One of the distinguishing aspects of the second Trump administration has been its pettiness. Besides being unbecoming in itself of the United States’ chief executive, it sets a dangerous precedent for future presidents to treat predecessors — and therefore, in essence, the ongoing working-out of the democratic process — as entirely expendable.

This habit of pettiness just this week touched former Pennsylvania Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine, who had served as President Joe Biden’s Assistant Secretary of Health. In this role, Levine received a commission in the U.S. Public Health Service Commissioned Corps — which has over 10,000 personnel and has roots as deep as 1798 in the form of the Marine Hospital Fund — as a four-star admiral.

As a transgender woman, Levine was the first openly transgender person to receive a four-star commission and to be confirmed by the U.S. Senate in any capacity. As a former assistant secretary, her photo appears in a hallway of the HHS headquarters in Washington.

Recently, however, current HHS leadership changed the name on Levine’s portrait to her birth name. The message, of course, is that this name is her “real” name, while her chosen name is somehow inaccurate. Here’s how HHS spokesman Andrew Nixon put it: “Our priority is ensuring that the information presented internally and externally by HHS reflects gold standard science. We remain committed to reversing harmful policies enacted by Levine and ensuring that biological reality guides our approach to public health.”

Advertise with us

First of all, whether or not an administration agrees with the policies of predecessors should have no bearing on the basic markers of respect accorded to them. A similar incident occurred recently when President Donald Trump added a “Presidential Walk of Fame” to the White House, but replaced Mr. Biden’s photo with that of an “autopen,” a reference to the notion that the former president’s official enactments might not be legitimate.

This essential erasure of a predecessor, even if tongue-in-cheek, communicates contempt for in the passing-down of democratic authority that has marked American history for nearly 250 years.

Second, using a person’s legal name on an official portrait has nothing to do with “biological reality” whatsoever. A person can change his or her name for any number of reasons. For instance, should all official references to Vice President JD Vance actually read “James Donald Bowman,” which was his given name? If the administration wanted to make play with Levine’s legacy, they might change female pronouns to male ones, which would still be petty and mean-spirited, but at least would be related to its arguments about “biological reality.”

Changing Levine’s name, however, doesn’t even make a coherent political point: It’s simply personally cruel.

We don’t believe a majority of Americans voted for this. They might have disapproved, even quite severely, of the polices of the Biden administration and of Levine’s public health governance, but most people aren’t interested in personal, arbitrary, playground-bully-style reprisals. They voted for people other than Levine and thousands of other Biden officials to make policy, not for them to be publicly abused.

Advertise with us

Worse, this kind of pettiness denies the respect for the democratic process essential to a government intended to work through alternations of parties and office-holders. The people elected Trump's predecessors and the people will elect his successors, and their authority to do should not be demeaned by contemptuous gestures against an administration they elected. Respect, formal even if not sincere, to one's predecessors sustains this democratic continuity and resists the wild swings that worsen polarization.

Indeed, the more radically an administration wants to undo the policies of the previous one, the more careful it should be to make its arguments based on principles and to avoid personal pettiness. Ideas, after all, outlast personnel. Bullies might win a playground tussle, but arguments will win the future.