The Pittsburgh Public School District is in a perilous situation. Some closures and mergers of existing schools will be necessary to respond to the city’s demographic realities and to mitigate a structural budget deficit. But the district’s administrative leadership has proven unable to convince parents, or a majority of the nine-member board, that its plan is anything better than (badly) managed decline.

Meanwhile, as the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has chronicled, PPS officials have resisted attempts to force transparency under Pennsylvania’s Right-to-Know Law, leaving parents in the dark about how the “Future-Ready Facilities Plan” came about and what, exactly, it will entail for their children’s education. We can now add that the district has claimed, in response to a public records request, that many supporting documents, such as demographic projections, “do not exist.

In other words, despite the time and expense put into the plan, and the trust PPS has asked parents and the broader community to place in it, the rigor of the preparations for merging and closing schools remains unclear, if not doubtful.

On Wednesday evening, after this article will have gone to print, the PPS board voted whether or not to return the Future-Ready plan to this year’s agenda. Whatever the board decided, this episode, at a turning point in the district’s history, has demonstrated that the culture and governance at PPS is not prepared to meet this difficult moment. We believe an external analysis of the district’s structures and leadership, convened by Mayor Corey O’Connor and Governor Josh Shapiro, is necessary — with an eye toward significant reforms to PPS governance that can only be initiated in Harrisburg.

Advertise with us

New year, new board

In late November, the board turned down the “Future-Ready Facilities Plan” that district officials had spent over two years constructing, while spending several hundred thousand dollars in consulting fees. It was a blow to Superintendent Wayne Walters and Board President Gene Walker, both of whom had boldly spearheaded the plan early in their tenures with the troubled school system.

The vote was six to three, but Walker had voted ‘no’ strategically, because only ‘no’ voters are permitted to return a defeated item to the agenda. In other words, the real vote was five to four.

Between then and now, however, three new board members have been sworn in: Tawana Cook Parnell replacing Sylvia Wilson, Erikka Grayson replacing Sala Udin and Eva Diodati replacing Jamie Piotrowski. Wilson had been one of three ‘yes’ votes on the closure, but Udin and Piotrowski had been ‘no’ votes. That means the board is split three ways: three ‘yes,’ three ‘no’ and three newcomers.

It was into this political dynamic that Walters and Walker reintroduced the Future-Ready plan. It was unclear what kind of changes, if any, had been made from the version voted down two months ago.

It’s an impossible situation created by poor leadership. Rightsizing the district’s real estate footprint is necessary. But the plan is visibly deficient.

Advertise with us

‘Does not exist’

Just before the November vote, the Editorial Board described how PPS parent Armin Schikorra had been stonewalled by the district in his attempts to seek some rather basic information about the data and assumptions underlying the Future-Ready plan. The district had denied his request for failing to use the proper form, when it had no posted policy requiring any particular form, in violation of the state Right-to-Know Law.

Eventually, in mid-January, PPS responded with the discouraging news that, beyond already public documents, nothing he asked for exists.

This includes the following documents:

  • “Any comprehensive financial plans, pro formas, or multi-year forecasts for the [Future-Ready] plan, including revenue and expenditure projections and underlying assumptions.”
  • ”All enrollment or demographic projections used for the plan … including the assumptions and inputs (birth rates, housing turnover, charter migration, retention).”
  • ”Analyses or estimates of transportation cost savings, vendor expenses, or route reductions connected to the Future Ready plan.”
  • ”Any data showing projected changes in average or median walking distances for students (by grade and/or school) [and] maps or models illustrating the new or revised walk zones.”
  • ”Any staffing models, internal tables, or communications specifying the number of World Language teachers to be hired under the Future Ready Plan.”

Now, in a few of these areas, there does exist public information — such as financial forecasts through 2030 and some specific figures for transportation cost savings. But the existence of these projections implies (or should imply) the existence of underlying data, models and assumptions, which are largely what Schikorra was after, in order to be able to judge the trustworthiness of the public information.

The district’s claim that these simply don’t exist raises two troubling possibilities: Either the public information about the Future-Ready plan was based in large part on guesswork, or PPS is still stonewalling. We are particularly concerned about the apparent lack of demographic data and modeling, because the district declined to hire a professional demographer and claimed to have performed this work in-house.

Advertise with us

Help from Harrisburg

School closures and mergers are necessary, but they require a great deal of public buy-in — that is, public trust. And, due to the district’s own actions, that is in very short supply.

It seems, at this point, very unlikely that PPS can pull off a rightsizing plan without alienating thousands of parents and other stakeholders. Or it may not be able to pull it off at all.

Which raises the question of whether the district, as currently governed, is equipped to fulfill its responsibilities generally. We believe it’s time to investigate alternatives, including state financial takeover or changes to the selection and composition of the board. Both would require state legislation.

But an outside voice, and maybe force, is clearly necessary to right this ship. We’d like to see the city’s legislative delegation in Harrisburg join O’Connor and Shapiro in forming a group to study all available options. PPS is too important to Pittsburgh’s survival to allow it to flounder forever.