Just as the Pittsburgh region has too many municipalities, it has too many school districts. Nowhere is this seen more clearly than in the travails of the Duquesne School District, tucked between West Mifflin Borough and the Monongahela River, and just south of Kennywood.
The lesson of Duquesne schools is that consolidation must be considered before a district is in crisis. Because once it’s suffering a crisis, the political cost of merging with another community’s schools, bringing along all the financial baggage, becomes far too high.
Duquesne is the smallest of four cities in Allegheny County, alongside Pittsburgh, McKeesport and Clairton. It topped out at more than 21,000 people in 1930, more than enough to justify its own school district. But today only about 5,000 people remain.
The city’s schools were unable to effectively educate their dwindling number of teenagers in the 2000s, so Duquesne closed its high school in 2007, with students transferring to the neighboring West Mifflin Area district. (This district includes West Mifflin and its tiny neighbor, Whitaker.) Five years later, the district closed its 7th- and 8th-grade programs, as well.
Yet in recent years, under the leadership of superintendent Sue Mariani, Duquesne schools have made a remarkable comeback. Seventh and eighth graders returned to the school on Kennedy Avenue a decade after they left, and the number of students in the district has ticked up to about 450. The district told Post-Gazette reporter Andrew Goldstein that it is financially stable, though it remains in state receivership through 2028.
It may seem odd, then, that the state’s Department of Education has begun studying the feasibility of suppressing Duquesne’s school district and merging the community with a neighbor. (The neighbor is most likely West Mifflin, though the city also borders the East Allegheny and McKeesport Area districts across the river).
The truth is that Duquesne schools probably should have been folded into West Mifflin Area not in 2007, when Duquesne High School closed, but a generation earlier. The little city had already lost half its 1930 population by 1980. By 2007, the die had been cast a long, long time earlier.
The district has recovered more than anyone expected, but it’s precisely the district’s newfound stability that makes it possible to consider consolidation.
The biggest hurdle to saving struggling school districts is that none of their neighbors want them or can even afford to take on their liabilities. It’s very hard to sell a community on absorbing a school district in crisis, likely resulting in increased taxes and possibly a decline in services as the district manages the merger and spreads its resources thin.
The lesson of Duquesne, therefore, is that many more school districts should be investigating mergers right now. Few can hope for a recovery like Duquesne’s, and Duquesne can’t rely on it continuing. If it doesn’t continue, the costs to the district of joining another district will be even greater.
Like an aging car or home, there comes a time when the cost of keeping up an independent school system overtakes the cost of letting it go. Too often — for understandable reasons relating to community pride and nostalgia — local leaders let the situation fall into such disrepair that the only viable solution, consolidation, becomes impractical.
One way to force the issue would be for the state to mandate a second round of consolidation across the Commonwealth. In the early 1970s, the state cut down from more than 2,500 to 500 districts. Now, State Rep. Greg Scott, D-Montgomery, is proposing another round of 80% culling, reducing the number to only 100.
That seems a bit extreme, but the concept is sound: The state should be encouraging and even incentivizing widespread consolidation. And the sooner the better, because the more districts fall into crisis, the more difficult resolving them will be.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.