There is no quantifying the great volume of outstanding television I’ve ignored over the years, from Game of Thrones to The Sopranos, from Breaking Bad to The Handmaid’s Tale, from Entourage to Stranger Things. I’ve watched none of it.
The primary function of the medium for me has generally been to deliver news and ballgames, Bucs and pucks, plaudits and pundits, with a few escapes into comedy but far fewer toward entertainment, no matter how accomplished.
Recently, however, the news has been so depressing I found myself really needing distance from it, a vicarious flight to a place where I could hear myself think, so what better vehicle for ponderous reflection than . . .
Chernobyl.
I know, you’re probably not in a good place when your TV comfort animal is a non-fiction nuclear explosion .
HBO’s extraordinary five-part docudrama certainly doesn’t need me to recommend it, but it is a beautifully written and sensitively directed treatment of the horrifying events in the Ukraine spring of 1986, and it is driving people nuts.
People are taking selfies in front of Chernobyl’s Reactor 4, the roof of which blew off at 1:23 a.m. on April 26 of that year, pumping into the atmosphere about 400 times the radiation of the Hiroshima bomb.
Ready? One, two, three, smile!
A video you can find readily on line now features Chernobyl tourists complaining that there are too many Chernobyl tourists. Maybe some of the overflow can join the long lines at Mt. Everest in what’s become a really strange summer travel season.
The triumphal impact of the HBO project is the haunting rendering of Chernobyl as way scarier today than it was 33 years ago, if only because 33 years ago, the then Soviet Union, typically, told no one outside the country. It wasn’t until sensors in Sweden, some 900 miles to the northwest, started squawking about radiation that the outside world got wise to it.
Mikhail Gorbachev was in charge of what he would later describe as the beginning of the end of the Soviet state, and even the premier himself could not believe the extent of the reflexive institutional cover-up.
A transcript of the emergency Politburo Transcript quoted in The Economist in 2016 illustrates a furious Gorbachev watching his vision of a more open society meeting its doom: “Everything was kept secret from the Central Committee. The whole system was penetrated by the spirit of boot-licking, persecution of dissidents, clannishness, window-dressing and nepotism. We will put an end to all this.”
Or fail to do so.
The government’s ham-handed bureaucratic attempts at solving the world’s worst science problem, with a clock ticking toward nuclear annihilation, come into stunning focus in the writing of Craig Mazin, one heartbreaking scene after another.
The one I can’t shake is of the Siberian miners rousted from their workplace and being told they were getting shipped to Chernobyl for the clean-up of what became known as the Exclusion Zone. They were essentially being conscripted for death or, on the upside, untold sickness and suffering.
Some 600,000 people were drafted into a decontamination exercise that would involve all manner of dehumanizing horrors, often with lethal implications, leading ultimately to the construction of a giant concrete and steel sarcophagus over the exploded reactor.
The legacy holds that cataclysmic human error at the site on that night coupled with systemic design flaws on this particular type of Soviet reactor triggered the disaster, but Mr. Mazin is careful here not to let the viewer feel superior to either the predicament or the behavior, and that’s no small hurdle for some Western democracies, not to mention any names.
In an interview with Emily Todd VanDerWerff at Vox, Mr. Mazin explained his vision, in part, like this: “It’s the story of the Soviet Union, but the danger is you make the story about how the Soviets were a bunch of liars and it’s easy for America — and some Americans continue to do this, remarkably — to say, ‘See? Those Soviets ... they’re liars.’ And it became clear to me that Soviets are just people, and we’re just people, and lying is not in the water over there. It’s something people do. And they do it here. The Soviet system is a warning: Don’t take it this far. Please, for the love of God, don’t take it this far.”
Depending on your source, the death toll from Chernobyl has been estimated at anywhere from 4,000 to more than 200,000, unless your source is the official Soviet figure: 31.
To this day.
The heroic Russian people, the Ukrainians and the Belorussians as well, saved millions of lives with their selfless courage in the face of disaster. Reflecting on it some years later, Gorbachev suggested the whole ordeal, the errors, the finger-pointing, and the lying had killed something else as well:
Chernobyl, he said, “even more than my launch of perestroika (Communist Party reform), was perhaps the real cause of the collapse of the Soviet Union five years later.”
What will we learn from this? Probably what we always do. Nothing.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.