One of the most serious crises facing the City of Pittsburgh is its aging fleet of city-owned vehicles, according to a startling report from City Controller Rachael Heisler. Chronic underfunding has left Pittsburgh with hundreds of overage and overused vehicles, from fire engines and ambulances to salt spreaders and dump trucks. The result is declining efficiency in delivering city services, including increasingly frequent and dangerous breakdowns of emergency vehicles.

The problem only compounds, both because older vehicles require more expensive maintenance and because the city is forced to pay third-party contractors in a pinch, especially for snow removal. In other words, stinginess in replacing vehicles only makes the fleet more expensive in the long run.

Indeed, an analysis of city capital spending on vehicles over the past two decades by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board shows that while the Gainey administration spent less per year (inflation adjusted) than its predecessors, underinvestment in vehicles is a long-term problem.

Solving it, therefore, will require creativity and patience. We have previously endorsed Ms. Heisler’s proposal for a fleet trust fund, filled by contributions from the city’s major nonprofits. But that won’t suffice: The city should also consider floating a bond to ensure its public services don’t further degrade.

Advertise with us

Growing crisis

As of June 11, according to Ms. Heisler’s report, the city had 1,339 “vehicle and equipment units” — that includes items such as Citiparks trailers used for outdoor movie nights — with 105 of them sitting around to be used for spare parts. Of those pieces of equipment, nearly one-half (49%) are beyond their expected life cycles.

The worst department by far is Emergency Medical Services, where 77% of ambulances are too old. This has interacted with a staffing crisis within EMS to hamper the city’s emergency medical response — all while making it more expensive, as the city relies on paying overtime and contracting with suburban agencies to supplement its efforts.

On multiple occasions in recent months, city ambulances have broken down on the way to an emergency, or with a patient inside. Just this week, in fact, WPXI’s Rick Earle reported that an ambulance became undrivable while responding to a stroke victim in Carrick.

A majority (58%) of the vehicles belonging to the Department of Public Works’ street division are also overage. Pittsburghers feel this most keenly in the wintertime, when the city’s response to snow events, which is already challenged by the city’s rugged topography, is even slower than usual. Ms. Heisler reports that from Jan. 2024 through the winter of 2025, the city spent over $350,000 on third-party rentals to supplement its snow clearance.

The problems are nearly as bad for police (49%) and fire (44%). It is important to note that fewer city vehicles are beyond their life cycles when measured by mileage versus age, but the report demonstrates that maintenance costs are dramatically higher for older vehicles, regardless of mileage.

Advertise with us

Chronic underinvestment

In order to understand the roots of the crisis, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board looked at the city’s capital budgets going back to the beginning of the Ravenstahl administration. For reference, the 2025 OMB analysis discussed in the Controller’s report estimates that the city needs to spend an average of $27.6 million over the next five years to get the fleet to a tolerable condition of 80% of vehicles within their life cycles, and $41.3 million per year to reach 100%.

Yet during Mayor Ed Gainey’s four years in office, including the proposed 2026 budget, his administration only budgeted about $7.4 million a year, in 2025 inflation-adjusted dollars, to acquire new vehicles. This includes using money set aside for the operation of the city’s parks to purchase vehicles for the DPW’s parks division, so the outlay of general-fund city resources was even lower.

However, it would be unfair to lay the underinvestment problem only at this mayor’s feet. During Bill Peduto’s eight years in office, the city budgeted an average of only $9.1 million (again, in 2025 dollars) — and it would have been lower than that were it not for an influx of federal pandemic relief funds the Peduto administration set aside for vehicles. As for the Ravenstahl administration, the inflation-adjusted average was $8.9 million per year.

In other words, today’s fleet crisis has been a long time coming.

Sustainable solution

And it will be impossible to solve in a timely manner. As we have described on numerous occasions, the city’s finances are broken and will require a combination of cutbacks and tax hikes to restore to health. Further, there’s the lead time for vehicle purchases: up to two years between order and delivery for complicated equipment such as fire engines.

Advertise with us

We have previously proposed negotiating a $20 million annual contribution from the city’s major nonprofits, while committing to a 50% match by the city to get to $30 million a year for vehicle purchases and maintenance. That both underestimated the costs of getting and keeping the fleet in good condition, and overestimated the city’s financial flexibility.

We now believe the solution must be two-fold: contributions from the nonprofits to a fleet trust fund, plus a one-time jump-start funded by a large bond.

Regarding the nonprofits, Pittsburgh is, admittedly, in a weak position. First, the city is negotiating from a position of need. Second, both eds and meds now find themselves in an uncertain financial situation, both due to market forces and the actions of the Trump administration regarding education and research funding. Still, once the fleet is stabilized, a shared contribution of $20 million should suffice for ongoing replacement costs.

Stabilizing the fleet is the hard part, and will require an enormous one-time spend. This is what bonds are for.

We are very hesitant to propose taking out new debt, but given manageable interest rates, the cost savings from having younger vehicles and the steep drop-off in the city’s expected debt service in 2027 and beyond, a bond would be a fiscally prudent choice. In fact, it’s the only way to stop treading water, and burning even more money.

The city’s vehicle fleet is the backbone of its ability to provide basic services. A sustainable solution for it must be a top priority.