Heavy snowfall may make for picturesque scenes and great fun for children, but for municipal budgets it’s nothing but a problem. Pittsburgh’s expensive vehicle fleet issues have already made headlines, but there’s another, less obvious problem facing the city’s finances: the cost of overtime for the city workers who cleared the streets of snow, sleet and ice.

If you thought the city’s overtime budgeting issues were fixed by City Council during its December standoff with former Mayor Ed Gainey, you’d be mostly right — but only with regard to the Department of Public Safety. Overtime for the Department of Public Works, however, remained dangerously under-budgeted. And after this snow, not to mention the coming NFL Draft, there’s likely to be another million-dollar shortfall.

This will, once again, threaten to throw the city’s ostensibly balanced budget out of whack, and force the O’Connor administration to dip deeper into its reserves.

The city’s overtime budgeting issues came to the forefront in 2025, and to a lesser degree in 2024, but the crisis had been slowly building for longer. An analysis of the two biggest overtime-spending departments, Public Safety and Public Works, demonstrates how budgeted spending went down while actual spending went way up during the Gainey administration.

Advertise with us

The starting point was already problematic. The 2022 budget, the last developed by the Peduto administration, included $40.3 million in premium pay for these two departments. But 2021 spending was actually $44.5 million — 10% more than the budget. In other words, the budget used “best-case” thinking to assume that overtime spending would go down by more than $4 million in 2022.

But it went up, by about $3 million. The budget was overshot by 19%, or $7.5 million.

For the next three years, the problem only got worse. The 2023 budget assumed 16% less overtime spending than what actually happened in 2022, but the real number ended up being 3% higher, a $9 million (22%) shortfall.

Then the 2024 budget projected spending 19% less than in 2023, but in 2024 the city actually spent 8% more. That was a $13.5 million miss, or 34% above budget.

And then there was the 2025 plan, which budgeted a whopping 30% less in overtime for Public Safety and Public Works than 2024 spending. But the actual spend — according to new data circulated by the Office of the City Controller — was 9% more than the previous year. The shortfall is over $20 million, with spending overshooting the budget by 55%.

Advertise with us

The main reason for the increases in spending has been staffing limitations in Public Safety. But Public Works overtime has also jumped, related to everything from weather events to the deteriorating condition of the city’s infrastructure.

This brings us to the 2026 budget, as amended by City Council, which refused to let the Gainey administration continue to underfund overtime — at least in Public Safety. The 2026 budget for EMS, Fire and Police is roughly in line with the 2025 spend.

But it’s a different story in Public Works, where the budget is nearly 40% lower, about $1.6 million, than last year’s spending. The heavy snow, which required not just extensive plowing but its physical removal by dump truck, was likely the most extensive DPW operation since 2010. It’s all but certain this year’s overtime will be higher than last year’s — not to mention the costs for private contractors.

The overruns are likely to exceed $1 million. It’s a lot better than previous years, but that’s not good enough. Going forward, the city must fix its Public Works overtime budget, as well, and stop planning for only the best-case scenario.