam­paign.

And you would be wrong about that.

Deep red Re­pub­li­cans don’t want a can­di­date who might have con­trib­uted to merely tens of thou­sands of deaths. They want a man some have said con­trib­uted to hun­dreds of thou­sands of deaths coast-to-coast: Don­ald J. Trump.

Stable ge­nius

Advertise with us

Didn’t Dr. Deb­o­rah Birx, the Trump ad­min­is­tra­tion’s COVID re­sponse co­or­di­na­tor, tell the House Select Coronavi­rus Sub­com­mit­tee that 30 to 40% of COVID deaths in the U.S. could have been pre­vented had the White House taken ap­pro­pri­ate steps to curb the vi­rus in the early days of the pan­demic?

You re­mem­ber Dr. Birx, who sat par­a­lyzed by in­cre­du­lity as Trump asked her on live TV about us­ing “a very pow­er­ful light” as a treat­ment. “And then I see the dis­in­fec­tant, where it knocks it out in a minute, one minute. And is there a way we can do some­thing like that?”

That’s the kind of sta­ble ge­nius who is crush­ing Ron DeSan­tis for the Re­pub­li­can nom­i­na­tion. DeSan­tis fully de­serves to be crushed, and that makes it not one bit less tragic.

Gene Collier is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and @genecollier. His previous column was “For Trump, which witch hunt trial matters most?”.