New data reported by the Post-Gazette’s Madaleine Rubin and Jimmy Cloutier demonstrate the deepening crisis of property taxation across Allegheny County: Even as the market value of real estate has climbed, the assessed value of that property — on which county, municipal and school district finances rest — is declining.

That is, the tax base for local government is collapsing, with the predictable result being property tax increases at every level of government.

This report adds to the growing pile of evidence in favor of a countywide property reassessment and, more specifically, in favor of regular automatic reassessments. Long gaps between so-called “base years” — that is, the year of the most recent full reassessment -— necessitate a complex system of estimation and appeals that fails to keep up with changes in the market.

Specifically, these long gaps ensure that increases in the market value of real estate are not reflected in tax revenues. Therefore, as the cost of providing government services increases due to inflation and other factors, revenues have been stagnant or declining. The only option is to raise millage rates.

Advertise with us

Only a full reset — that is, a countywide assessment called by County Executive Sara Innamorato — followed by deep reforms of the taxation-and-assessment system will restore some fairness and predictability to the system. Allegheny County’s long-term competitiveness depends on it.

Reassessment paradox

There is an apparent paradox at the heart of the conversation about property assessments and taxation. On the one hand, Pennsylvania’s anti-windfall provisions ensure that taxing bodies can’t profit from a reassessment. Beyond a tiny bit of wiggle room, just a few percent, a reassessment cannot be a broad-based tax hike.

On the other hand, the Editorial Board has joined real estate experts in arguing that failing to reassess is, in part, responsible for declining tax revenues, which has necessitated tax hikes. That certainly seems to imply that a reassessment would boost revenues — that is, that it would be a tax hike.

But that doesn’t actually follow. Here’s why.

Yes, it’s confusing

There are two ways to bring a property’s assessed value, which is the number to which the millage rate is applied in calculating taxes, in line with its market value. The first is a countywide reassessment, when every property is ratcheted to (roughly) its current market value. The second is an individual property appeal, which can be filed either by property owners (if they believe the assessed value is too high) or by taxing bodies (if they believe the assessed value is too low).

Advertise with us

On appeal, the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review applies the “common level ratio” to the market value to derive a new assessed value. This value is meant to be comparable with other values from the base year, in this case 2012.

Over time, however, market values tend to drift further away from the base-year assessed value, meaning these appeals become more frequent and the potential corrections more severe. This was exacerbated by the COVID pandemic, which caused major reductions in the market value of commercial real estate, prompting waves of appeals year after year that reduced assessed values by over a billion dollars in Pittsburgh alone, especially in the Golden Triangle.

At the same time, however, residential real estate mostly got more expensive, which should have offset the commercial losses, allowing governments to continue to fund services. But those assessed values are only ratcheted into place piecemeal by taxing-body appeals, which tend to occur only when a property is sold: the “newcomers’ tax.”

Rubin and Cloutier report that residential appeals in recent years have increased the tax base by $270 million — but commercial appeals have reduced it by eight times that figure.

This means that many thousands of properties, largely in high-growth parts of the county, have remained chronically underassessed at their 14-year-old base year. This has starved local governments of resources, necessitating tax hikes.

Advertise with us

As Rubin and Cloutier showed, the county’s collapsing tax base has resulted in $25 million in lost revenues last year at the county and municipal levels alone. When school districts, which typically have the highest millage rates of all, are added in, the losses would be tens of millions greater. This is why 12 municipalities (including Pittsburgh) raised taxed for 2026, while a majority of school districts — 28 of 43 — have done the same in the last 12 months.

If reassessments had occurred regularly, assessed values would have kept up with the market, keeping revenues more consistent and mitigating the need for rate increases.

Dentists and mechanics

A reassessment now won’t solve this problem, but it will reset the system to reduce unpredictability. And the longer it takes, the more local-government tax hikes will be “locked in” by the reassessment, making the end result more painful for more people.

In other words, while calling the reassessment will cause financial pain for some homeowners, delaying the reassessment is making that pain worse.

This gets at one of the underlying problems of Pennsylvania’s ad hoc assessment system: Countywide reassessments happen so infrequently that they seem like special events, and feel like earthquakes, when they should be little more than routine maintenance of the tax system.

Advertise with us

It’s like how taking your car in for maintenance every 30,000 miles, or going to the dentist every six months, results in less severe (and expensive) findings than putting those visits off for years and years. But the longer you take between visits, the more daunting actually going in becomes, because you know there’s a much bigger chance you’re going to get expensive news.

Allegheny County needs to go to the dentist, even though it will be painful, because its teeth are only getting worse. Then it needs to make regular visits, to avoid this problem in the future. Only regular reassessments, either in county or state law, will keep the county from getting in this situation again.