Pittsburgh City Council should quickly and unanimously pass Council President Daniel Lavelle’s “will of council” resolution calling on Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato to undertake a countywide property reassessment. It’s past time for more public officials and voices to support stabilizing the county’s taxation system.

The next three weeks will be the most important period of politics and policy in Pittsburgh in years. At the last possible moment, City Council is reckoning with the fiscal mismanagement of the Gainey administration — including formally rebuking the administration for its deceptive 2026 budget proposal and considering an eye-watering 30% tax hike proposed by Councilwoman Barb Warwick of Greenfield.

At the same time, Lavelle is rightly asking Council to address one of the underlying causes of the instability of public finances across Allegheny County: a long overdue reassessment.

The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has been raising the alarm on this crucial issue for nearly two years, but unfortunately few regional leaders have applied pressure to the Innamorato administration to call the assessment she campaigned on. We have said that the system’s instability will only worsen, with assessed values diverging further from market values and commercial real estate write-downs shifting the tax burden onto residential property owners.

Advertise with us

This, we argued, will lead to layers of tax hikes by all three taxing bodies — county (which hiked rates 36% last year), municipal and school district — from the North Hills to the South Hills, and from the west suburbs to the east.

This is exactly what is happening, and what Lavelle’s will-of-council resolution argues. We wish Pittsburgh’s city legislators had joined the fight before staring down the barrel of a major tax increase of its own, but late is better than never.

Residents around the county must understand that they are not immune. Especially communities with significant commercial real estate are seeing stagnating or dropping revenues even as the cost of providing services is increasing faster than inflation. This will result in many people seeing triplicate tax hikes.

To be clear: A reassessment is not a cure-all for sickly municipal finances. Generating new assessed values will neither increase nor decrease overall revenues, due to anti-windfall provisions in state law that require millage rates to be adjusted post-reassessment. (School districts are permitted to increase revenues by a marginal amount.) Generally speaking, long-time property-owners in hot real estate markets are likeliest to see the biggest tax increases, while long-time property-owners in stagnant real estate markets are likely to pay less in taxes.

What a reassessment will accomplish, however, is stabilize the tax system, specifically making future revenues more predictable. It would staunch the bleeding in commercial property revenues and reduce the need for municipalities and school districts to challenge the values of transferred properties — the so-called “newcomers tax.” In so doing, it would make further tax hikes less likely.

Advertise with us

Innamorato has indicated that she would like to call the reassessment only when certain guardrails are in place, specifically those that would protect low-income long-time homeowners from big tax increases. The problem is that she’s had nearly two years to put these guardrails in place, but has shown little urgency to do so.

All the while, she has fought attempts to trigger the process through the courts. All of which raises the question of how serious she really is about reassessment.

We hope that all nine councilmembers approve Lavelle’s will-of-council resolution, to send a united message down Grant Street. And we hope that other public leaders will find their voices to insist that the Innamorato administration fulfill its duty to administer a fair taxation system for Allegheny County.