After negotiations continued to the eleventh hour, on Sunday six members of Pittsburgh City Council voted to take the unfortunate but necessary step of raising taxes on city property owners. This budget crisis was partially the result of structural factors such as inflation, but its magnitude was greatly enhanced by the maladministration of Mayor Ed Gainey and the lack of oversight by City Council during his term in office.
While Gainey refused to take responsibility for the mess, six councilmembers — President Daniel Lavelle, Bob Charland, Deb Gross, Khari Mosley, Erika Strassberger and Barb Warwick — took their medicine and the hard vote to move city finances back toward sustainability.
However, the final increase of 20%, or 1.61 mils to raise roughly $28 million, was higher than what was strictly needed to resolve the current crisis. We believe more cuts to expenditures were available to Council, such as fully pausing transfers to the overflowing Stop the Violence Trust Fund, even on the very tight deadline under which it was working.
This imposes as even greater responsibility on the city’s legislature and Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor: They must govern in a manner that will not require another tax hike for a very long time. In other words, the city must live within its means, laser-focusing on the efficient administration of core services and facilitating the kind of economic growth that will generate greater revenues through shared prosperity, not through emergency tax increases.
That begins — as we insisted to County Executive Sara Innamorato after her 36% tax hike one year ago — with demonstrating good faith to taxpayers by looking for and finding whatever savings is available. In this regard, Councilwoman Gross’s statement that she doesn’t “see any more places to cut” does not suffice.
Because of Gainey’s insistence on his fake budget and Council’s own foot-dragging, the nine-member legislature only had a few weeks to study potential cuts. Further, as we have previously pointed out, the complexity of union regulations and the functioning of the government makes rushed personnel decisions imprudent or impossible.
But this doesn’t mean city government is perfectly lean; no one who has studied it for more than five minutes can believe that. O’Connor and Council should immediately empanel a working group, including experts from both the public and private sectors, to study where city government can save taxpayer resources, or put them to better use. Particular attention should be paid to services that are duplicative of, or in tension with, those provided by Allegheny County.
One of the reasons the final tax hike was higher than expected was the judgment that cutting spending — that is to say, layoffs — would be even more politically damaging than raising taxes. City leaders must overcome this stigma, or it will lead to cascading tax hikes that doom the city to stagnation or worse. Elected officials’ primary duty is to taxpayers, not public employees.
Speaking of duty, there is one last hurdle that must be overcome: Gainey must sign the tax ordinance and the budget, which corrected his false figures for overtime and utility expenses, or they will become law at midnight on Dec. 31. This is literally the last second before the current budget expires.
But doing so would acknowledge his poor governance. And so, as of this writing, the Mayor’s Office has not acknowledged Sunday’s votes and the bills remain unsigned.
In fact, City Council is prepared to meet nearly as the crystal ball drops in Times Square, in case they must override a last-second veto. This is how far the situation has deteriorated.
For the good of Pittsburgh, Mr. Mayor, sign the bills, and move on. Let us all move on.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.