On Tuesday, the Pittsburgh Public Schools Board of Directors is slated to vote on the “Future-Ready Facilities Plan” — that is, the complete reorganization of the district, including the closure of nine current school buildings. Yet, despite two years of preparations, what exactly the future holds for the city’s school district is cloudier than ever.

This is fundamentally due to a disconnect between the district’s insular leadership and the people of the city it serves, especially the parents of schoolchildren. While there is a large array of documents on the district’s website that describe the Future-Ready plan, and PPS leadership has held numerous public information sessions, very few community members feel well-informed about the ambitious reorganization. And many feel patronized by a process that never seemed to trust parents with enough information to allow them to engage in an informed way.

This has manifested, in particular, in the district’s standoffish approach to requests for information that go beyond its own curated presentations. In one case, in response to a parent’s request for detailed information about Future-Ready implementation, PPS appears to be skirting the state’s Right-to-Know Law (RTKL). Which raises the question of just how confident district leaders are in their own plans, and how much they trust the families they serve.

As a result, we fear that the implementation of the school-closure plan will alienate even more families than is typical for such ambitious reorganization programs. Specifically, we fear that the district’s struggles to generate public confidence will lead to an exodus of families who have other choices, such as private or charter schools. This could accelerate a death spiral of declining enrollments: PPS cannot survive if it only serves families who have no other options.

Advertise with us

Hiding the ball

Armin Schikorra of Squirrel Hill is a professor of mathematics at the University of Pittsburgh and the father of two PPS students. For several months, he has sought key information about how PPS developed the Future-Ready Facilities Plan, and about the details of its implementation.

Most recently, on Oct. 31, Mr. Schikorra sent to PPS three requests for public information under the RTKL. The first requested internal documents related to the provision of world language teachers after reorganization; the second asked for detailed information about the financial and demographic assumptions and methodologies that went into the plan; and the third requested information about the new transportation scheme, especially regarding plans for student safety.

Five business days later — the maximum allowed by law — the district denied these requests on the basis that Mr. Schikorra failed to use the official PPS form. But the official who responded accidentally left unredacted an internal email from one of the district’s attorneys, which read, “Can you calendar and add a note in the excel spreadsheet to deny this [because] it is not on the RTK form. This is the 3rd submission from Schikorra today.”

There are several problems here. First, in this context “calendar” almost certainly means to wait to deny the request until the five-day clock is about to run out. In other words, PPS knew immediately it would deny Mr. Schikorra’s request, but still waited five days — in effect, slowing his ability to respond.

Second, while the state Office of Open Records (OOR) does indicate that a government or agency may require the use of a particular form, it specifies that “an agency must first have a publicly posted policy requiring the use” of such a form. While PPS does have a detailed public records policy on its website, nowhere does it explicitly require the use of any particular form.

Advertise with us

Third, whether it is the first, third or thirtieth request from the same person on the same day has no bearing on the district’s obligation to respond in good faith. We believe this note would be strong evidence for a finding of bad faith by the OOR.

Lack of trust

Mr. Schikorra has since resubmitted his requests with identical language on the proper form, and the district has asserted its right to take a full 30 days to respond. (This is, frustratingly, standard practice across the commonwealth.) Of course, this delay will ensure that whatever information PPS ultimately supplies will not be public until after Tuesday’s scheduled board vote on the Future-Ready plan.

This episode is emblematic of an insular and suspicious culture at PPS, one experienced by numerous parents who have questioned aspects of the reorganization and the process that led to it. Remarkably, district leaders were prepared to approve the Future-Ready plan a full 12 months ago, but held it for further refinements and public engagement. Yet few parents feel more informed, and much information — such as that requested by Mr. Schikorra — remains under lock and key.

Indeed, Mr. Schikorra submitted his public-records requests shortly after an Oct. 20 meeting where the final and full details of the proposal were supposed to be laid out for community members. Yet he, like many others, left feeling shortchanged: The final implementation document was impressively designed, but once again failed to include information on the data, methodologies and assumptions that underlaid its conclusions.

The implication is that PPS was asking, or rather telling, parents: Just trust us. The problem is that too few parents do.

Advertise with us

Which future?

The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has called for PPS facility consolidation for years, and we celebrated Superintendent Wayne Walters’ boldness when he announced what became the Future-Ready plan over two years ago. We were, and remain, keenly aware of how sensitive and difficult this process is. But also necessary: The district cannot justify its current footprint, given demographic reality.

Yet the process has laid bare structural challenges within PPS, specifically its insular and defensive culture, which leads to strained and suspicious relationships with the very people it serves.

After two years, the board must finally decide on the Future-Ready plan before the end of the (calendar and fiscal) year. But it is not obligated to decide, and should not decide, on Tuesday. This would allow one last chance for more information to be released, and trust to be built.

Because without serious changes within the district’s institutional culture, Future-Ready or not, there’s little hope the future of PPS — or of Pittsburgh — will be bright.