On the still distant fringes of America’s omnipresent Trump discussion, an idea that’s begun to blossom will soon command more notice. A deal.
Technically, in legal language, a plea agreement.
Sound minds inhabiting brains much larger than mine (OK, low bar) are imagining a pathway out of this black forest of the former Buffoonatic-in-Chief’s legal entanglements. Indicted in four jurisdictions on 91 felony counts, Trump lumbers and blunders along his own pathway, the one he set out upon decades ago, the one where he breaks so many laws that the legal system can’t possibly process his unending treachery.
He doesn’t understand
As Ty Cobb, one of the USA’s thousands of former Trump attorneys, said so eloquently in the New York Times last week, Trump “doesn’t understand anything about the propriety of how to live a life.”
Well.
Read More
And yet, here in early 21st century America, the singular pathology Cobb describes is, rather than disqualifying, somehow able to make you the runaway choice for the Republican presidential nomination.
So that’s a bit of a pickle, right?
Trump thinks he’s got to run, and win, to stay out of the slammer by either stopping the investigations or simply pardoning himself. Most Americans think bringing him to justice is indispensable to maintaining our Constitutional principle that no one is above the law.
Some serious people think that merely arresting Trump is a bad look for America, making him a martyr and trafficking the imagery of how authoritative states deal with political agitators. Worse, some other serious people say, having a former president in prison sends a terrible signal around the globe as to the health of American democracy; it only stokes anger and the need for vengeance at home.
Few will be surprised that I seriously disagree with all of those serious people. Prosecuting Trump in the ways long established by the rule of law, with the full presumption of innocence and conviction only on proof enough to persuade a jury into unanimity, just like anyone else who’d magnetized 91 felony counts, only strengthens American democracy and reinforces its Constitutional foundations.
Bad and worse
This isn’t exactly an original opinion. Some have put it more pointedly, like this: Is prosecuting Trump bad for America? Yes. Do you know what’s worse? Not prosecuting Trump.
But in anticipation of looming discussions, what would a plea arrangement look like anyway?
A typical preliminary bid goes something like this: Trump admits guilt (not bloody likely), avoids prison (a travesty), agrees never to run for office again (he probably can’t anyway, according to the 14th Amendment), and gets home confinement. I would throw in golf confinement (indoor simulators only) and that Trump be required to complete a remedial spelling course if he’s somehow allowed to continue on social media.
Here’s a quick intro on that last point. It’s stolen, not “stollen.” It’s smoking, not “smocking.” It’s lose, not “loose.” It’s unprecedented, not “unpresidented.” Also (attention commenters and emailers), it’s you’re an idiot, not “your and idiot.”
Other versions of a deal have included that Trump cannot leave the country, must report weekly to a parole officer, and return any classified documents still lying by the commode, including any that he may have declassified just by “thinking about it.”
There are a couple of accompanying realities that might indicate a deal is ultimately where we are headed. Something like 90 percent of all federal cases in this country are decided through plea agreements. If all of those cases went to trial, the legal system could not bear it.
Open to a deal
Trump has demonstrated throughout his long and sordid legal history that he’s open to a deal. He “wrote” a book called “The Art of the Deal,” and though I doubt he read it, he might be more willing than ever to a deal that frees him from years of hair pulling in the courts, particularly since his legal bills have already required him to divert some $40 million in campaign contributions to lawyers who haven’t been indicted yet.
Trump is 77 years old. His legal exposure is such that he could easily be incarcerated for the rest of his natural life. He could fly that Trump 757 to Moscow and live comfortably with Putin among the disgraced oligarchs, but vanity prevents it. Vanity and that $200,000 bond he’ll have to post Thursday.
Ultimately, it’s not about him, but about us. Any deal that keeps Trump out of the public square, or makes him 100 percent politically irrelevant within it, deserves our earnest scrutiny. I guess.
On its face, I don’t like it, but Democracy is about compromise too.
Gene Collier is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and @genecollier. His previous column was “Dear Donald, Stop begging to be jailed.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.