This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city, and southwestern Pennsylvania more generally, during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.
In almost every one of Allegheny County’s 130 municipalities, police make up by far the biggest line item in the annual budget. With over 100 independent police departments serving 1.25 million people, law enforcement fragmentation is the most visible and most expensive consequence of the county’s extreme governmental complexity.
Fixing this legacy system should be one of the most urgent tasks for the reigon’s leaders. This is especially the case right now, as property tax increases ripple through the system at the county, municipal and school district levels due to stagnant growth and a broken property assessment and taxation system.
Tinkering will not solve Allegheny County’s structural problems.
We believe a variety of options should be on the table, beginning with a proven concept: regional police departments that spread out costs without reducing service. But we also believe municipal and county officials should study a more radical solution: folding most or all policing into an expanded Allegheny County Police Department.
Costly cops
In 2016, then-Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner released a report on policing in Allegheny County. At the time, the county had 108 police departments, and among the roughly 60% of municipalities that responded to her office’s queries spending on police averaged $222 per resident.
Since then, Forward Township has disbanded its police department and joined forces with Elizabeth Township, while Rankin, Braddock, North Braddock and East Pittsburgh have formed the Eastern Regional Mon Valley Police Department. That means we’re down to 104 bureaus.
Meanwhile, the cost of policing has only gone up. In 2016, the eastern suburban borough of Churchill reported spending $408 per person on policing, among the most in the county. In 2025, that’s up to $500 per person, and the 3,000-person borough’s cops cost half its operating budget.
A Post-Gazette Editorial Board analysis of several municipal budgets from all over the county reveals that policing typically costs around a third of municipal operating budgets. As a general rule, smaller communities pay more for policing both as a percent of their budgets and per capita. Leet Township in the Ohio Valley spends 36% of its budget and $500 per person to police a community of 1,600 people. Mt. Lebanon, 20 times larger, uses 22% of its budget at $275 per person.
But what distinguishes some of the most cost-effective police forces in the county isn’t the size of the municipality — it’s shared services.
Savings in numbers
The Northern Regional Police Department covers Marshall, Pine and Richland townships, along with Bradford Woods Borough, and it’s the best deal in the county. The three townships pitch in proportionate to the number of calls that come from each, while tiny Bradford Woods pays a flat 4% of the department’s costs. These growing communities, which together include about 40,000 people, pay under $200 per person for policing.
Compare that to $400 in the City of Pittsburgh. Or, even better, to the geographically and socioeconomically similar Upper St. Clair, whose police force costs its 21,000 residents over $300 per person — over 50% more than Northern Regional.
These combined police departments should be much more common. Besides being costly, small departments serving small (and often shrinking) communities struggle with training and keeping up with best practices and equipment. The scale provided by combined departments allows for more efficient administration, including handling matters such as collective bargaining agreements, while sacrificing little in terms of community connection to its law enforcement officers.
County Executive Sara Innamorato should take a leading role in convening local leaders and encouraging these arrangements. Waiting for grassroots momentum will take far too long, and municipal leaders are likely to hesitate out of deference to their communities’ attachment to legacy police departments. Further, piling together several departments already in crisis — as with the Eastern Regional Mon Valley Police Department — has limited benefits compared to more strategic combinations, which require regional thinking and regional leaders to make happen.
We propose a regional policing commission, comprised of representatives of a variety of municipal departments along with the Allegheny County Police, Sheriff’s Office and District Attorney’s Office.
Going all the way
There is a more radical solution to be considered: Allegheny County offers to expand its police force to provide coverage for any municipality that disbands its force. It would work toward a county-wide system with police “zones” and strategically placed stations around the county to ensure consistent coverage and fast response.
Existing officers would be given a chance, though not a guarantee, to join the county force and serve the areas they're now serving.
County taxes would rise to pay for the service — but, in theory, not as much as municipal taxes would drop in communities that disbanded their departments. If people see the financial benefit and find the policing satisfactory, more communities would eventually join. Communities would undoubtedly lose the benefits that come from being guaranteed to have law enforcement entirely committed to their local area. Bigger communities may find centralization an advantage, and smaller communities with less professional service and under financial strain may find it a fiscal lifesaver.
There are numerous hurdles such a system would have to clear, most obviously ensuring every corner of the 730-square-mile county is well-served, and specifically that city concerns don’t come to dominate suburban and rural ones. The county will have to guarantee that it will be adequately funded. Many communities may not want to take the risk and may continue to prefer paying for their own police officers.
Regional policing offers clear advantages over the present system, but a radical solution should be studied closely, because it may be what’s really needed. Allegheny County and local leadership must think outside the box to solve one of the Pittsburgh region’s biggest challenges.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.