When Fenway Sports Group (FSG) closed its deal to buy the Pittsburgh Penguins at the very end of 2021, Pittsburghers felt both optimism and trepidation.
On the one hand, the international sports conglomerate, owner of the Boston Red Sox and the Liverpool Football Club, would bring significant experience and deep pockets to the storied small-market franchise.
On the other, it was unclear how and whether the Boston-based company wanted to grow a community asset or just extract profit, especially given the sensitive obligations to the Lower Hill that come with owning the Penguins.
With FSG’s selling the Penguins after four tumultuous years with an $800 million profit, the skeptics have been vindicated.
Professional sports franchises are, in one aspect, businesses like any others. They have balance sheets and payroll and obligations to shareholders like any other corporation.
Yet they are not like other businesses in another aspect. They are civic assets, which implies honoring their responsibilities to the community that sustains them, and whose identity they help to form. We have made this argument with regard to the Pirates, and the reluctance of that team’s ownership to risk easy profits by spending enough to field a competitive lineup. (We are cautiously optimistic about the squad’s young stars this year.)
When FSG acquired the Penguins, therefore, it acquired more than an asset that could be quantified using a variety of spreadsheets. Rather, it acquired a stake in and responsibility for the civic life of southwestern Pennsylvania.
This was all the more serious in this case, in which FSG chose to inherit responsibility for the stalled and controversial redevelopment of the Lower Hill, scoured seven decades ago for the construction of the Penguins’ first home, the Civic Arena. The team received rights to redevelop the 28-acre site as part of the deal that built PPG Paints Arena nearly 20 years ago.
While the FNB Tower was completed on Fenway’s watch, and the Citizens at the Wylie music venue broke ground, the remainder of the site remains essentially untouched. It’s one of the most obvious urban scars in America.
It’s fair to say that the team’s previous owners, headlined by Mario Lemieux and Ron Burkle, also failed to develop the plot — and had much longer to make progress than FSG, which also contended with the aftermath of the COVID pandemic. But making progress — much more than it did — was part of FSG’s pitch, and the promise made to Pittsburgh. After all, it was said at the time of the sale, FSG had successfully developed land around Fenway Park in Boston.
But Pittsburgh never benefited.
As FSG prepares to exit the city, some civic leaders, including members of the Sports and Exhibition Authority board, have suggested that the company should give Pittsburgh a small slice of its $800 million windfall — maybe enough to grease the skids on some Lower Hill projects. It would be the right and just thing to do, given all that this city contributed to FSG’s big payday — $200 million a year — but we doubt the company will do that.
Such a payment would admit what businesses like FSG can’t afford to: that they have real responsibilities beyond their own balance sheets. But morally they do — as do all owners of civic assets, whose thriving is entwined with that of the communities they inhabit and serve.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.