We applaud Mayor Corey O’Connor and the Heinz Endowments for partnering to defray the cost to taxpayers of Pittsburgh’s overly expensive comprehensive plan. While the city still paid far too much for the project, especially the absurd $2.6 million for an essentially invisible community engagement process, this grant allows the in-progress plan to get to the finish line while giving taxpayers a discount.

We consistently supported the creation of such a plan, which has potentially big benefits, both in guiding development and for securing private- and public-sector grants. But the actual plan was one of the most frustrating boondoggles of the Gainey administration. Pittsburgh 2050’s proposed price tag of $6 million was way out of keeping with similar projects in other cities.

Unfortunately, however, despite extensive debate, in early 2024 City Council approved the entire package. The result, as the Editorial Board predicted, was the evaporation of the $2.6 million “community engagement” budget on unaccountable giveaways to community organizations. Meanwhile, the technical work on the plan, at a high-but-not-extreme price point of $3.5 million, occurred quietly in the background.

This was all particularly problematic given the financial straits the city was in. The plan’s expenses — at least the technical part — might have been tolerable for a city with money to spare. But Pittsburgh was no longer that city.

Advertise with us

By the end of last year, City Council was (finally) fed up, and tried to claw back some of the approved expenditures. This was ill-fated: Council cannot unilaterally change or void previously approved contracts. And in any event, the plan itself was far enough along that pulling the plug would be even more wasteful, resulting in a large overpayment for an incomplete product.

The only prudent and fiscally responsible option was to see the plan through.

The question became whether the city could benefit from a completed comprehensive plan while shifting some of the exorbitant costs off of taxpayers. And the O’Connor administration derived a solution: partner with the city’s foundation community.

Philanthropy — even in a city like Pittsburgh, which has the second-most foundation dollars per capita in America — can’t be a deus ex machina for every problem. That’s not what foundations are for: Even they will eventually run out of money if they say “yes” too often. But to help a cash-strapped city complete a pricey project with potentially big benefits falls right into the philanthropic wheelhouse.

These are the kinds of partnerships, not just with foundations but with the private sector more generally, that cities like Pittsburgh need to make in order to thrive.

Advertise with us

As for the comprehensive plan itself, we hope and expect O’Connor to place his stamp on it. One reservation we had about the proposal was that it locks in one mayoral administration’s priorities for the next 25 years. If the comprehensive plan is adopted, all development in the city will have to be done in keeping with it.

After the voters spoke in last year’s election, it’s clear that any plan that represent Pittsburghers must include both the priorities of the mayor elected in 2021 and those of the mayor elected in 2025. Both men represent aspects of what Pittsburghers, broadly, are looking for in their city. Therefore, both should have a hand in guiding the plan’s development.

The way the comprehensive plan came to be was far from perfect, but the finished product — with an assist from the Heinz Endowments — could still profit Pittsburgh for many years to come.