Municipal and school district taxes are increasing, in some cases significantly, across southwestern Pennsylvania. Last week, the Post-Gazette’s Jacob Geanous reported on tax hikes around the region, from a 9% increase (1 mill) in small Verona on the Allegheny River to 56% (about 1.5 mills) in Moon Township.

Municipal leaders explained the necessity of the hikes in a variety of ways, but increases in the cost of providing government services predominated. In many cases, local governments and school districts have held the line on taxes while depleting reserves, to avoid the political cost of a tax hike. This year also saw the expiration of federal pandemic relief funds, which many local authorities — including the City of Pittsburgh — used to juice operating budgets, without planning for how to fill the gap when the funds went away.

Across the Pittsburgh region, the bill is finally coming due.

Beneath the surface, however, there are larger structural forces applying pressure to municipal and school budgets. These are Pennsylvania’s (and, in particular, Allegheny County’s) property assessment system and fragmented governance. Both of these make it difficult for local governments to keep up revenues with inflation while also keeping costs low. Tax hikes at the local (and county) level will continue to plague the region until these problems are addressed.

Advertise with us

Reassessment debacle

Property tax revenues should, roughly speaking, keep up with the cost of government services. That’s because increases in the value of real estate should result in higher revenues, allowing governments to cover costs that rise with inflation.

But that process is short-circuited if real estate values are not consistently reassessed, leaving revenues stagnant while costs rise. Eventually, only an increase in tax rates will suffice.

Consider Allegheny County, which hasn’t reassessed since 2012. As the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has consistently argued, in an urban-suburban county with roughly 600,000 parcels, this is simply far too long. In the meantime, market and demographic conditions have changed dramatically, leaving many property-owners under-assessed and some over-assessed, with the divergence between market and assessed values increasing day by day.

This leaves local governments and school districts with only one way to make up some of the difference, loved by lawyers who get the business and hated by everyone else: appealing the values of purchased properties, known as the “newcomers tax.” Under this costly, unfair, ad hoc system, new property owners end up paying substantially higher taxes than long-time owners, while taxing bodies still collect far less than they would if every property were simply reassessed on a regular basis.

Indeed, Pennsylvania is the only state with such a system: Everywhere else, there are regular, scheduled reassessments that don’t depend on nervous county officials or courts to trigger. Pennsylvania must adopt this common-sense system, which helps to keep tax rates down by allowing property values to do the work.

Advertise with us

Until then, however, the spate of tax hikes is yet another reason County Executive Sara Innamorato should call the reassessment she campaigned on (at least at first) as soon as possible. Further delay will allow more municipal and school tax increases to be “locked in” by the reassessment process. It will be far more difficult, politically, for taxing bodies to make these moves after the reassessment.

Too many governments

The complexity of the reassessment question points to another underlying problem that keeps the Pittsburgh region’s taxes high: There are simply too many taxing bodies.

It is far more expensive to provide government services, from trash pickup to street cleaning to public safety, in dozens of small municipalities than in a few bigger ones. Allegheny County’s famous fragmentation, with part or all of 130 municipalities and 43 school districts, discourages the creation of economies of scale that would allow services to be rendered much more efficiently.

This is one of the most important factors applying upward pressure to local tax rates in the Pittsburgh region. It also results in absurd inequities, which can be seen clearly in Geanous’s reporting on tax hikes around the region.

Take Verona, with a population of about 2,500 in one-half square mile in the Allegheny Valley. Its borough council passed a 1 mill tax increase, but that’s only a 9% hike because the rate was already 9.7 mills. Meanwhile, Franklin Park — population 15,500 over 13.5 square miles in the North Hills — also bumped its millage by 1 mill, but that was actually a 63% hike because the original rate was (incredibly) only 1.59 mills.

Advertise with us

So, Verona’s rate is now 10.7 mills, about four times’ Franklin Park’s 2.59 mills. Yet, according to county data, the median property value in Verona is $52,100, while in Franklin Park it’s $280,000. So a mill in Franklin Park generates more than five times more revenue per property than a mill in Verona.

In practice, this means that smaller communities with lower property values must be taxed much more aggressively than larger communities with higher property values, stifling struggling areas and helping already successful ones. This isn’t a matter of low-tax communities being better-run than high-tax ones; it’s a matter of arithmetic.

Holding Pittsburgh back

The Pittsburgh region is cursed with a disproportionate, if not unique, variety of factors applying upward pressure on property tax rates. Among these are a senseless property assessment system and eyewatering degrees of governmental fragmentation.

There are, on the other hand, very few factors, here or anywhere, that apply downward pressure on taxes. Excellent leadership is one such factor, but it’s hard to find and its emergence is unpredictable.

Another, much more reliable factor is growth — both economic and population. A bigger and more dynamic Pittsburgh region would see higher property values (especially in the commercial sector) and less need for squeezing already dry communities for just enough revenue to keep going.

And one of the best ways to fertilize the region for growth would be solving, or at least mitigating, the structural problems that are both stifling dynamism and pushing taxes higher. Fixing the reassessment system and mitigating fragmented governance will be essential to any new resurgence in southwestern Pennsylvania.