Dear Iowa,
I know you feel badly about the way you mangled your famous caucuses this time around, and you should, because you had four years to prepare and still you made the first lap in the race to the White House look like “Mad Max: Fury Road.”
Democrats did not flee your state like they were in a post-apocalyptic death race for nothin’.
Well, don’t worry Iowa. Sure, ya screwed up (I loved the part where you eventually had precinct leaders emailing photos of their little worksheets to people who weren’t necessarily expecting them), but look, yours won’t be the first pie-in-the-face moment between here and November. Not in this ridiculous electoral system.
Bernie Sanders, who made you re-canvass the whole mess and who expects to “win” again Tuesday night in New Hampshire, this time in more demonstrable terms, had the nerve to say this at a rally in the Granite State on Monday:
“In Iowa, when they finally get around to counting the votes ... we’ll have 8,000 more votes, and from where I come from, getting the most votes means you win.”
Read More
Really Bernie, are you from America?
Because where I come from, Hillary Clinton got 2,868,686 more votes than her opponent less than four years ago, and no victory lap. Twenty very long years ago, the same thing happened to Al Gore in what was thought to be the pivotal moment when Americans were forced to take a long hard look at the Electoral College.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
So, what’s 20 years of progress look like on this topic? Should we check in on it? Because it still doesn’t seem like the presidential candidates are going to be spending a lot of time in Idaho this time around, even though that’s supposed to be the whole point of the current system — to give voters who might otherwise be ignored an outsized influence on presidential politics.
Is that working for anybody?
In 2020, just as in every other presidential election cycle — including the two in the past five when the Electoral College flipped the will of the people on its sorry head — the election will be decided by a minority of voters in the so-called battleground states. And not necessarily a shrewd minority either. More likely a block of “independent” voters whose collective judgment might be swayed irretrievably by “low-information” voters.
Put another way, the MOST CONSEQUENTIAL ELECTION OF OUR LIFETIMES (yes, again), will likely be decided by a couple thousand people who basically don’t know much and/or don’t much care.
Oh, it’s a great system.
There have been efforts, going back into late ’70s, when President Jimmy Carter proposed a constitutional amendment abolishing the Electoral College, to make the way we select what used to be called the leader of the free world a little more sensible. They’ve failed miserably.
Smart people have thought long and hard about it, and solutions have not been terribly elusive. One suggests increasing the size of the House of Representatives so that the electors will be more representative of the broader population. Another says the winner-take-all system for each state’s electoral votes is a fatal flaw, and that instead, electoral votes be apportioned by the percentage of the popular vote won by the candidates.
Amazingly, Maine and Nebraska have decided to actually do this second one. If their system had been in place nationwide in 2016 and 2000, the results would very likely have been reversed. So only 20 years after Bush v. Gore wound up in the Supreme Court, there are just 48 states standing between the presidential election and, um, logic.
It’s a similar situation with the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, an initiative that points out more than 70% of Americans favor guaranteeing the presidency to the winner of the popular vote, an effort thought by many constitutional scholars as the most promising path forward.
Fifteen states have signed on to the Compact. Fifteen. Oh, and the District of Columbia. Bully.
So look, Iowa, I know you’re hurting. You hearing nothing from the Democrats but calls for the death of your caucuses and oaths to drop you in the lineup from your cherished lead-off spot all the way to Triple A.
But take comfort; we never fix anything in America. The electoral system, the political system, the education system, the legal system, the health care system, the roads, the bridges, the power grid, the mass transit systems, the water system — if it weren’t for the Dewey Decimal System (still a thing!), just about nothing would work.
Iowa, you are not the only fly in the ointment on this one. We haven’t even talked about voter suppression, gerrymandering, Twitter, Facebook, the Russians, the Chinese, and 50 others sinister electioneering elements still undiscovered.
Relax, Iowa. We’ll see you 2024. Maybe be ready this time.
Kindest regards.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.