What with the planet accelerating its seemingly inalterable descent into madness, the relatively obscure legal settlement of a years-long argument in madness-prone Florida this week didn’t get the notice it might have.
Based on the terms of the agreement, it looks like the governor, the flailing presidential pretender Ron DeSantis, along with his flunkies in the Florida Department of Health, have been lying about COVID statistics since at least June of 2021.
Owning their own lies
Now they’re required to effectively own their lies, and fork over $152,250 in legal fees to the Florida Center for Government Accountability and former state representative Carlos Guillermo Smith, who filed suit two years ago.
“The Department lied about the existence of these public records in court and did everything to restrict information and downplay the threat of COVID even while the Delta variant ripped through Florida — a decision that cost many lives,” said Rep. Smith in a statement.
Prior to the ignition of the Delta variant that summer, Florida’s health department routinely furnished the public with detailed information on a daily basis. But with the number of cases multiplying across the state and the governor declaring “Florida’s open for business!” the Department changed the way it was reporting data to the Centers for Disease Control.
Read More
The new method made it appear the virus was instead declining just as DeSantis was running for a second term for governor and keeping no secrets about his White House ambitions.
Rep. Smith vs. the State of Florida
When Rep. Smith asked the state for detailed COVID info for Orange County, the long argument that ensued went essentially like this:
Smith: I need info on confirmed COVID cases in Orange County by age, sex, ethnicity, and race, and I need the vaccination rate.
The Department: That’s confidential.
Smith: No it’s not.
The Department: Yes it is, and it’s not subject to public disclosure.
Smith: No it’s not and yes it is.
The Department: Yuh-huh and nuh-uh.
Smith: I’ll sue to get it.
The Department: Knock yourself out.
Smith: Ok, the Court says you’ve got to explain why you’re restricting this data.
The Department: What data?
Smith: The COVID data.
The Department: It doesn’t exist.
Smith: The data you said is confidential and not subject to public disclosure doesn’t exist?
The Department: Right.
Smith: Ok, now the appeals court says you have to show the data.
The Department: Oh ... all right then.
Preventable deaths
All of this could be sloughed off as common Floridian slapstickery if it weren’t for, you know, all the dying. Some studies have posited that Florida leads the nation in preventable COVID deaths, and DeSantis’s chronic vaccine idiocy has been no small contributor.
There is significant academic evidence that DeSantis is, in fact, not an idiot, but his approach to the COVID crisis has always been purely political flimflam. The Miami Herald, among others, has repeatedly nailed him on it.
“The vast majority of people hospitalized in Florida – and the 87,141 who have died on his watch — had not been vaccinated,” said the editors. “The biggest clusters of the dead were in red Panhandle counties where people listened to his pandemic mishandling as if it were gospel.”
He was also a hypocrite. “When he was running for re-election in 2021 and vaccines were at a premium, he made them available to his wealthy donor class in at least two Florida locations and proclaimed that they ‘saved lives.’ Then, he saw the political profit of standing against vaccine mandates.”
You might conclude that this kind of craven duplicity is so pungent that you could smell it all the way to Iowa and anywhere else DeSantis had taken his doomed presidential campaign.
And you would be wrong about that.
Deep red Republicans don’t want a candidate who might have contributed to merely tens of thousands of deaths. They want a man some have said contributed to hundreds of thousands of deaths coast-to-coast: Donald J. Trump.
Stable genius
Didn’t Dr. Deborah Birx, the Trump administration’s COVID response coordinator, tell the House Select Coronavirus Subcommittee that 30 to 40% of COVID deaths in the U.S. could have been prevented had the White House taken appropriate steps to curb the virus in the early days of the pandemic?
You remember Dr. Birx, who sat paralyzed by incredulity as Trump asked her on live TV about using “a very powerful light” as a treatment. “And then I see the disinfectant, where it knocks it out in a minute, one minute. And is there a way we can do something like that?”
That’s the kind of stable genius who is crushing Ron DeSantis for the Republican nomination. DeSantis fully deserves to be crushed, and that makes it not one bit less tragic.
Gene Collier is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and @genecollier. His previous column was “For Trump, which witch hunt trial matters most?”.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.