A new report from City Controller Rachael Heisler, who also serves as the controller for Pittsburgh Public Schools, regarding careless procurement practices provides yet more evidence that the district’s administration, governance and culture is severely compromised. While the district should certainly implement the reforms suggested by Heisler, we continue to insist that state intervention is necessary to save PPS from itself.
Heisler’s report tracked the haphazard procurement process for a single contract, which demonstrated a startling lack of structure and professionalism in handling a multimillion-dollar expense. This report follows a more general analysis from the Controller’s Office last October, which revealed that the district uses competitive bidding only to the minimum extent required by law, and rarely requests for proposals (RFPs), even for major expenses.
This continues to take place in the context of a school system staring down insolvency, with annual deficits increasing and reserves dwindling, even as its board has refused to decide on a cost-saving school-closure plan. Heisler’s reports point to a chronic problem in the district’s institutional culture: a heedless resistance to change, even in the face of crisis.
Comfort zone
The initial controller’s report from last October laid bare a PPS procurement system that is clearly not designed to get the best deal for taxpayers — and to conserve resources so they can be used to further Pittsburgh schoolchildren’s educations.
The topline numbers are startling: Heisler’s office identified 498 contracts awarded by the district between the beginning of 2024 and mid-2025, totaling about $96 million in spending. Of those, only 44, or less than 10%, were awarded on the basis of a competitive process. And the controller could only match four, or less than 1%, to an RFP.
Those competitive bids, meanwhile, were often little more than window-dressing. To quote the report, “the reality is that there is little competition for each bid. When looking through each contract with listed bids, it is regularly the same handful of contractors that bid on each posting.”
This strongly indicates habits of procurement based on relationships and remaining within a narrow comfort zone, rather than seeking real competition to provide better services at lower costs.
Here’s an example: In the wake of this report, at a school board meeting last November Board President Gene Walker asked a few questions about procurement, based on agenda items that didn’t seem quite to make sense — such as approving contracts backdated to a few months before the meeting.
In one case, he asked PPS Chief Operations Officer Mike McNamara why the board was being asked to approve an extension of an existing environmental abatement contract, instead of putting it out to bid. McNamara’s response was, in part, that “we’ve built a really good relationship” with the existing contractor and (somewhat ominously) that “it’s good to have contractors who understand the nuances of doing work for us.”
Valuing these things isn’t unreasonable, but when the entire system seems to run on these principles — simplicity, relationship, comfort, “understanding” — the institution will never respect the city’s taxpayers or serve the city’s children as well as it could.
Wasting money
In this week’s report, Heisler also zoomed in on a single contract, in which PPS paid over $100,000 a month to The Wilson Group in O’Hara Township to “manage the District’s document output environment of copy machines, printers and scanners.” There does not appear to have been an RFP or any other bids solicited for the contract, which was signed for five years in 2016.
When the contract was set to expire in 2021, the district prepared to extend it at the same terms for another five years, for $6.1 million in total. But another possible vendor, which felt it could do the work at a lower price point, reached out to the district’s Chief Technology Officer Mark Stuckey and Chief Financial Officer Ron Joseph to ask to meet, and if an RFP would be released. The vendor got no response.
So the vendor wrote to then-PPS board member Kevin Carter, who responded by rebuking the vendor for making contact with him, and telling the vendor to reach out to the CFO. And round and round we go.
Eventually, the vendor was able to present a proposal to PPS at a cost of $69,000 a month, a discount of over 30% on its current spending. But instead of initiating a formal bid process, the district went back to The Wilson Group and secured a lower price from them, down to $85,000 monthly. But it turned out the contract had an “escalator clause,” which district officials missed, bringing today’s costs right back up to $99,000.
There are multiple lessons here. First, even an informal bid process resulted in cost savings to the district. Second, a formal bid process would almost certainly have secured much more savings. Third, thie ad hoc procurement system privileges relationships over cost effectiveness, and insiders over newcomers, leaving it very susceptible to graft.
Test of priorities
While it’s impossible to pinpoint just how much savings PPS is missing out on, the October report estimated that a formal bidding process for the most expensive contracts could result in savings from 20% to 30%. For the period of the study, from Jan. 2024 to Aug. 2025, that would mean $15 million.
Meanwhile, the district’s board just passed a 2% tax hike, which will raise about $4 million from Pittsburgh property owners. It’s money that’s supposed to be funding education, but much of it is funding waste.
PPS asserts that it’s fulfilling its duties under state procurement law — but that’s not good enough. Heisler rightly recommends that the district should set up a professional procurement office, whose costs would be more than offset by contract savings.
But that would require admitting that the way PPS has always done things isn’t working — something its governance and culture strongly resists. Whether the district is willing to embrace procurement best practices will signal whether protecting itself, or serving Pittsburgh, is its top priority.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.