Despite scrutiny from the media and the Office of City Controller Rachael Heisler, the City of Pittsburgh continues to violate its own rules regarding the use of purchase cards, or p-cards, an analysis by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board shows.

Going back to the beginning of 2025 — the year after misuse of p-cards was a major issue for the Gainey administration — more than two dozen vendors have been paid more than the limit of $10,000 per year using the credit cards distributed to some city employees. While some of these are understandable, such as court filing fees paid to Allegheny County by the Department of Law, others are not.

The most extreme example is the ongoing use of p-cards to pay over $100,000 a year for the city’s voice-over-internet-protocol, or VOIP, phone service. There is no justification for paying for this service outside the established invoicing process.

The fact that the scrutiny of the Controller’s Office has resulted in no change signals a deep dysfunction within city government, which crosses administrations. When internal efforts to ensure accountability are ignored or rebuffed, while City Council keeps rubber-stamping expenses, it’s clear that a culture of nonchalance has set in with regard to rules meant to protect taxpayer resources.

Advertise with us

It’s going to take more than mathematics to resolve Pittsburgh’s budget crisis, which is ultimately a spending problem. It’s going to take the restoration of a culture of accountability in city government.

Beyond accountability

City p-cards came to public attention in 2024, when Heisler revealed that a person arrested for antisemitic vandalism had been paid by the city — but in an unusual way. Mario Ashkar had received more than $10,000 through a PayPal account, charged to a purchase card held by the Department of Parks and Recreation.

P-cards are meant for one-time expenses, where the usual city procurement and payment processes don’t make sense. Sometimes, like with Ashkar, that means vendors for events, like a caricaturist at a city festival. More typically, that means supplies for a work site. That’s why, according to the Editorial Board’s analysis of p-card reports going back to January 2025, the Department of Public Works is the most prolific user, with over half a million dollars in p-card expenses.

The trouble with these payments is that they occur outside the city’s accountability processes. Typically, the executive branch submits an invoice for an expense approved by City Council to the Controller’s Office, who cuts the check from the correct account. All three branches are involved. The Controller is legally bound to pay all legitimate invoices, but this step does provide some oversight of the payment process.

When a p-card purchase is made, however, it is a fait accompli. The vendor has already gotten the money, and it’s up to the city to pay the credit card company, which it is bound to do. City Council receives weekly reports on p-card usage, but it always rubber stamps them.

Advertise with us

Neverending emergency

In our analysis of those reports, supplemented but the Controller’s “Checkbook PGH” website, one vendor leaped off the page: Twilio, Inc., a provider of internet-based phone services. This vendor received more than 12 times the maximum annual p-card expenditure, about $118,000, in 2025. And it has already surpassed the $10,000 mark for 2026.

The city began using Twilio in 2020 during the COVID pandemic, as work shifted to home. It appears that the Department of Innovation and Performance paid Twilio using p-cards as an emergency measure — and never stopped.

When questioned by representatives of the Controller’s Office in January 2025, according to emails reviewed by the Editorial Board, an official at the department explained that the city was moving away from Twilio, and so the payments would continue until that process was complete. When the Controller’s Office made a similar inquiry just this month, the department responded with substantially the same answer. That’s a 16-month extension of an “emergency” stopgap that began in 2020.

But it gets worse: Innovation and Performance has been promising to wean off Twilio since at least 2023. That’s when the department issued a request for proposals for a new phone communications system for all of city government.

City Council approved a 2-year contract with Twilio at the same time, which included a “waiver of competitive process,” because it was supposed to be a temporary extension of an existing service. But the 2023 RFP expired with no decision. And Innovation and Performance has continued to pay Twilio using a p-card, rather than submitting invoices to the Controller, to this day — well past the expiration of Council’s two-year extension.

Advertise with us

Culture shift

The department issued another RFP in January 2025 and managed to successfully select a new vendor: Cisco Systems. But the transfer of city phones off Twilio still isn’t complete, and won’t be for several more months. So the p-card payments will continue, a representative from Innovation and Performance told the Controller’s Office this month, seemingly unrepentantly.

Besides exceeding the $10,000 annual limit, these payments violate the p-card regulation against using the method for ongoing expenses. These are precisely the kind of expenditures that must, by rule and by any reasonable standard of accountability, be approved by the people’s representatives on Council and submitted, by legitimate invoice, to the fiscal watchdog at the Controller’s Office.

From top to bottom, it’s hard to count just how many rule violations and procedural abnormalities occurred in this episode. And yet, no one appears to be empowered or motivated to make it stop. The Controller’s Office made inquiries, but the department brushed them off. City Council could take binding action, but it lacks the resources to look into every expense placed before it, and the will to cause a fuss.

It falls, therefore, to the city’s chief executive: Mayor Corey O’Connor must make it clear that skirting the rules is not acceptable in the government he runs. Especially regarding taxpayer resources. Especially in a budget crunch.

And a great first step would be cracking down on the Department of Innovation and Performance — and getting the city’s internet phone payments off p-cards and into real invoices.