We’ve barely gotten through half a week without Max Baer, and the carefully written explainers with their beautifully expressed sentiments have made nothing short of a superb attempt to contextualize the life of the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.
Putting the man’s death in context, that’s the hard part.
Everything happens for a reason, maybe you’ve heard since about the time you could hear. It’s the ever-available platitude the unwittingly platitudinous love to platitude all over the place. So go ahead, tell me the reason that Max Baer, less than three months from retirement after a career of intense public service, goes to his dreams thinking of the oodles of time he’ll soon get to spend with the grandkids, and dies overnight.
I’m sorry; there’s no reason for that. Instead, I’m going to leave this achingly poignant explanation to Judy Horgan, his friend of some three decades.
“I know that he died in his sleep,” she told me Monday. “And I thought that if the Angel of Death had come to him during the day, he would have been able to say, ‘I still have work to do.’ And they would have left him here, because he was such a positive, take action kind of guy. It’s what made him effective and made people love him.
“And he was not done, which kind of breaks your heart.”
Read More
The plain fact is, Max Baer wasn’t the kind of guy who was hard to explain; he was just one of those people there aren’t nearly enough of. The things that were so evident about him — he was good and he was caring and he could not only get things done, he could get great things done — were rock solid genuine.
All of those things would become profound in their way, but anyone who met him knew immediately that he loathed pretense. I met him over a series of lunches with mutual friends at an old Smithfield Street saloon called Jimmy’s Post, where pretense went to die. Because Pittsburghers never use one preposition when two will do, the little restaurant on the second floor was called Up Over Jimmy’s Post.
Though Max had already been deputy attorney general for Pennsylvania, done most of a decade in private legal practice and was a judge on the Allegheny Court of Common Pleas, ours were not what anyone could describe as high-level discussions.
It was there, it seems logical to remember, that during the newspaper strike in 1992, someone suggested the owner of Jimmy’s Post buy the Post-Gazette and call it Up Over Jimmy’s Post-Gazette.
It was there, over slabs of deep fried fish the size of a throw rug, that Max would fret over the looming opponent of his beloved Pitt footballers and luxuriate in the common and yet exceedingly special collegiality of the moment.
“That’s how he was, everything he did was so collegial,” said his friend Karen Blumen. “He was very good at assembling a group of people that felt they were part of a team that was crafting a solution.”
So it was that Max Baer, first as the sitting judge at what was then called Juvenile Court (now Family Court), watched the system he was part of failing the kids who came before him, saw that government funding would never fully take care of them and saw that simple needs that could be shoved within their reach — a bike, a football, a music lesson — could make a profound difference in their desperate quest just to be normal kids, and a foundational difference in the community.
That’s what was behind his child advocacy, and with Judy Horgan, who founded and directed Child Watch of Pittsburgh, and with Karen Blumen and Marc Cherna, who led the makeover of the county’s Children and Youth Services from a disgrace into a national model, and with hundreds of others, Max Baer did some of his noblest work.
“He cared about people, and one of the things that was so extraordinary about him is that he really cared about making a difference for children,” said Mr. Cherna, who retired as the county’s Director of Human Services two years ago. “You know, most judges, you win an election, and you’re an instant expert, and you can disengage. He stayed on it. He was really engaged. The reform in Children and Youth Services couldn’t have happened without his leadership.”
Max and his cohorts started the Allegheny County Music Festival, and though it generated unprecedented funding, when the money looked as though it still wouldn’t meet the county’s growing need, Max started Candidates Comedy Night, which raised $35,000 to $40,000 every year it got staged for more than a decade.
When he asked me to be part of that brainstorm — a night every summer when political candidates for everything from the local courts to the governor to the United States Senate would channel their infinite glibness into stand-up comedy, my first thought wasn’t, “Well, yeah, that could work.” It was something closer to, “Ya know Max; I’ve got enough trouble trying to be funny on stage myself without shepherding 10-12 ‘acts’ who can’t stand the sight of each other through a couple of hours of dubious entertainment.’”
But you didn’t say that to Max. You wouldn’t. You couldn’t. He was so positive. It would work. He knew it. Next thing, I’m on at the Improv going, “Ladies and Gentlemen, Arlen Specter!”
And Arlen Specter flat out slayed ‘em. Honest to God.
Max sat well out of the spotlight, beaming.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @genecollier






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.