After nearly four years of instability, Pittsburgh needs a permanent police chief. An apparent lapse of judgment by Jason Lando, the former Pittsburgh commander and Frederick, Md., chief to be nominated by Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor, does not appear to be enough to justify denying a chief to the city and its police officers.
Lando is alleged to have sent anonymous, abusive text messages to a retired corporal from the Frederick police department. A brief state investigation, triggered under Maryland law, was closed after finding “no violations of criminal law.”
Still, the situation, brought to light in recent days by WPXI-TV’s Rick Earle, requires thoughtful and thorough scrutiny by City Council, once Lando is officially nominated. Council members should particularly home in on how Lando will build respect and trust among officers in Pittsburgh, many of whom were previously his colleagues, when the conduct in question involves his treatment of a retired officer once under his command.
If Lando can successfully demonstrate that this issue is behind him, and that his relationships with the mayor-elect and the police force are strong and will be strengthened further, Council should feel comfortable confirming his nomination.
Frederick falling-out
The Frederick controversy stems, according to Lando, from a pattern of bad behavior by a now-retired corporal in the department, Daniel Sullivan. Lando has said that Sullivan refused to “accept responsibility for violating his oath as a police officer,” referring at least in part to a 2021 inappropriate-use-of-force incident. Sullivan initiated, according to Lando, a campaign of harassment against him.
Sullivan denies all of this. He describes his falling-out with Lando by reference to the case of Cpl. James Dodson, a Frederick officer arrested by Pennsylvania State Police in June on child pornography charges. Sullivan, who retired in 2023, publicly accused Lando of failing to pursue the Dodson matter aggressively and transparently.
For his part, Lando has said that his hands were tied during PSP’s lengthy investigation, during which Dodson remained on leave. Lando made a five-minute video to the Frederick community upon Dodson’s arrest.
This would have remained a local dispute until Sullivan began to receive profane anonymous text messages criticizing his efforts against Lando. These messages were sent via an app called Burner, which allows users to send messages from throwaway, or “burner,” phone numbers. There is compelling evidence linking the Burner account to Lando. An internal inquiry in Frederick was elevated, under Maryland law regarding investigations of police leaders, to the state.
Maryland prosecutors closed that case on Dec. 2, with a letter to Lando that they found “no violations of criminal law.”
A test of character
Lando’s alleged conduct is troubling. At best, it represents a lapse of judgment, to lash out at a one-time subordinate — no matter how obnoxious — in a manner at once passive-aggressive and threatening. At worst, it indicates a disqualifying inability to lead without resorting to intimidation and other illegitimate means.
It will be Lando’s task to prove to city leaders, specifically the members of Council who will vote on his nomination, that the episode is evidence of a temporary lapse and not an ongoing defect.
In his favor is that fact that, until this controversy, Lando’s public reputation was pristine. There is no visible evidence of a pattern of bad conduct, of pettiness, of retribution, of anything of that sort. It is certainly plausible that the circumstances in Frederick led to a single out-of-character and regrettable decision.
However: The position of police chief in a city like Pittsburgh will almost certainly present Lando with interpersonal conflicts and other stressors at least as intense as in Frederick, a city of about 80,000 people. That single, serious lapse may have been the first — but how will he handle the fractious, rudderless bureau here?
We don’t believe the Frederick incident is disqualifying in itself. It will be how Lando handles it, and himself, under scrutiny in Pittsburgh that should determine whether he’s up to leading this city’s police.
Beggars and choosers
The problem for Pittsburgh is that the city is desperate for police leadership, and there’s no option on the horizon besides Lando.
Pittsburgh is in this situation due to a shambolic police chief search that culminated in early 2023 in the selection of Larry Scirotto, a part-time NCAA basketball referee who had been investigated as chief in Ft. Lauderdale for discrimination against white-male officers. He stayed on until he began moonlighting on the hardcourt again, precipitating a crisis that ended with his resignation.
After Scirotto, deputy chief Christopher Ragland stepped into a role, before abruptly resigning due to conflict with some members of City Council. For the past nine months, Martin Devine has been serving as acting chief, but he doesn’t live in the city, disqualifying him from the permanent job. No other top brass live in the city, either.
Meanwhile, the second finalist in the 2022-2023 search was Ryan Lee of Boise, who had seriously injured a subordinate during a training exercise. The third finalist was Lando.
At the time, some city insiders expressed surprise and concern that Lando had been passed over: He had similar Pittsburgh experience to Scirotto — Lee had none — with none of the baggage. This is why he was widely expected to be tapped by O’Connor as top cop. He was the clearest choice — the only choice — for a stable leadership and a fresh start.
That has now been thrown into doubt.
Corey O’Connor shouldn’t abandon Lando, and City Council should approach him with an open mind. Specifically, they must press him for a public and comprehensive account of the Frederick controversy, and seek a detailed plan for how he would build trust among current Pittsburgh officers — and, crucially, recruit new ones. The only thing worse than inconsistent leadership would be bad leadership that further erodes morale and the bureau’s attractiveness to new recruits.
We don’t think there’s enough evidence to conclude that Lando would be worse than the status quo. Not yet.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.