From what I’ve read, it’s pretty clear that Nelson Mandela chose his words carefully. So when the late South African revolutionary and Nobel Laureate elected to equate education with weaponry, you had to figure he was onto something.

“Education,” he said, “is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.”

America went back to school this month with its need to weaponize education more urgent than ever. In a country that always seems to know more and more about nothing but less and less about something, educators at all levels have to feel like they’re guiding students through an ever-intensifying blizzard of disparate information, much of it accumulating in the palms of their hands.

The effect is, to strain the metaphor, chilling.

Advertise with us

This week, I talked with three educators of varied backgrounds and academic platforms, three for whom I have the utmost respect, and each independently identified the same daunting challenge: There is more to know than ever, and the delineation between what Mandela would weaponize to change the world and everything else has virtually disappeared.

“I’m getting from college freshman that they’ve kind of been numbed to learning,” one told me. “There’s just so much out there and it all runs together. They don’t memorize anything because they can just look it up on their phone, where knowing which Kardashian is which is just as important as knowing what the capital of France is or who the prime minister of England is. They don’t know how to distinguish what’s important, but at some point, when you’re talking to someone, you’re going to have to show that you actually know something.”

Blisteringly true, but not if you want to go into government, necessarily.

American government, maybe you’ve noticed, is thick with functionaries who have no idea how American government works, particularly at the highest levels.

There’s a popular trope which posits that this is in some part because we don’t teach civics anymore, but that’s partly a dodge and generally not true. We might not call it civics, but government studies are often folded into social studies curricula, though it’s correct to say the degree to which social studies are required varies wildly from district to district and coast to coast.

Advertise with us

Government is still being taught, which you know because Trumbull High in Connecticut last April won its eighth consecutive state championship and 24th since 1987 in a competition developed by the Center For Civic Education. In these events, students testify as constitutional experts before panels of judges acting as congressional committees, where they’re grilled on depth of knowledge, understanding, and their ability to apply constitutional principles.

So, you missed that on ESPN2?

Outside of Trumbull High and its worthy competitors, knowledge of governmental structures and processes tends to diminish just a bit, depressingly so if you include the great majority of Americans who, as went the ancient Sam Cooke diddy, don’t know much about history.

A survey done by the Woodrow Wilson Fellowship Foundation found that 64% of Americans could not pass the immigration exam given to non-citizens, about 91% of whom pass both it and the English exam, according to a July story in The New York Times.

The same Wilson Foundation noted that 87% of us don’t know the year the Constitution was signed, 60% don’t know which countries America fought in World War II, and 57% don’t know how many justices are on the Supreme Court. So this is a country where more people are sure that Michael Jackson wrote “Beat it,” than are aware the Bill of Rights are part of the Constitution.

Advertise with us

“The fact that people are ignorant about history and political structure is not about what’s being taught in school,” said another of my education consultants. “The people who do know these things are the people who read the news. I’m very suspicious about any nostalgic notion that ‘Oh kids today aren’t getting what we got.’

“It’s been demonstrated that Americans don’t know basic government and history, but my general crankiness about it is that it has more to do with the fact that there’s so much more junk to consume. People can tell you who won ‘The Bachelor’ for the past seven years because that (knowledge) is something they’re using.”

Thus your “Bachelor” bonafides might fall into what’s called operational learning (rather than memorization). I can tell you off the top of my head who won every World Series back to about 1950 because that’s where I’ve sort of been operating for most of my life, not because I memorized a list of champions.

Getting students to operate in areas with potentially world-changing ideas, to use Mandela’s weaponry, is an educational challenge in which difficulty and urgency are hurtling along parallel tracks.

Or, as the Wilson Foundation President Arthur Levine put it, “Americans need to understand the past in order to make sense of a chaotic present and an inchoate future. History is both an anchor in a time when change assails us and a laboratory for studying the changes that are occurring. It offers the promise of providing a common bond among Americans in an era in which our divisions are profound and our differences threaten to overshadow our commonalities.”

Advertise with us

God bless you educators. All that is riding on this is everything.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.