The exorbitantly expensive “community engagement” for the City of Pittsburgh’s comprehensive plan is, predictably, an unaccountable shambles. Pittsburgh residents deserve answers about where $2.6 million in taxpayer money has actually gone — because it clearly hasn’t been used effectively to educate Pittsburghers about the plan that could frame and direct the city’s development for a generation.
Take the Pittsburgh 2050 website, which is nicely designed but lays bare the project’s shortcomings. The site lists four “upcoming events” where residents can discuss “different possibilities for how Pittsburgh could grow and change in the years ahead.” The dates of those events are Oct. 22, Oct. 23, Oct. 29 and Nov. 1. Today is Nov. 13.
Broken engagement
Then there are the numbers. With the last public phase of the process winding down, an initiative that cost nearly $10 per Pittsburgher estimates that only about half of city residents were even exposed to the planning process. And of those 168,000 people, 139,000 (83%) were only exposed to it through social media advertising or mass emails.
But what about deeper engagement? Pittsburgh 2050 estimates that about 30,000 city residents were “engaged” during the process. This means anyone who participated by “attending a community event or meeting, submitting a comment via email or social media, or responding to a survey.” Each of these meager data points — which likely include numerous duplications or triplications of the same people — cost the city about $100 each.
The Pittsburgh 2050 effort did participate in several dozen events around the city, where organizers set up tables at neighborhood festivals or presented at community meetings. This allowed comp plan representatives to meet people who were just out and about, rather than holding events that would be likely to attract only the usual suspects. This was not an unreasonable approach.
However, at a City Council meeting this Monday, Councilwoman Barb Warwick — one of the Gainey administration’s and the comp plan’s biggest supporters — observed that during the events she observed in her district, the personnel were typically employees of the Department of City Planning. Which raises the question: Where were the people Pittsburgh paid to undertake this effort?
Where did the $2.6 million really go?
Follow the money
Nearly two years ago, when Mayor Ed Gainey proposed the comprehensive plan, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board argued that $3.5 million for the technical work — that is, the preparation of the plan itself —was pricey but not unreasonable, but $2.6 million for engagement was wildly out of keeping with similar projects.
Worse, the way the funds were divvied up gave the appearance of self-dealing on several fronts. About $70,000, for instance, was earmarked for an employee of the UrbanKind Institute, whose director, Jamil Bey, was announced as City Planning director just weeks later. The nonprofit organization 1Hood Media received funding as an “identity expert” after its political affiliate, 1Hood Power, supported Mr. Gainey’s 2021 campaign. The group was also among the most active supporters of the mayor’s re-election.
And then about $700,000 was set aside for the main vendor, Common Cause Consultants, to simply give away to community organizations and individuals to compensate them for engaging with the process.
Before City Council passed the appropriation we warned that it “certainly looks like it could be abused as unaccountable walking-around money for friends and allies.” We are relieved that the Pittsburgh 2050 website includes several dozen “mini-grant” recipients, so Pittsburghers can have some sense of where their money went.
Yet the number of reported “mini-grants” still implies that each one totaled more than $10,000, which is an absurd sum simply to participate in an event, and only bolsters our suspicions. There must be a full public accounting in the weeks and months to come.
Planning the future
From the beginning, we warned that “the plan mustn’t be a vanity project to bake a single mayor’s priorities into the next 25 years of city governance.” There’s little evidence in the community engagement initiative to dissuade Pittsburghers from concluding it was primarily meant to manufacture a consensus around those priorities.
And so with Mr. Gainey’s term in office soon to come to an end, what should happen to Pittsburgh 2050?
First, the use of public funds, especially for “community engagement,” must be accounted for. City Controller Rachael Heisler’s office should perform a full audit of comp-plan spending and produce a public report that shows Pittsburghers where their money went, especially the “mini-grants.”
For his part, Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor should approach City Council to seek to claw back any unexpended funds from the original $2.6 million appropriation. In doing so, he could make it a little less of a boondoggle.
Second, Mr. O’Connor should direct the technical aspects of the comprehensive plan to their conclusion. While on the pricey side, comprehensive plans are fixtures of modern governance that are essential, for instance, to unlocking some public and private grants. We expect the plan, which will provide interesting insights in itself, will also pay for itself.
Mr. O’Connor and his team should also feel free to place their stamp on the plan. In fact, it would only make the comp plan a more compelling and complete document if it included the insights and priorities of two successive mayors, rather than just reflecting those of one administration. The voters spoke in 2021, and in a different way in 2025, so a Pittsburgh 2050 plan should reflect both of those choices.
Third, especially under the circumstances described above, the comprehensive plan should be understood by city officials, and the public, as a way to inform, and not to direct, Pittsburgh’s development going forward. This is a time of great change in the city and the world, and it won’t do to lock Pittsburgh into a single framework for the next two and a half decades.
As predicted, the plan’s “community engagement” was an expensive mess of ineffectiveness and self-dealing, which must be scrutinized by city authorities. But the plan that emerges could still have value for the city and its people.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.