This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city, and southwestern Pennsylvania more generally, during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.
The United States Census estimates that the City of Pittsburgh has added nearly 4,700 people since the 2020 count, an increase of 1.6%. These between-census estimates can be significantly inaccurate, but if the figures hold, Pittsburgh is looking at its first decade with a population boost since the 1940s.
The city itself, however, is an outlier in its nine-county region, which has seen a 1.4% decline since 2020, according to the Census Bureau. This is largely related, as we have previously discussed, to the disproportionate share of older people in southwestern Pennsylvania, especially in the river valleys and elsewhere devastated by deindustrialization, leading to a higher death rate than birth rate.
This data should temper enthusiasm about the city’s apparent growth: The 2020 tracked a small increase in the regional population, but it appears to be reversing. Whether the city has bottomed out, or is looking at a Jack Rabbit-style double dip, is yet to be seen. Further, family attraction and retention has proven particularly difficult for Pittsburgh, which has the second-smallest proportion of under-18 residents among top American cities.
Stabilizing the city’s and region’s population has been a topic of conversation among civic leaders for decades, but durable success has proven elusive — even as the new organization Pittsburgh Tomorrow shows promise. So, what about just paying people to move here?
Remote in Tulsa
This is far from a new idea. A May 2025 study by the W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research of a program in Tulsa, Okla., indicated that there were, at the time, over 100 such programs in communities across the country.
The Tulsa one may be the most famous. Called Tulsa Remote, it’s funded by philanthropy — specifically the George Kaiser Family Foundation — and is targeted specifically at luring remote workers to make their homes in the Oklahoma city of about 400,000 people, whose population roughly leveled off around the turn of the millennium.
Tulsa Remote offers grants of $10,000 to individuals who work outside Oklahoma, either in monthly disbursement to offset rent or in a lump sum to help with a down payment on a house. Since the program launched in 2019 (notably, pre-COVID), Tulsa Remote reports that through 2025, 3,974 people have gone through the program, with 80% staying longer than two years in the city. The Upjohn report indicated that the economic benefit was four times the cost, while the organization itself reports that “remoters” made $878 million in employment income, much of which supported the regional economy through consumption and taxation.
The independent report did note that the program seemed to cause a small increase in overall property values, which all means a small decrease in housing affordability. Such an effect could be easily counteracted, however, by facilitating the construction of more supply.
Moving Motown
Now Detroit is getting in on the action: An organization called Move Detroit is about to start offering $15,000 stipends to put down stakes in Motor City, according to a Fox Business report. This program, unlike Tulsa’s, does not appear to be limited to remote workers, and will include “entrepreneurs and creatives” as well as current residents who commit to staying in Detroit. The first wave of the program will fund about 300 people at a cost of $500,000.
For Pittsburgh’s purposes, what is particularly notable about Move Detroit is that it is a consortium of a huge variety of for-profit businesses and non-profit organizations who’ve pledged to work together specifically with the goal to “grow Detroit’s population, build shared prosperity, foster thriving communities, and create even brighter futures for all Detroiters.” This is exactly the kind of civic cooperation of which Pittsburgh used to be a national model.
The partners in Move Detroit include everything from finance giants JPMorgan Chase, Rocket Mortgage and Fifth Third Bank, to nonprofits like the United Way and multiple foundations, to civic groups like Visit Detroit, the Detroit Opera and the Downtown Detroit Partnership, to both the University of Michigan and Michigan State University. Not to mention General Motors and the City of Detroit itself, bridging the public-private divide.
Move Detroit is, by all appearances, a civic leadership organization optimized for the first half of the 21st century in the way the Allegheny Conference on Community Development was optimized for the second half of the 20th century.
Cold hard cash
Would paying people to move to Pittsburgh be good for Pittsburgh? The evidence from Tulsa is strong, and the fact others, like Detroit, are deploying similar strategies is notable. Both of these programs, we should emphasize, use zero taxpayer dollars to fund the incentives. Any program we’d support in Pittsburgh would be the same, involving a renewed civic commitment by the city’s most visible organizations.
One significant difference between Pittsburgh and these two model cities is physical size. Tulsa is a sprawling 202 square miles, while Detroit is a denser but still large 143 square miles. Pittsburgh is a very tightly-defined city of 58 square miles. This matters because in both Tulsa and Detroit, the factors working against growth are largely contained within city limits. In Pittsburgh, however, many of the most struggling communities, who need an influx of new life, are beyond its borders.
For that reason, we think a Pittsburgh incentive program shouldn’t just be about juicing the city’s population, but should target the struggling cities and towns of the Three Rivers more broadly. Such a program might consider graduated incentives that pay more to relocate to (for instance) McKeesport than to Pittsburgh proper.
Pittsburgh has talked about its population troubles for decades, but nothing speaks as loudly as cold hard cash.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.