Eighteen years ago today, Aug. 31, 2001, the final original episode of Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood appeared on PBS, an out-of-the-blue factoid that happens to be unrelated to why I’m writing this.

By every likelihood, this column will end well before I comprehend its raison d‘etre, but I’ve been thinking a lot about Fred Rogers lately because I keep bumping into his memory. I’m finding it discomforting.

I was at a function inside the Fred Rogers Center at Steelers training camp earlier this month; I’ve chatted with Father Paul Taylor, the new president of St. Vincent College, about how that institution is entrusted with Fred’s legacy; I’ve encountered critical praise for “Won’t You Be My Neighbor,” the Fred documentary that brought in some $22 million in 2018, one of the top grossing biographical docs ever produced, and I’ve made it through the trailer for Tom Hanks’ portrayal of Fred that will hit theaters Nov. 22. With Hanks’ predictably perfect touch under the direction of Marielle Heller (“Can You Ever Forgive Me?”), it’s the closest arrangement that exists to a cinematic sure thing.

I won’t see it.

Advertise with us

I can’t. I cannot face Fred Rogers. Not now. Not in 2019.

Feb. 27, 2003, the day Mister Rogers died, has a place in my own unofficial collection of the worst days in American history. The simple decency and humanist values that seemed to shrivel from that day to this do not belong anywhere near Fred’s legacy, but that was a turning point. I’m certain of it. Officially unofficially certain.

Thing is, I never met him. I suppose we were in the same place a few times, most memorably when he threw out the first ball at a Pirates game, uncorking a wild pitch that took about 30 hops to the backstop behind some befuddled Bucco.

But I did meet Joybubbles, a 50-ish blind man who came to Pittsburgh in the late 20th century to listen to tapes of every single episode of “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood.” Last I heard, someone was trying to make a documentary about Joybubbles too. He said early sexual abuse had robbed him of his childhood, so he’d formally changed his name to Joybubbles so that he could  pretend to be 5 all the time.

“When you’re 5,” he told me, “you don’t have to make sense.”

Advertise with us

Ten hours a day for six weeks in the summer of 1998, Joybubbles sat in a remote corner of a Pitt library with his own puppets, searching out a lost childhood through the gentle assurances of Fred Rogers. That’s something I remember about the day Fred died. I phoned Joybubbles at his home in Minnesota. He was distraught. He died not four years later.

Fast forward then to present day America, where a federal court had to order — order! — the United States Government, aka We The People, to provide toothbrushes, soap, clean water, and edible food to detained migrant children in Border Patrol detention facilities.

This government had gone to court in June to argue that it should not be so required. Perhaps you read this tragic exchange.

“To me it’s more like it’s within everybody’s common understanding: If you don’t have a toothbrush, if you don’t have soap, if you don’t have a blanket, it’s not safe and sanitary,” Senior U.S. Circuit Judge A. Wallace Tashima told Justice Department lawyer Sarah Fabian. “Wouldn’t you agree to that?”

Ms. Fabian then said she thought it was fair to say “those things may be” part of the definition of safe and sanitary.

Advertise with us

“What are you saying, ‘may be?’” Judge Tashima shot back. “You mean, there’s circumstances when a person doesn’t need to have a toothbrush, toothpaste and soap? For days?”

If the government had any second thoughts, they were only to make things worse, to detain children longer than the 20 days allowed by law.

The damage to these children will be inestimable.

One study found that 34% of children in detention had diagnosable mental health disorders, and that more than 80% of children and parents said their mental health was affected by detention, with sadness and constant crying as their most common symptoms. Another found that all children and adolescents in detention met the criteria for PTSD, major depression and suicidal thinking.

Sorry kids, that’s our policy. We The People.

Advertise with us

Fred Rogers got the Presidential Medal of Freedom for doing the exact opposite, by infusing the developing psyche of young children with self-worth, community, civility, tolerance, sharing and moral reasoning.

If he were with us now he’d never stop weeping.

I regularly take morning walks on the North Shore, passing beneath the Fred Rogers monument and the Robert Berks statue of Mister Rogers tying his sneakers. I hear him up there with his recorded songs, looking fondly across the Allegheny River at Pittsburgh.

It's you I like

The way you are right now,

Advertise with us

The way down deep inside you

Not the things that hide you,

Not your toys

They're just beside you.

But it's you I like

Advertise with us

Every part of you.

I hope that you'll remember

Even when you're feeling blue

That it's you I like,

It's you yourself

Advertise with us

It’s you.

Even as a statue, I can’t look Fred in the eyes. My friend Saleem Ghubril, the director of The Pittsburgh Promise and himself a passionate advocate for children, tells me that Fred would say I’m wrong to think like this.

“Fred would not agree with that sentiment,” said Ghubril, who spoke at Mr. Rogers’ Heinz Hall memorial service in 2003. “He would say you’re putting him on a pedestal, and he would not approve of that. Everyone was his equal. At some point, after troubling events, we made him the national comforter of children, the national counselor of children, but the Mister Rogers that appeared on TV is not a character. That’s Fred Rogers.”

Before Joybubbles left Pittsburgh, I asked about how he thought of Mister Rogers now that he’d absorbed the very totality of his work.

“I think of him as kind,” he said, “as if I told him the worst thing about me that I could possibly think of, he would still say, ‘You’re special and that’s OK, and I like you very, very much.’”

Advertise with us

Uh-huh. Those were the days, in some other America.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.