Pittsburgh’s legacy systems to renovate sidewalks, like the walkways themselves, are broken. The assumption that everyday homeowners can and will fix their own sidewalks, let alone that they even understand their responsibilities to public rights-of-way, no longer holds. And it’s making the city less safe, and less attractive, to navigate for everyone.
Recent efforts to make sidewalk renovations more accessible for more property owners by leveraging the power of city government have been a step in the right direction. Indeed, if these changes are brought to completion by the O’Connor administration, in the form of a permanent repair fund, they will and should be remembered as a signature achievement of his predecessor, Ed Gainey, who initiated forward-thinking sidewalk reform.
Crumbling sidewalks are a major quality-of-life issue. They’re potentially dangerous for everyone, but especially for the disabled and elderly, who can easily trip in a way that will cause serious injury. They’re particularly troublesome for parents with strollers and anybody with wheeled mobility devices, who either have to go into the street or find an entirely different route when sidewalks are impassible.
These eyesores also acclimate Pittsburghers to shabbiness. That is, they make it seem like our public spaces aren’t worth taking care of, when they should be something everyone can be proud of.
Like about three-quarters of large American cities, Pittsburgh holds property owners responsible for sidewalk upkeep. In an age where wealth was more broadly shared and concrete services were more affordable, this was a sustainable system. But today large swaths of the city’s sidewalks are in disrepair, disproportionately in lower-income neighborhoods that already suffer from weak investment and shoddy infrastructure.
In 2023, then-Mayor Ed Gainey championed legislation creating the Sidewalk and Curb Repair Program, which began as a pilot and was expanded citywide two years later. The program leverages the size and scope of city government to resolve residents’ dangerous sidewalks while sharply limiting the time and money they have to spend on the project.
First, the city does the work itself, through a contractor, at a price point below what the typical homeowner can find on the market — typically about $200 per square yard, at least a 50% discount from prevailing prices. For reference, a complete sidewalk replacement for a house with 30 feet of frontage would require about 15 square yards, or $3,000 at the city’s price point.
Second, the city offers every property owner a five-year zero-interest payment plan — and low-income homeowners rebates of up to 75%, in addition to the payment plan. Residents who opt into this program also have their permit fees waived, saving at least $295. Altogether, this makes it much easier for private landowners to provide the public good of safe, attractive walkways for all.
Indeed, at scale this program could essentially replace the city’s legacy private sidewalk repair scheme with a de facto public one — where government facilitates the work and the financing, while still recouping most of its costs. In a 2025 letter to City Council, then-director of the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure Kim Lucas estimated that, over time, building up a $50 million fund through annual appropriations and property-owner payments would allow the city to replace sidewalks on a regular schedule.
That’s probably a bit ambitious, given the city’s financial situation, but the concept is sound. The days are gone when private homeowners can be expected consistently to be able to afford to repair public rights-of-way. A hybrid public-private system will ultimately be the only way to ensure sidewalks, and the neighborhoods whose quality of life they make possible, are maintained in good repair across Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.