The primary reason the federal government remains shut down, and the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania does not yet have a budget, is that the cost of the impasses do not yet outweigh the perceived benefits to legislators of keeping them going. But there’s a very simple way of adjusting the calculus in favor of getting deals done: forcing legislators to experience the pain they’re imposing on others, by denying them their salaries during the shutdowns.
Sure, both sides at both levels of government claim the shutdown is a matter of principle — Senate Republicans in Harrisburg point to the state’s structural deficit, for instance, while Senate Democrats in Washington point to expiring Obamacare subsidies. While these are certainly part of the motivation for their actions (or inaction), at its base the dysfunction is the result of a political calculation that each side stands to lose more by reaching an agreement than by refusing to compromise.
In Pennsylvania, this is in part because several recent court decisions have required the commonwealth to continue to fund many government functions during an impasse. This has limited the pain felt by everyday Pennsylvanians, reducing the political pressure to get a deal done.
But as reserves begin to run out in county governments, school districts and non-profits dependent on state funds, the consequences of the dysfunction will become more apparent to more people. Pittsburgh Public Schools, for instance, is canceling some field trips, denying students opportunities for enrichment. This may seem like a small thing, but for many families it’s their first personal experiences of the effects of the impasse.
And it certainly looks like Harrisburg politicians are favoring political brinksmanship over the good of Pennsylvania’s children. All while drawing a paycheck they’re denying to many state-funded organizations.
A similar process is occurring at the national level. While the effects of the shutdown have in some respects been muted (unless you had planned a visit to a National Park Service unit), guidance from the Department of Agriculture is now indicating that the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) — that is, food stamps — will not have enough funds to fulfill its obligations beginning in November. Eventually, the political cost of the pain imposed on the American people will overcome the perceived benefits to the legislators who can’t, or won’t, make a deal.
Denying legislators their own paychecks would ensure that the tipping point comes much sooner — or, ideally, would dissuade lawmakers from closing the government altogether. Even those legislators who don’t need the paycheck — that is, those who are wealthy by other means — would notice its absence, and would experience pressure from their fellow members whose families couldn’t afford to go weeks or months without pay.
Just like the thousands upon thousands of government workers and employees of state-funded organizations who are raiding their savings to stay afloat right now.
It should be clear to state and federal lawmakers that closing the government isn’t just another bargaining chip or negotiating tactic among many: It’s a failure to govern. That is, it’s a failure to do their job properly, for which there must be consequences beyond the political. That means experiencing some personal hardship themselves, as they’ve shown themselves so willing to impose on others.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.