This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city, and southwestern Pennsylvania more generally, during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.
Zoning reform is coming to the city of Pittsburgh. The current traditional and restrictive system, which went into effect in 1999, no longer serves the city of 2026 (and it really didn’t serve the city of 1999 well, either). Pittsburgh needs land use and building rules that will unlock growth without radically changing the culture and character of the city and its neighborhoods.
The question is whether this reform will be piecemeal and scattershot, or comprehensive and cohesive.
It’s a perfect moment to consider a total reboot of zoning in Pittsburgh: a shift from so-called “Euclidean” zoning, which focuses entirely on the use of land and the buildings placed on the land, toward a “form-based” code, which emphasizes the design of the buildings themselves, and their relationships to public spaces, as opposed to what goes on inside the buildings.
Think of it like focusing on how the hardware looks and feels rather than what exactly the software is doing.
While a completely form-based system would be impractical to implement in an older, built-out city like Pittsburgh, elements of this way of thinking about zoning can create tremendous opportunities for creativity in development and vibrancy in communities that the current zoning code smothers.
An unusual corner
The corner of Bryant Street and Highland Avenue in Highland Park is one of the most eclectic and vibrant in residential Pittsburgh. Under the current zoning code, however, it shouldn’t exist.
Sitting at the edge of the Bryant Street business district, this corner is zoned for low-density single-family residential. But you’ll actually find a beautiful turn-of-the-20th-century apartment building called the Eaglemoor and a popular coffee shop called Tazza D’Oro, neither of which are in keeping with the strict separation of uses defined in the zoning code.
Yet no one could credibly argue that the Eaglemoor and Tazza D’Oro detract from the Highland Park community in any way. Just the opposite: They’re essential parts of what makes the neighborhood distinctive, in keeping with its historic aesthetic while enhancing the public spaces around them. The two buildings also play off each other: The 21-unit apartment building provides customers for the coffee shop, and the coffee shop provides an amenity that enhances the value of the apartments.
Pittsburgh’s traditional zoning code, strict even by the standards of such systems, all but prohibits this kind of dynamic land use, outside of narrowly defined mixed-use zones. In fact, Pittsburgh defines 130 land use types across 24 possible zones, meaning its use table has 3,120 entries. Add in the 5 possible permission categories, and you get 15,600 possible regulations.
It doesn’t have to be this way.
A new approach
Here’s how the urban planning website Planetizen describes an alternative model of zoning, which was just being developed when Pittsburgh imposed its current code in 1999: “Form-based codes address the relationship between building facades and the public realm, the form and mass of buildings in relation to one another, and the scale and types of streets and blocks. … [They are] based on the belief that the form of buildings is more important than the use in determining community character.”
In other words, it’s more important that a neighborhood looks cohesive, with coherent public spaces and building shapes, sizes and setbacks, than that (for instance) coffee shops or rowhouses or small offices are kept strictly separated from single-family homes. This allows for more organic development patterns, with land uses naturally interspersed where they make sense, rather than where the city decrees they must be.
Cranberry Township, Butler County, adopted a form-based code in 2008 and describes it like this: It “places the physical form of a construction project ahead of its intended use, leading to more efficient, pedestrian-oriented building patterns suitable for mixed uses.” Obviously, the fact that Republican-dominated Cranberry has adopted this approach shows that it crosses partisan and ideological lines.
But the Cranberry example also points to one of the difficulties of applying a form-based code to Pittsburgh: They’re much easier to implement where communities are being built from scratch, rather in in mature built-out cities. That’s because writing a code that actually applies to the existing built environment, while being narrow enough to be useful and flexible enough to be practical, is very hard.
A too-strict form-based code can make development harder by forcing expensive design choices on developers and requiring them through even more complicated and subjective bureaucratic reviews than traditional zoning codes. A too-loose one, on the other hand, fails to order the built environment at all while adding unnecessary administrative complexity.
Denver was an early adopter of form-based zoning, but its 1,500-page code is at least as difficult to navigate as Pittsburgh’s 24 zone/130 use code.
A rare opportunity
We believe that a well-executed form-based code is likely to be superior, potentially substantially so, to this city’s existing code. But a badly executed form-based code is likely to be worse, potentially substantially so.
At a moment when Pittsburgh’s land use is being reconsidered in the most serious way in a generation, civic leaders would benefit from studying the form-based option, and seeing what lessons could be applied to a revamped code.
Specifically, we suspect that significantly simplified land use regulations — that is, fewer categories and zoning types with more use permitted in more places -— could be supplemented by form-based standards that ensure that any diverse uses in currently uniform areas fit snugly in the community’s character.
Hybrid codes come with problems of their own: No approach to land use is perfect. But Pittsburgh’s current approach is unusually straightjacketing. To achieve effective reform all alternatives should be on the table, with the goal of creating a code that unlocks the potential of Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods and unleashes the creativity of its most ambitious residents.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.