By one iteration or another, the observance of Halloween dates back thousands of years, so it’s little wonder that many of its developed traditions have come to be misapplied, misunderstood or simply mangled into something else entirely.
Not that there’s anything wrong with any of that.
It’s just that “traditionally,” if a person wears his or her clothes inside out and then walks backward on Halloween, he or she will see a witch at midnight.
You heard me. But confusion persists on this one. Do you have to be walking backward at midnight with your clothes inside out to meet the witch? Must your underwear be on the outside? Most scholars say no, the underwear placement is optional and any time on Halloween will do. I like to get it out of the way early.
Many historians and occultists identify Ireland as the birthplace of Halloween, which I suppose is arguable except to say that the backward-walking aspiring witch greeter with his or her clothes inside out just sounds like one of the most Irish things ever.
It’s heartening, in its way, that tonight’s 6,000th Halloween or so will come off in some form as yet another attempt to scare ourselves despite it being 100% redundant. Who needs Halloween when we’ve got Twitter, after all? Who needs a bolt of raw fear when cable news is churning 24/7? Who needs bats and cats and scarecrows and witches and goblins when Rudy Giuliani roams the mediascape like a lost soul?
In America, we’ve established an indoctrination period to ease people into an awareness that Halloween exists separate from the national fright quotient of any particular October, starting with the lesson that Halloween also exists outside of, you know, reality. That’s why it starts with trick-or-treating.
“So tonight, Ashley, you’re going to put on a costume, go outside and walk up to the houses of strangers holding this sack, see?”
“What?” Ashley will say if she’s not already crying.
“No wait. They give you candy. You say, ‘Trick or treat!’ and they give you candy, in your sack.”
“But I don’t take candy from strangers!”
“You do tonight, now put on this Harley Quinn get-up and let’s go; I ain’t got all night.”
Contemporary trick-or-treaters have worked this tradition into a fairly rigid form of street ballet. Up the walk, ring the bell, say the magic words, extend the sack, accept the ransom, say thank you or fail to do so, turn and rejoin the helicopter parents who maintain a strict 50-foot perimeter.
When I started, during the All Hallow’s Eve harvest festivals of the mid-16th century, trick-or-treating included a performance aspect that was traditional in the Eastern Pennsylvania coal regions. You didn’t just stand on the porch holding your sack, you were invited in with your small group of trick-or-treaters and you either said a short spooky poem or sang a short spooky song. Then and only then were you granted a small treat and ushered into the night.
In addition to being completely nonsensical, this system was time-consuming. The veteran trick-or-treaters soon learned the importance of knocking on the doors of local taverns, of which there was no shortage. In the bar, you did the same short show, then walked along the bar and accepted contributions from 10 or 15 patrons, some of them in a very generous mood.
One song, 15 Hershey bars. Now we’re gettin’ somewhere.
As the baby boomers aged, however, we mangled Halloween more and more toward more adult purposes, either in the way described by my comic friend Mike Wysocki, “Boy, we turned that holiday into a drunken slut-fest, didn’t we?,” or in our weird yet relentless impulse to frighten ourselves.
My scariest Halloween was actually in February 1979, which was when I finally got into a movie theater to see “Halloween,” the original film in the enduring Michael Myers-as-the-boogeyman franchise that would endure for 40 years. In that theater in center city Philadelphia, the audience was a full participant.
“Don’t go up there!”
But Laurie Strode did go up there (of course!). And she was hiding on the floor of that closet when Michael Myers stuck a 15-inch kitchen knife between the horizontal slats of the closet door and started ripping it apart.
“Oh, get out!”
In the spring of 1979, “Halloween” was a truly scary film. I didn’t sleep. The next evening, I flew to Florida to cover spring training for the Philadelphia Journal. I drove my rental car to a rented condo on Indian Rocks Beach through some Fright Night weather along the Gulf Coast. Crashing lightning, swirling rain. Inside, the power was out (of course!). Felt my way around. Pitch black. Lightning through a kitchen window lit up the first thing I saw — the horizontal slats of a utility closet.
I’ll bet there’s a knife drawer.
I can’t not sleep again, I thought. I’ve got to interview Pete Rose tomorrow.
Should you need a more refined way to frighten yourself tonight, turn out the lights and ask Alexa to shuffle some Shostakovich. The 20th century Russian composer was a master of dissonance, dark harmonies and unnerving tonalities, and for good reason. He was constantly falling in and out of favor with Stalin. Fear pours from his symphonies. Maybe light a candle.
If that doesn’t work, there’s always Rudy.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.