All bridges are not created equal. A pair of appeals for state funds to support bridge projects — one by a national sports association and another by a local economic development organization — exemplify bad and good uses of state community investment dollars.

The first proposal has been made by the United States Golf Association (USGA), for $5 million in state funds to help build a third pedestrian bridge over the Turnpike between the two halves of Oakmont Country Club. It is, on its face, brazen and ridiculous to ask Pennsylvania taxpayers to fund an improvement at one of the most prestigious private golf clubs in America.

This isn’t to say that the project would have no public benefit. Around 200,000 people attended the U.S. Open at Oakmont this year, and almost all of them passed across one of two narrow bridges between holes 2 through 8 and the rest of the course. The second bridge was built in 2003 because of bottlenecks during the 1994 event that caused the USGA to pause holding major tournaments at the Allegheny Valley course.

While the USGA has committed to hosting five majors (three men’s and two women’s U.S. Opens) at Oakmont over the next 25 years, the funding request appears to indicate concern about crowd control moving forward. These tournaments are among the most important special events for the Pittsburgh region — an entire week not only of huge crowds from all over the country, but also of business opportunities, as national and international executives converge on the swanky hospitality tents.

Advertise with us

Five million dollars in state money to keep major tournaments are Oakmont wouldn’t be a bad investment. The problem is twofold: Clearly USGA and Oakmont stakeholders could fund the bridge themselves; and there are much better uses for limited state economic development dollars.

These include the second bridge project proposal just released: rehabilitating the Carrie Furnace Hot Metal Bridge to accommodate bike and pedestrian traffic across the Monongahela River. This application is sponsored by the Redevelopment Authority of Allegheny County (RAAC) and asks for $4 million to help pay for paving over the surface of a bridge that for decades carried railcars of molten metal between the Carrie Furnace in Rankin and the Homestead Works — now home to the sprawling Waterfront mixed use development, which would also stand to benefit.

The bridge is owned by the Rivers of Steel Heritage Corporation, which preserves the steelmaking legacy of the Mon Valley as part of a National Heritage Area. Bringing the span back online would connect the tremendous Carrie Furnace site on the north side of the Mon with the Three Rivers Heritage Trail (part of the Great Allegheny Passage Trail) on the south side. In other words, it’s a key missing link that would bring new life to a classic piece of steelmaking infrastructure, while making the Mon Valley’s steel sites more connected and accessible to locals and tourists alike.

We strongly support this bid for funds from the state’s Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program (RACP). In fact, it’s exactly the kind of project these resources are meant to support: projects with clear public benefits and positive economic knock-on effects that need a little help to get across the finish line.

There’s only so many RACP funds available in any given round of awards. The Carrie Furnace Hot Metal Bridge deserves must stronger consideration than the Oakmont County Club bridge. Surely there’s a needier and worthier project on which to spend those $5 million.