Nearly four years after a mass shooting at a party hosted at an Airbnb rental in East Allegheny, the City of Pittsburgh has yet to pass enforceable regulations on short-term rentals. That, finally, may be about to change.
Pittsburgh is one of the few large cities that currently enforces no specific regulations regarding short-term rentals — that is, single rooms or entire units (homes or apartments) that are let out by their owners via listing sites such as Airbnb or Vrbo, typically for between one night and one week. This issue rose to the surface after the deadly Easter Sunday 2022 shootout, but its effects run much deeper than one violent outburst.
From its consequences for housing affordability to neighborhood cohesion, the unregulated short-term rental market has quietly (and in some areas quite loudly) become a significant part of the city’s life and culture. As in cities around the country and around the world, there’s no good reason to continue to allow this system to operate without rules.
These rules must be well-calibrated, because short-term rental regulations are also associated with reductions in residential construction, an outcome this city in particular, which is desperate for growth, should try to avoid, or at least to mitigate.
City Council tied its first attempt at short-term rental regulation to the question of a registry for all rentals, short- and long-term, which remains tied up in the courts, and thus cannot be enforced. Last month, however, councilmembers Deb Gross, Anthony Coghill and Bobby Wilson introduced new, standalone short-term rental rules.
It’s a good pair of bills — one describing a licensing program and another amending the city’s zoning code — and with a few tweaks they will be ready for a signature by Mayor Corey O’Connor.
Wild West
Across the country, large numbers of short-term rentals have become associated with higher overall housing prices, both rental and sales, because they take otherwise livable housing off the market. In Pittsburgh alone, for instance, there are around 2,000 short-term rental listings, with another 1,000 across the rest of Allegheny County.
Besides increasing costs for residents, neighborhoods with high concentrations of short-term rentals — in Pittsburgh, this means several parts of the East End as well as the flats of both the North Side and the South Side — can struggle to form cohesive communities, due to the large number of mostly empty properties periodically occupied by people just passing through. At the very worst, these rentals are abused by their occupants, leading to disturbances from loud music to violence.
Meanwhile, these short-term rentals are increasingly owned by people from outside the community, or not by people at all — that is, by large firms that see in Pittsburgh’s properties opportunities to extract value, with no concern for the city and its people.
For these reasons, we broadly support policies that would force short-term rentals to be licensed by the city, thereby subjecting them to rules and regulations like any other lodging.
License to rent
The Gross-Coghill-Wilson bills require that every short-term rental be licensed by the city. The licensing itself is not terribly onerous — it requires a good deal of paperwork, but no physical inspection besides a visit to confirm maximum occupancy — but it comes with a variety of rules.
The critical regulations include a 28-day cap on individual stays (to ensure the short-term rentals don’t become regular long-term rentals), limitations on the number of short-term rentals that can be licensed within a building (to prevent the creation of essentially unregulated hotels), and requirements that hosts keep a log of guests (so authorities can know who stayed where during which times) and that the owner or property manager live within 25 miles of the rental (to ensure a responsible person is nearby to address problems).
Violations would result in a warning, followed by revocation of the license. The penalty for letting out an unlicensed rental would be up to $500 per unit per month.
We’d like to see that 25-mile figure pared down: Zelienople and Greensburg would qualify under this rule, which is too far away to be meaningfully responsive to issues with properties in Pittsburgh. We’d also like to see the rules for numbers of short-term rentals in large multi-unit buildings shifted to a proportion of the building, rather than the current proposal that limits them to five in buildings with more than 20 units (and two in buildings with 20 or fewer units). This would be fairer for very large buildings, where the five-unit limit is too low.
Zoning adjustments
The companion zoning legislation may present the bigger barrier to entry for new and existing short-term rentals. While this property use would be permitted by right in mixed-use and certain dense residential districts, its would only be allowed by a special exception in remaining residential areas, representing the vast majority of such districts. Special exceptions require a public hearing before the Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA).
It makes sense that owners who desire to use their property in this manner should prove to a public authority that the use “will not create detrimental impacts on the surrounding properties.” But we are concerned that this might favor corporate property owners, who can navigate the process — which can take up to two months — more easily than mom-and-pop rental owners.
An alternative would be to allow short-term rentals by “administrator’s exception,” which would only require the city’s zoning administrator, an individual official, to sign off. City Council should solicit expert testimony on this matter, which could make a significant difference in how many property owners seek the short-term rental exception.
Broadly, however, the proposed legislation includes thoughtful and necessary regulation without unduly burdening the short-term rental market, which should continue to have a place in Pittsburgh. With some adjustments and after careful consideration of the details, City Council should approve the legislation.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.