It is neither the intent nor the legitimate purpose of this column to be arguing with experts, much less with scholarly professionals in virology, immunology and public health, but I simply must venture this modest pushback:

Use of the term “impending doom” should, if at all possible, be limited to the start of the Pirates season.

You’re welcome.

It was Rochelle Walensky, head of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, who blurted that very phrase in some emotional off-script remarks during a formal briefing the other day, adding, “Right now, I’m scared.”

Advertise with us

This was barely 12 hours after CNN presented a two-hour documentary rounding up all the top health professionals who’ve overseen this disaster from the start, ostensibly to codify some record of how we got here and where we’re going, some explanation for how a country with 4% of the world’s population continues to churn out 20% of its deaths.

Less clear, even with Ms. Walensky’s plea, was exactly where we are, so I’ll offer a tentative opinion on that. We’re in extra innings. It’s not the eighth, not the ninth. We’re in extras, meaning the pandemic could be over soon in the United States, or could go on for a long time, its outcome indeterminate. Cases of coronavirus are up in more than half the states. The more it spreads and the more variants it shakes loose, the more ominous what Dr. Anthony Fauci called on CNN “this damned, evil virus,” becomes.

“It’s a war,” Dr. Fauci said, “and in war, you’d better start shooting at the enemy, not each other.”

Alas, what the war glossary calls friendly fire has been ubiquitous from the spark of this pandemic to this moment. Almost every health professional who participated in CNN’s examination gave testimony about the previous administration either lying about the COVID threat or threatening them for not lying about it. Dr. Robert Redfield, head of the CDC in the Trump administration, went so far as to accuse his bosses of pressuring him to alter his agency’s MMWR, the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, a scientific document referenced by professionals worldwide to, in part, design mitigation strategies that can save lives.

At no time did the previous administration take misinformation and disinformation out of its toolbox.

Advertise with us

A year ago this week, Mr. Trump told a virtual town hall on Fox News, “I would love to have the country opened up and just raring to go by Easter. Wouldn’t it be great to have all the churches full? You’ll have packed churches all over our country.”

Last Easter, deaths in this country were headed toward 1,000. This Easter, we’re headed toward 600,000. So evidently, yeah, mistakes were made, which brings us to the story that’s been driving this corner of the news cycle since Dr. Deborah Birx weighed in on the weekend.

The first wave of COVID-19 resulted in 100,000 deaths, she said, but everything after that could have been mitigated substantially, meaning that some 400,000 Americans did not have to die from it.

If only Dr. Birx had known someone in the Trump administration.

That last sentence I tweeted on Sunday, before the reconstruction of Dr. Birx had begun in earnest. I didn’t have to point out that not only did Dr. Birx know someone in the Trump administration, she knew the coordinator of its coronavirus task force. In fact, she was it.

Advertise with us

If Dr. Birx knew that the administration was bungling the pandemic response in potentially catastrophic proportions, the time to say it was then, even if it meant being honorably fired.

“Dr. Birx probably should have pushed more,” Dr. Fauci said Sunday night. “But she did a lot.”

Dr. Birx told CNN’s Dr. Sanjay Gupta that former Vice President Mike Pence listened to her advice and allowed her to communicate it to state and local officials, but that Mr. Trump ultimately blocked her from the White House podium for that capital sin, chronic truth-telling. Mr. Trump thought Dr. Birx was misrepresenting the pandemic, making it worse than it was. Dr. Birx thought she hadn’t made it out to be as bad as it was.

“I got called by the president,” Dr. Birx said. “It was very uncomfortable, very direct, and very difficult to hear.”

“Were you threatened?” Dr. Gupta asked.

Advertise with us

And then there were three seconds when Dr. Birx’s mouth closed and her eyes darted left and right. No one misread it.

“I would say it was a very uncomfortable conversation.”

Dr. Birx had already received death threats, already heard that her tongue should be cut out, and already heard plenty of examples of Mr. Trump’s rhetorical thuggery. That telephone call was in August 2020. The fact that she stayed on until the next administration will be analyzed throughout history, but it was perhaps the mirror image of Dr. Fauci’s explanation when asked last year why he didn’t leave.

Often referred to around the White House as a skunk at the picnic, Dr. Fauci said he thought “that if I did walk away, the skunk at the picnic would no longer be at the picnic. Even if I wasn’t very effective in changing everybody’s minds, the idea that they knew that nonsense could not be spouted without my pushing back on it, I felt was important.”

Maybe Dr. Birx should get the benefit of the doubt on that. Through all of it, she did manage to stay well short of “impending doom,” regardless of whether she should have.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.